Economic Issues in Spectrum Utilization
|
|
- Randolph Pierce
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Page 1 of 9 Economic Issues in Spectrum Utilization Thomas W. Hazlett 1 George Mason University Arlington Economics, LLC 2 Feb. 24, 2011 The modern era in spectrum allocation began with cellular telephone licenses in the 1980s. Up until that point, regulators controlled virtually all dimensions of spectrum access. Licenses were exceedingly narrow, prescribing what services wireless operators could supply and precisely how they could supply them. Micro-managing the emerging mobile networks proved impractical, however. In Canada and, indeed, around the globe, regulators thus departed from traditional models and crafted new authorizations ceding far broader discretion over how radio waves were to be utilized. Instead of mapping out just where cellular base stations could be placed, as with broadcasting stations, or how much power transmitters (or devices) could emit, as with most every other radio service, licensing authorities delegated broad decisionmaking to markets. With multiple wireless suppliers authorized, competitive rivalry replaced bureaucratic mandates. The result has been extraordinarily beneficial. Mobile networks have been efficiently planned, organized, constructed, expanded, upgraded and upgraded again and again. Millions of consumers share the airwaves licensed to operators; each subscriber enjoys the use of the spectrum, and network infrastructure, controlled and optimized by the service provider. This has enabled a mass market in mobile services. 1 Professor of Law & Economics, George Mason University, USA, and Managing Director of Arlington Economics, LLC. He has previously held faculty positions at the University of California, Davis, the Wharton School, and the Columbia Institute for Tele-Information, and served as Chief Economist of the Federal Communications Commission. He publishes widely in law reviews and economics journals, specializing in telecommunications policy and issues relating to radio spectrum allocation. He is also a columnist for the Financial Times New Technology Policy Forum. Dr. Hazlett thanks Anil Caliskan, Ph.D. and Ralitza Grigorova, J.D., both of Arlington Economics, for assistance in the preparation of this paper. He gratefully acknowledges the support of Bell Canada. The analysis and views expressed are entirely his own. Comments may be directed to him at twhazlett@gmail.com. 2 See
2 T.W. Hazlett Economic Issues in Spectrum Utilization 2 Page 2 of 9 Competition among rival networks has constrained prices, pushing them sufficiently low as to create widespread substitution of minutes of conversation or hours of broadband access with wired telecommunications networks. The transition from fixed to mobile, yet ongoing, underscores how a service that did not exist a quarter-century ago now challenges one of the largest and most pervasive infrastructure industries of our time. Industry Canada believes correctly that much too much spectrum lies idle. If more bandwidth were being productively utilized, wireless services would be cheaper and better, delivering consumer gains, while enhanced innovation in radio devices and applications would spur capital formation, business sector efficiency, and overall GDP growth. Complicating the matter is that what appears to regulators as unused spectrum may in fact be a resource productively employed. The discovery that not all network capacity is used to host communications traffic does not imply anything useful about efficiency. The relevant evidence reveals that firms acquiring the largest bandwidth holdings are those that serve the most customers and build the largest, most expensive network infrastructure. This is a set of facts that is strongly consistent with the efficiency view, and strongly inconsistent with the anticompetitive view. Alternatively, bandwidth set aside by regulators to accommodate various services may be under-employed. Excellent examples are found in the administrative allocations governing the television band for decades. 3 Broadcast signals are protected not only by restricting any other broadcasting on the same frequency, but by setting aside two or more adjacent channels (one on each side, etc.) as taboos, blacked out for rival use. Consider the Canadian TV band, where 67 channels are set aside in the VHF and UHF frequencies. 4 Even in the largest and most heavily used markets, and over-counting utilization by including all local stations plus all stations in outlying areas, vast TV band capacity is left fallow. In Vancouver, some 75% of channels are currently left unused. In Toronto and Montreal there is higher utilization, but still more than half of all TV channels host no broadcast signal anywhere in the city or in any nearby city. See Table See, e.g. Thomas Hazlett, A Law & Economics Approach to Spectrum Property Rights: a Response to Weiser and Hatfield, 15 GEORGE MASON LAW REVIEW 975 (2008). See also Michael Heller, The Gridlock Economy (2008), Chapter 4. 4 TV channels are allotted 6 MHz each. VHF bandwidth set aside for stations consists of MHz; MHz; and MHz. UHF channels are allocated MHz; MHz. See Industry Canada, SP MHz, Part II Spectrum Utilization Policy for the Mobile, Broadcasting and Amateur Services in Frequency Range MHz; 5 These percentages figure to be reduced when the analog TV band (67 channels) is reduced to the digital TV band (49 channels) as planned in the Summer 2011 transition, yet will leave large, and hugely expensive, white spaces.
