Analysis of contributions in 'Annals of Library and Information Studies'

Transcription

1 Annals of Library and Information Studies Vol. 4, June 2007, pp. 06- Analysis of contributions in 'Annals of Library and Information Studies' Neerja Verma', Rajnish Tamrakar"and Priyanka Sharmab Department of Library & Information Science, M.L.B. Govt. College of Excellence, Gwalior, Madhya Pradesh, India, b This paper deals with the analysis of the contributions of the journal entitled' Annals of Library & Information Studies' published during It examines yearwise, institutionswise, statewise distribution of contributions, authorship pattern, citation analysis, length of the contributions etc. The study shows that most of the contributions of this journal are contributed by single author and statewise distribution shows that most of the contributions are contributed from New Delhi. Citation analysis of 46 citations includes to find out average number of citations per contribution, types of publications cited and preparing of ranked list of cited journals in contributions of this journal. The study reveals that journals are the most cited publication amongst the library and information scientists and the source journal i.e. Annals of Library and Information Studies is the most cited journal in the contributions of this journal. Introduction Annals of Library and Information Studies, earlier published as Annals of Library Science and Documentation is a well known journal in the field of library and information science published from India. It covers articles, documentation notes and research reviews on library, documentation and information science, information systems, services and products, information technology, information users, bibliometrics, scientometrics and informetrics, education and training and other related areas. It is a quarterly journal, published by the National Institute of Science Communication and Information Resources (NISCAIR), New Delhi. There are several studies by different authors analyzing the contributions (with and without citation analysis) of different journals of various fields. Thate and Mishral, Tiew2, Vij and Bedi, Dutta and Sen4., Das6, Dhiman7, Sivasubramanian8 9 and Hazarika, Goswami and DaslO have studied the contributions of different journals related to agriculture, defence science, physics, botany and mathematics. As far as journals of library science are concerned, a few studies related to analysis of contributions of ILA Bulletinll, Library Herald2 and IASLIC Bulletin' by the corresponding author of this paper are also available. A study related to citation analysis of Annals of Library Science and Documentation by Mete and Deshmukhl4 is also available. The present study is related to analysis of contributions of Annals of Library and Information Studies from 999 to 200. Objectives of the study To examine authorship pattern, year-wise, institution-wise and geographical distribution of contributions of the journal; To examine the average length of articles and average number of citations per article in the journal; To study the types of publications cited in the contributions of the journal; and To prepare ranked list from journals cited in the contributions of the journal. Methodology For the purpose of this study, the journal Annals of Library and Information Studies (ALIS) has been selected as the source journal. Twenty eight issues of seven volumes from 999 to 200 have been selected for the study. Out of the seven volumes, two volumes, i.e., volume of years 999 and 2000 are entitled "Annals of Library Science and Documentation (ALSD). Information about each contribution such as author, author's affiliation, length of contributions, citations, " I If III il j II,j,

2 VERMA et al: ANALYSIS OF CONTRIBUTIONS IN 'ANNALS OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION STUDIES' 07 Three Two More One authors% than % three% Vol No.ofIssue % Total of Contribution no. % of age contributions 00 Table -Percent Yearwise distribution of articles uthor(s) tions(volumewise) etc., was scanned, checked and examined carefully. Short communications are also included for the study. Analysis and findings Year-wise distribution A total of contributions have been published in seven years ( ), which consists of full articles, review articles and short communications. Table gives details regarding the distribution of contributions published from Maximum number of articles i.e., 2 (7.6 %) was published in 200 and minimum number of contributions i.e., 6 (2.2%) in 999. Authorship pattern of contributions Table 2 gives the details about the authorship pattern. A total of 47 contributions (.88%) out of have been contributed by single author, 60 contributions (4.80%) by two authors and 2 contributions (6.0 %) by three authors and contributions (02.29%) by more than three authors. Authorship pattern of contributions (volume-wise) Table gives authorship pattern of contributions voumewise. It indicates that out of the 47 contributions of single author, volumes 46 and 2 has the highest number i.e., 9 (9.4%) and vol. 48 have the lowest number i.e. (06.8%) contributions. Out of the 60

3 " 08 ANN. LIB. INF. STU., JUNE 2007 Table 4 - Institutionwise distribution of contributions Contributed by Percent No. of contributions contributions by two authors, vol. 48 has the highest i.e. 2 (20.00%) and vol. 46 has the lowest number i.e., 4 (06.67%) contributions. Out of the 2 contributions by three authors, vol. and 2 has the highest i.e. (2.80%) and vol. 47 has the lowest number i.e., (04.77%) contributions. Out of contributions by more than three authors volumes 49, and 2 have one each. Institutionwise distribution of contributions Table - Statewise distribution of contributions Table 4 gives institutionwise distribution of contributions of this journal. Out of contributions, the highest number, i.e., 8 (6.8%) has been contributed by academic/ research institutions and lowest number, i.e., (.82%) has been contributed by information/ documentation centres. Name of state New Delhi Karnatka Maharastra West Bangal Uttranchal Uttarpradesh Kerala Andhra Pradesh Madhya Pradesh Tamilnadu Orissa Assam Haryana Rajasthan Manipur Punjab lharkhand Chattisgarh Foreign Countries Total No. of contributions % age Statewise distribution Table gives the statewise distribution of contributions in the seven volumes of the journal. Out of contributions, the highest number, i.e., 29 (22.%) has been contributed by authors in New Delhi and lowest number i.e., (%) has been contributed by authors from Manipur, Punjab, Jharkhand and Chattisgarh each. Out of contributions only contributions are from two foreign countries i.e., Nigeria and Nepal. Length of articles Study of citations of contributions Table 6 indicates the details about the page length of the contributions. Out of contributions, 8 contributions (29.00%) have page length of - pages while 67 contributions (.%) have length of 6-0 pages. There is only one contribution that has page length between 26-0 pages i.e., (0%). Table 7 reveals the details of number of citations appearing at the end of contributions during Table 6 - Length of articles Total 79II I No. of pages %age I 62 I I ;j I

