Medicinski časopisi u otvorenom pristupu: iskorak ili privilegij?

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Medicinski časopisi u otvorenom pristupu: iskorak ili privilegij?"

Pierce Harrington
5 years ago
Views:

1 Medicinski časopisi u otvorenom pristupu: iskorak ili privilegij? Mario Habek Referentni centar za demijelinizacijske bolesti Klinika za neurologiju KBC Zagreb Medicinski fakultet u Zagrebu

2 The future of publishing nature.com

3 Tradicija / OA Shidham et al, EMBO reports, 2006.

4 Tradicija / OA Dobitnik Nobelove za medicinu i fiziologiju 2013 Dr. Randy Schekman...open access journals are superior to traditional scientific journals because they are not concerned with the selling of expensive subscriptions and can accept all papers that meet quality standards, with no artificial caps.... called on scientists to no longer publish in luxury high-impact journals, and instead to publish in openaccess journals. The Guardian, UK

5 Tradicija / OA Grant N. Pierce, Can J Physiol Pharmacol, Editor I see more poorly written papers published in a plethora of new, open-access journals than anywhere else. I can only conclude that openaccess journals have done more to compromise peer review in the last 5 years than anything else I can think of. This will ultimately challenge the validity of published scientific data in ways that are alarming to me. Solomon, PeerJ, 2014

6 Tradicija / OA Rast troškova procesuiranja radova Promjena načina financiranja pretplata čitatelj (institucija) APC (article processing charges) autor (institucija, izvor financiranja) Solomon, PeerJ, 2014

7 Kome dati prednost? Utvrditi obilježja autora megajournala Koju vrstu radova šalju? Koji čimbenici utječu na odluku u koji časopis poslati rad? Izvor financiranja za APC ili druge troškove? Koja je vjerojatnost da će isti autor poslati novi rad u isti časopis? BMJ Open, PeerJ, PLOS ONE ili SAGE Open Solomon, PeerJ, 2014

8 Rezultati Financiranje iz grantova PLOS ONE 50% BMJ Open i PeerJ 33% SAGE Open 10 % Samofinanciranje SAGE Open 60% PeerJ 32% Solomon, PeerJ, 2014

9 Rezultati Čimbenici koji utječu na odluku autora o odabiru časopisa postaju prvenstveno izvor financiranja te svota koju autori imaju za plaćanje APC-a Solomon, PeerJ, 2014

10 Rezultati Solomon, PeerJ, 2014

11 Rezultati Solomon, PeerJ, 2014

12 Rezultati Solomon, PeerJ, 2014

13 Odakle su autori koji objavljuju u OA časopisima? USA 25% UK i Australija BMJ Open HRV, BiH, SRB, SLO, MNE, HUN 0 radova Austrija 1 rad Italija 21 rad

14 Samo 6% istraživača ima sredstva koja im omogućuju OA publikaciju istraživanja

16 Opening up... Higher Education Funding Council for England (HEFCE) znanstvnici bi trebali arhivirati svoje radove u online repozitorijima odmah nakon prihvaćanja za objavljivanje period od 1 godine je prihvatljiv u znanosti, a 2 godine za društvene znanosti i umjetnost prije no što postane javno dostupan

17 Opening up... Jeffrey Beall otkriva potencijalno shady practices u OA časopisima

18 Lista časopisa Year Number of predatory publishers

21 nature.com

22 Kako provjeriti pouzdanost izdavača? Check that the publisher provides full, verifiable contact information, including address, on the journal site. be cautious of those that provide only web contact forms Check that a journal's editorial board lists recognized experts with full affiliations contact some of them and ask about their experience with the journal or publisher Check that the journal prominently displays its policy for author fees Be wary of invitations to submit to journals or to become editorial board members Read some of the journal's published articles and assess their quality contact past authors to ask about their experience Check that a journal's peer-review process is clearly described try to confirm that a claimed impact factor is correct Find out whether the journal is a member of an industry association that vets its members, such as the Directory of Open Access Journal or the Open Access Sholarly Publishers Association Use common sense, as you would when shopping online if something looks fishy, proceed with caution nature.com

24 Moja iskustva s OA...kao autor Apr 1, 2014 All manuscripts submitted by Non- Members of the Japanese Society of Internal Medicine are subject to a publication processing fee upon acceptance for publication. The society now plans to implement the fee. Further details will be announced.

25 Moja iskustva s OA...kao reviewer

26 Moja iskustva s OA...kao reviewer

27 Gold or green: which is the best shade of open access?

28 Zaključak Home About Browse Advanced Search Help Upute Login Create Account Search Welcome to Repozitorij Medicinskog fakulteta Sveučilišta u Zagrebu University of Zagreb Medical School Repository is a database of published material by members of the Medical School, including peer-reviewed journal articles, published conference papers, books and book chapters. Database includes also PhD thesis awarded by the School. The full text of these publications is made freely available where posible. The repository is compliant with Open Access Initiative protocols and can be searched using a variety of web-based tools. Please see the Contact Information for more information about the Repository. Repozitorij Medicinskog fakulteta Sveučilišta u Zagrebu sadržavat će digitalni oblik cjelovitih tekstova objavljenih radova djelatnika Medicinskog fakulteta i to poglavito radova objavljenih u znanstvenim časopisima. U repozitorij će se pohranjivati i cjeloviti tekstovi recenziranih priopćenja objavljenih u kongresnim zbornicima te knjige i poglavlja u knjigama. Repozitorij će također sadržavati i cjelovite tekstove doktorskih radnji obranjenih na Medicinskom fakultetu. Repozitorij se pridržava protokola OAI i može mu se pristupiti na različite načine. Za sve informacije pogledajte Contact Information. Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0 Latest Additions View items added to the repository in the past week. Search Repository Search the repository using a full range of fields. Use the search field at the top of the page for a quick search.

A) Instructions for preparing original articles Krajnji rok za prihvaćanje radova i sažetaka je godine.

A) Instructions for preparing original articles Krajnji rok za prihvaćanje radova i sažetaka je 15.05.2018. godine. Signa Vitae Journal publishes papers covering adult, pediatric and neonatal intensive