3 T.W. Hazlett Economic Issues in Spectrum Utilization 3 Page 3 of 9 TABLE 1. TV BROADCASTING AND TV BAND UTILIZATION IN CANADA 6 Market no. of channels Taboo Channels % Unused Toronto Montreal Vancouver Far more wireless services could be accommodated without materially impacting the delivery of broadcast television programs. But the use of spectrum as buffer space is not subject to competitive market pressures; it is frozen in place, according to regulatory choices made generations ago, under traditional spectrum allocation rules. The evidence is overwhelming that airwaves do not here satisfy the most pressing consumer demands. Indeed, given Canada s high rate of satellite and cable TV subscribership, shifting all households to a multi-channel service and freeing up the entire 402 MHz band for advanced wireless networks including emerging 4G systems now challenging ultra-fast fixed-line Internet broadband providers in some markets would likely prove a low-cost, high-reward social proposition, as in the U.S. 7 Instead, terrestrial over-the-air video broadcasting, an application popularized in the 1950s, continues to consume vast bandwidth, most used for taboo channels, deterring far more valuable mobile services that distinct from home TV reception cannot be efficiently delivered via fixed networks. Figure 1 expands on Table 1 by showing the number of over the air television stations across all 42 designated market areas (DMAs) in Canada. Note that the white space denoting unassigned TV channels dominates the graphic. Station counts include licenses going through regulatory approval at the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission, as well as operating stations. The Ottawa/Gatineau DMA features 27 channels, the highest occupancy of the 67 allocated TV channels, followed by Toronto/Hamilton/Niagara Falls with 26 and Vancouver-Victoria with 25. Even in these markets, abundant white space exists. And in aggregate, very little of the frequency space appears to host transmissions of any sort. 6 Provincial and Territorial Lists of Over the Air Television Stations 2010, JON C. LEBLANC WEBSITE, (visited on Nov. 30, 2010); 7 Richard Thaler, The Treasure in Your T.V. Dial, N.Y. TIMES (Feb. 27, 2010).
4 T.W. Hazlett Economic Issues in Spectrum Utilization 4 Page 4 of 9 FIG. 1. NUMBER OF OVER-THE-AIR TV STATIONS IN CANADA BY MARKET 8 This is not the case in the cellular bands. Relative to other bands they are intensely utilized, not only in engineering terms (relatively high levels of radio emissions are registered there 9 ), but in generating valuable economic activity. This is achieved through pervasive spectrum sharing. Cellular operators could manage spectrum similar to how regulators have historically managed broadcasting for television, leaving vast white spaces between users. But, given their liberal licenses, they face different incentives. Squandering spectrum would dissipate profits. Hence, licensees adopt low-power technologies, directional antennas, dynamic power controls (continually adjusting radio links to their lowest possible levels, reducing pollution ), and sophisticated protocols enabling far higher levels of economically valued communications traffic than in broadcast TV. In short, spectrum sharing in the TV band is administered; spectrum sharing in the cellular band is competitively determined. The performance differences offer testimony in favor of the social advantage of the latter. Allowing market rivals better access to unoccupied spectrum will speed the introduction of new technologies and assist in the productive expansion of established networks. One path, secondary market transactions allowing existing licensees to host new wireless services, holds great promise but is widely seen as a disappointment. Viewed properly, however, robust spectrum trading activity is observed. Licensees permitted liberal use of allocated spectrum capture wide and deep efficiencies, bundling 8 Ibid. Licenses are originally provided by province and territory. They are aggregated using the DMA list in Appendix A. 9 See Thomas Hazlett & Evan Leo, The Case for Liberal Licenses: An Economic and Technical Analysis, BERKELEY TECHNOLOGY LAW JOURNAL(forthcoming, Spring 2011).