4 VERMA et al: ANALYSIS OF CONTRIBUTIONS IN 'ANNALS OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION STUDIES' 09 ions ed Cumulative Total Year %age Years No % Issue age % Citations Issues 4age No % age No of Table citations 7 - Study of citations Committee) Nil

5 0 Annals SRELS Herald Nature Indian Science DESIDOC Malaysian ILA Scientometrics IASLIC Name Bulletin Cumulative Journal of Science Trends Library American journal Marketing 66 Journal the Bulletin Documentation Processing %age Library American with % Information, Science age of JUNE Society areview Library I.T. Slant Society Management 2007 for & Library Doc. Information Studies Information & ANN. Society0 No LIB. 9 Annual Aslib Journal 0 Engineering IAALD Computers Special International MIS Libri Kelpro Federal Information Lucknow Library College Research CLIR Current The 98 Titles Quarterly Proceedings Issues Bulletin Review Libraries Herald & 6.49 of Register Contents with 00 Librarian Evaluation Research Information Academic Scientific Development Technology Today of 8.78 citations 00 Bulletin Journal and Libraries & Librarianship Industrial Science Tomorrow & each & of Libraries Library Scientometrics 4 Science Research Review & of INF. STD., Information Science & Technology Informetrics & Technology Studies - Ranked list of cited journals i' 'I I " I II' II

6 VERMA et al: ANALYSIS OF CONTRIBUTIONS IN 'ANNALS OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION STUDIES' Out of contributions published, 4 contributions have no citation. The highest number of contributions with citation between -0 is 8 (64.89%) and lowest number of contributions with citation between 8-90 is (%). Distribution of citations Table 8 indicates that the 7 volumes have 46 citations appended to the articles. Out of 46 citations, vol. 2 has the highest number i.e., (22.78%) and vol. 47 has the lowest number i.e. (0.40%). Types of publication cited Table 9 indicates that out of 46 citations, 684 (46.97%) are the journal citations and 09 (2.22%) are book citations. Ranked list of cited journals Ranked list of journals helps in selecting the journals for acquisition in different libraries as the list shows the journals of maximum utility amongst the users. There are 46 titles of journals in Table 0 arranged according to their ranks. It can be seen from the ranked list that Annals of Library and Information Studies occupied first rank with 88 citations (2.87%), second rank occupied by Scientometrics with 78 citations (.40%). This is followed by IASLIC Bulletin with 4 citations (6.8%). Conclusion The analysis shows that majority of the articles in the journal are two-authored and majority of the contributions are from New Delhi, the place of publication of Annals of Library and Information Studies. With regard to the citations, 8 contributions have up to 0 citations. Study of citations showed that Annals of Library and Information Studies received the highest number of citations, followed by Scientometrics and IASLIC Bulletin. Earlier studies on Annals of Library Science and Documentation, IASLIC Bulletin and ILA Bulletin showed that the Annals topped the list of highly cited journal and a citation analysis study of Library Herald showed that Annals ranked second on the list of highly cited journalll 4. The present study shows that Annals of Library Science and Documentation that has been rechristened Annals of Library and Information Studies continues to be a prominent Indian library and information science journal. References. Thate R K and Mishra S, Periodicals cited most frequently by Indian agricultural economists, lla Bulletin, 26 () (990) Tiew W S, Journal of natural rubber research : A ten year bibliometric study, IASLIC Bulletin, 4 (2) (998) Vij Rand Bedi D S, Defence science journal: A ten year bibliometric study. lla Bulletin, 4 (-4) (998-99) Dutta Band Sen B K, Indian journal of pure and applied physics: An analysis of citation pattern, lla Bulletin, 6 () (2000) Dutta Band Sen B K, Indian journal of pure and applied mathematics: An analysis of citation pattern, IASLIC Bulletin, 46 (4) (200) Das A, Bibliometric analysis of publications in plasma physics contributed by the scientists at the institute for plasma research, IASLIC Bulletin, 4 (4) (2000) Dhiman A K, Ethnobotany journal: A ten year bibliometric study, IASLIC Bulletin, 4 (4) (2000) Sivasubramanian V, Journal of Indian coffee: a bibliometric study, Annals of Library Science and Documentation, 47 (2) (2000) Sivasubramanium V, Journal of planters chronicle: A bibliometric study, IASLIC Bulletin, 48 (2) (200) Hazarika T, Goswami K and Das P, Bibliometric analysis of Indian forester: , IASLIC Bulletin, 48 (4) (200) Verma N, Analysis of contributions of ILA Bulletin, ILA Bulletin, 0 (-4) (994-9) Verma N, Analysis of contributions of library herald, Library Herald, 9 (-2) (200) Verma N,Analysis of contributions ofiaslic Bulletin, IASLIC Bulletin, 49 (2) (2004) Mete M V and Deshmukh P P, Citation analysis of annals of library science and documentation, Annals of Library Science and Documentation, 4 () (996) -2.