5 T.W. Hazlett Economic Issues in Spectrum Utilization 5 Page 5 of 9 spectrum access and network services to reduce costs and ease complex coordination problems. Spectrum could be packaged in small, raw increments and then sold to customers. However, this approach is not what is observed in the marketplace. Instead, carriers assemble large bandwidth and combine it with large networks, exploiting economies of scope, and then offer wholesale and retail wireless service packages in competition with rival networks. This model offers striking efficiencies relative to an alternative where end users buy spectrum rights, unbundled, and then assemble their own wireless services say, by buying devices that operate without the need for extensive network infrastructure. 10 Competition policy rules are general to virtually all countries, and wireless markets can be analyzed with the consumer welfare models common to antitrust authorities. Spectrum policy makers often imposed spectrum caps as a sort of sectoral antitrust policy, helping to spur market competitiveness. There is nonetheless a common sentiment, expressed in Industry Canada documents and elsewhere, that additional rules are needed to restrict special sorts of actions that licensees may take to warehouse spectrum. Make no mistake: there is a huge warehousing problem in wireless. It is seen in the traditional allocation system that under-allocates spectrum and leaves far too much valuable bandwidth in inventory. This wastes productive opportunities and lowers social well-being. Once spectrum is assigned to liberal licenses and rights are assigned to economic actors, however, warehousing incentives dissipate. Those parties holding productive spectrum rights squander them to their own financial detriment. Internalizing costs ends waste. It is sometimes asserted that large networks tend to bid aggressively for new spectrum rights when auctions offer new rights to market participants, and that this is evidence of incentives for such networks to warehouse spectrum. Such claims overlook a far more salient fact: large networks make very productive use of bandwidth precisely because of the complementarity of the new assets with those they already hold. The efficiency explanation is as compelling as the hypothesis that spectrum is being acquired so as to facilitate monopolistic output restriction. The alternative views can be evaluated using data from the U.S. mobile market. There, four national networks compete, with distinct size differential among the rivals: Verizon and AT&T are the largest players, with Sprint and T-Mobile markedly smaller. While free rider problems present challenges for all competitors contemplating a strategy 10 Of course, devices used in unlicensed bands where exclusive spectrum rights are not awarded and secondary spectrum markets have not formed are tailored to do just this. Wi-fi radios, cordless phones, remote controls, and baby monitors, all popular applications in such spectrum, are short-range communications devices that either plug into a wide area network or offer services that are extremely localized.
6 T.W. Hazlett Economic Issues in Spectrum Utilization 6 Page 6 of 9 of output restriction, it is clear that circumstances favor the larger firms. Whatever sense it makes (or doesn t make) for a largest player to reduce output so as to raise industry price levels, it makes much less sense for smaller firms that have markedly less impact on market demand and less advantage to secure if they were to somehow increase prices to their customers. This inter-firm variance allows us to make predictions based on the competing theories, defined thusly: (A) the anticompetitive view: the larger networks are buying bandwidth so as to keep the inputs away from their rivals, reducing industry output and raising prices. (B) the efficiency view: the larger networks place a relatively high value on spectrum given they use it more intensely, serving larger customer bases. Two testable implications allow us to evaluate the rival hypotheses. First, if networks with large spectrum holdings are amassing bandwidth to restrict output, then their subscriber and/or usage levels should decline relative to other networks. Alternatively, if such networks are acquiring spectrum and using it to serve more customers than rivals, then the implication is that bandwidth is being acquired for productive purposes. Second, if strategic spectrum purchases are being executed to block rivals from gaining access to spectrum, then the acquiring firms would be hoarding spectrum, if not by letting it sit idle, but by under-utilizing it. In that case, they amass bandwidth but economize on capital outlays relative to the expenditures undertaken by firms with no such anticompetitive motive. Alternatively, were the spectrum acquired for productive purposes, then large bandwidth owners would also be the largest investors in network infrastructure.
7 T.W. Hazlett Economic Issues in Spectrum Utilization 7 Page 7 of 9 FIG. 2 U.S. MOBILE CARRIERS SPECTRUM, SUBSCRIBERS AND CAPEX 11 Figure 2 displays data for the four major U.S. networks. Verizon and AT&T own mobile licenses giving them control of over 90 MHz, on average, in the top ten markets. Sprint and T-Mobile, in contrast, have acquired less than 60 MHz. But the carriers acquiring the largest spectrum footprints are serving considerably more customers. The two large networks serve about 90 million each; the two smaller less than 50 million (T- Mobile under 35 million). In terms of physical infrastructure, it is clear that the larger networks invest far more aggressively. Their annual capital expenditures by 2Q2010 were about 2-4 times the levels undertaken by the two smaller firms. The evidence clearly reveals that the firms acquiring the largest bandwidth holdings are those that serve the most customers and build the largest, most expensive network infrastructure. This is a set of facts that is strongly consistent with the efficiency view, and strongly inconsistent with the anticompetitive view. Efficient spectrum use is also fully consistent with the existence of some level of slack, what is known as holding inventories in other markets. Economical deployment lags exist. Infrastructure base stations, backhaul, and mobile radios make airwaves far more valuable. Because the operator will exploit this demand by charging for the use of the network, it has strong incentives to put such capital in place. But speed 11 Mean MHz are calculated for the top ten U.S. markets using data from Stifel Nicolaus, Washington Telecom, Media and Tech Insider (March 28, 2008), p. 9. Subscribership and capital expenditure data are from Bank of America/Merrill Lynch, Global Wireless Matrix 3Q2010 (Sep. 24, 2010), pp Capital expenditure data are provided only for Verizon and AT&T. Using the mean increase in CapEx for these two bigger carriers from 2009 to 2010 as a multiplier, the 2Q2010 CapEx for Sprint and T_Mobile were forecast from 2009 data collected from Bank of America/Merrill Lynch, Global Wireless Matrix 2Q2010 (June 25, 2009).
8 T.W. Hazlett Economic Issues in Spectrum Utilization 8 Page 8 of 9 is a costly input; building networks more quickly costs more, all else equal. 12 Taking due time to architect new systems, assemble labor, procure physical inputs, and arrange other assets such as leases for preferred tower sites generally lowers costs. It is also the case that waiting produces an important economic benefit, option value. 13 The ability to deploy superior systems or technologies as they become available over time is one clear consideration in constructing, expanding, or upgrading wireless networks. Hence, not all spectrum resources should always be fully committed, or used to maximize capacity, in networks. At any point in time, there will predictably be efficiency reasons to not deploy certain assets. In addition to husbanding resources on an optimal investment time path, networks are regularly built and operated so as to reserve some indeed, abundant slack capacity during ordinary operations. This allows not only for traffic fluctuations over standard daily or seasonal cycles, with peak times seeing higher utilization rates, but provides relatively low-cost provision of both emergency capacity (expansion) and standard growth trends. The bottom line is that the discovery that not all network capacity is used to host communications traffic does not imply anything useful about efficiency. On the one hand, it is difficult to define what full employment might mean for a wireless network, given that there are always ways to squeeze more output out of given spectral inputs. The easy example is to think of cellular networks, where cell-splitting yields more intense spectrum re-use. But the more general economic principle is that, by applying more capital (more base stations, better handsets, more advanced technology) it is always possible to engineer additional communications. The efficiency test is whether that extra increment produces benefits greater than the costs required. And that trade-off cannot be purely discerned from examining technical deployments to observe where white spaces are found. It can be discerned, however, by observing how enterprises deploy their assets. A simple analogy is found in the housing market. A canvassing of suburban homes in any major U.S. or Canadian city could produce the conclusion that considerable underdeployment exists in that large numbers of unoccupied bedrooms are found. A family of four living in a five-bedroom home leaves at least one bedroom vacant every night. During the day, vacancy rates are even higher typically 100%. But the outcome is not properly defined as inefficient or wasteful. That is because homeowners are free to increase occupancy levels, taking in relatives, renting out rooms to strangers, or trading for a smaller home. The utilization rates we observe tell us very little. By their revealed preference, however, we discern that vacant bedrooms are valuable. We conclude that they are generally worth what the owners pay for them. 12 The classic essay on the relationship of costs and production time is Armen Alchian, Costs and Outputs, in M. Abramowitz, et al., eds., The Allocation of Economic Resources: Essays in Honor of Bernard Francis Haley (Stanford University Press: 1959), pp Avinish K. Dixit and Robert S. Pindyck, Investment Under Uncertainty (Princeton University Press: 1994).
9 T.W. Hazlett Economic Issues in Spectrum Utilization 9 Page 9 of 9 The analogy is directly transferable to wireless markets, although it may be noted that individual homeowners are unlikely to possess market power whereas a large wireless network may enjoy that ability. Yet a firm that could restrict output, increasing prices above competitive levels, will have no need to warehouse spectrum. The operator would still seek to minimize costs by efficiently using all bandwidth inputs available to the network, just as a competitive firm would. The implication of market power is not that less spectrum will be deployed, but that it will accommodate less economic activity due to the higher prices charged for access. The wireless monopolist would not be effectively constrained by a mandate that all of its spectrum be used. It would be non-binding. But even if it were not, the spectrum could be deployed by using it for access at monopoly prices. It is not possible to objectively measure the economic level of spectrum (or bedroom) deployment to discern warehousing. A requirement that spectrum be used can be satisfied by using it in a cheap, if relatively unproductive, way. The consumer issue to which warehousing concerns are inaccurately pointed is found in the standard antitrust models: inadequate market rivalry. The solution is to put abundant spectrum resources into the marketplace under rules that allow competitors maximum scope for efficient behavior. Market structure is the proper focus, not spectrum utilization. There, the cost-minimization incentives of for-profit firms are far more reliable than prices or allocations administratively imposed.
Consultation on Repurposing the 600 MHz Band. Notice No. SLPB Published in the Canada Gazette, Part 1 Dated January 3, 2015
Consultation on Repurposing the 600 MHz Band Notice No. SLPB-005-14 Published in the Canada Gazette, Part 1 Dated January 3, 2015 Comments of Ontario Ministry of Economic Development, Employment and Infrastructure
More informationBefore the Federal Communications Commission Washington, D.C ) ) ) ) ) REPLY COMMENTS OF PCIA THE WIRELESS INFRASTRUCTURE ASSOCIATION
Before the Federal Communications Commission Washington, D.C. 20554 In the Matter of Amendment of the Commission s Rules with Regard to Commercial Operations in the 3550-3650 MHz Band GN Docket No. 12-354
More informationResponse to the "Consultation on Repurposing the 600 MHz Band" Canada Gazette, Part I SLPB December, Submitted By: Ontario Limited
Response to the "Consultation on Repurposing the 600 MHz Band" Canada Gazette, Part I SLPB-005-14 December, 2014 Submitted By: February 26th, 2015 1 DISCLAIMER Although efforts have been made to ensure
More informationThe Telecommunications Act Chap. 47:31
The Telecommunications Act Chap. 47:31 4 th September 2013 Presentation Overview Legislative Mandate Limitations of Telecommunications Act Proposed Amendments to Telecommunications Act New Technological
More informationRadio Spectrum the EBU Q&A
1 Radio Spectrum the EBU Q&A What is spectrum and what is it used for? Spectrum or radio spectrum is the range of electromagnetic radio frequencies used to transmit signals wirelessly. Radio frequencies
More informationAPPENDIX A. Report of Gregory L. Rosston, Ph.D. 11/13/2001
APPENDIX A Report of Gregory L. Rosston, Ph.D. 11/13/2001 I. Introduction/Executive Summary My name is Gregory L. Rosston. I am Deputy Director of the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research at
More informationBoulder Thinking About The Incentive Auction
Boulder Thinking About The Incentive Auction. Preston Padden Principal, Boulder Thinking, LLC May 12, 2017 The FCC Spectrum Incentive Auction: Lessons for the Future Center For Innovation Policy At Duke
More informationOECD COMMUNICATIONS OUTLOOK 2001 Broadcasting Section
OECD COMMUNICATIONS OUTLOOK 2001 Broadcasting Section Country: HUNGAR Date completed: 13 June, 2000 1 BROADCASTING Broadcasting services available 1. Please provide details of the broadcasting and cable
More information21 December Mr. Michael Helm Director General Telecommunications Policy Branch Industry Canada 300 Slater Street Ottawa, Ontario, K1A 0C8
21 December 2001 Don Woodford Director - Government & Regulatory Affairs Mr. Michael Helm Director General Telecommunications Policy Branch Industry Canada 300 Slater Street Ottawa, Ontario, K1A 0C8 Dear
More informationFuture pricing of spectrum used for terrestrial broadcasting A consultation
Future pricing of spectrum used for terrestrial broadcasting A consultation Consultation Publication date: 27 July 2006 Closing Date for Responses: 27 October 2006 Contents Section Annex Page 1 Executive
More informationI. Introduction A. Overview of IT, DTV, and the Internet in Japan
Platforms for the Development of Digital Television Broadcasting and the Internet in Japan Fourteenth Northeast Asia Economic Forum Shenyang, China 20-21 September 2005 Hajime ONIKI Osaka-Gakuin University,
More informationReply Comments from the Canadian Association of Broadcasters
March 26, 2015 Reply Comments from the Canadian Association of Broadcasters Re: Canada Gazette, Part 1, Notice No. SLPB-005-14 Consultation on Repurposing the 600 MHz Band, publication date January 3,
More informationAPPENDIX D TECHNOLOGY. This Appendix describes the technologies included in the assessment
APPENDIX D TECHNOLOGY This Appendix describes the technologies included in the assessment and comments upon some of the economic factors governing their use. The technologies described are: coaxial cable
More informationLook Communications Inc.
Look Communications Inc. Response to Notice Number DGTP-002-07 Consultation on a Framework to Auction Spectrum in the 2 GHz Range including Advanced Wireless Services May 2007 Response to Notice Number:
More informationBefore the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C REPLY COMMENTS OF THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION
Before the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20554 In the Matter of: ) ) In the Matter of Amendment of ) GN Docket No. 12-354 the Commission s Rules with Regard ) to Commercial Operations
More informationOECD COMMUNICATIONS OUTLOOK 2001 Broadcasting Section
OECD COMMUNICATIONS OUTLOOK 2001 Broadcasting Section Country: CANADA Date completed: June 29, 2000 1 Broadcasting services available BROADCASTING 1. Please provide details of the broadcasting and cable
More informationAN EXPLORATION OF THE BENEFITS OF MIGRATION TO DIGITAL BROADCASTING
AN EXPLORATION OF THE BENEFITS OF MIGRATION TO DIGITAL BROADCASTING Rev. Fr. Hyacinth C. Orlu-Orlu, Ph.D. Senior Lecturer, Department of Linguistics and Communication Studies, University of Port- Harcourt,
More informationBefore the. FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION Washington, D.C
Before the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20554 In the Matter of: ) ) Authorizing Permissive Use of the ) Next Generation Broadcast ) GN Docket No. 16-142 Television Standard ) REPLY
More informationMOBILE DIGITAL TELEVISION. never miss a minute
MOBILE DIGITAL TELEVISION never miss a minute About Mobile DTV The Power of Local TV on the Go Mobile Digital Television (DTV) represents a significant new revenue stream for the broadcasting industry
More informationDragonWave, Horizon and Avenue are registered trademarks of DragonWave Inc DragonWave Inc. All rights reserved
NOTICE This document contains DragonWave proprietary information. Use, disclosure, copying or distribution of any part of the information contained herein, beyond that for which it was originally furnished,
More informationGOVERNMENT GAZETTE OF THE REPUBLIC OF NAMIBIA. N$4.00 WINDHOEK - 11 July 2014 No. 5507
GOVERNMENT GAZETTE OF THE REPUBLIC OF NAMIBIA N$4.00 WINDHOEK - 11 July 2014 No. 5507 CONTENTS Page GENERAL NOTICES No. 193 Communications Regulatory Authority of Namibia: Notice in terms of the Regulations
More informationVia
Howard Slawner 350 Bloor Street East, 6th Floor Toronto, ON M4W 0A1 howard.slawner@rci.rogers.com o 416.935.7009 m 416.371.6708 Via email: ic.spectrumengineering-genieduspectre.ic@canada.ca Senior Director
More informationPUBLIC INTEREST ADVOCACY CENTRE LE CENTRE POUR LA DÉFENSE DE L INTÉRÊT PUBLIC
PUBLIC INTEREST ADVOCACY CENTRE LE CENTRE POUR LA DÉFENSE DE L INTÉRÊT PUBLIC The Public Interest Advocacy Centre (PIAC) is a non-profit organization based in Ottawa, Ontario that provides advocacy and
More informationBroadband Changes Everything
Broadband Changes Everything OECD Roundtable On Communications Convergence UK Department of Trade and Industry Conference Centre London June 2-3, 2005 Michael Hennessy President Canadian Cable Telecommunications
More information1 COPYRIGHT 2012 ALCATEL-LUCENT. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Latin American Spectrum Conference 2012 Mexico City October 24-25, 2012 Session on The Possibilities of 700MHz October 25 th 15.00 17.30 Stephen A. Wilkus 1 Sustaining the Revolution The potential of 700
More informationIntelsat CEO Stephen Spengler on the fleet operator s big broadband bet
SPACENEWS.COM BUSINESS POLITICS PERSPECTIVE FEBRUARY 29, 2016 Intelsat CEO Stephen Spengler on the fleet operator s big broadband bet INSIDE Tory Bruno on ULA s $800 million U.S. Air Force launch contract
More informationDemonstration of geolocation database and spectrum coordinator as specified in ETSI TS and TS
Demonstration of geolocation database and spectrum coordinator as specified in ETSI TS 103 143 and TS 103 145 ETSI Workshop on Reconfigurable Radio Systems - Status and Novel Standards 2014 Sony Europe
More informationResponse to Ofcom Consultation The future use of the 700MHz band. Response from Freesat. 29 August 2014
Response to Ofcom Consultation The future use of the 700MHz band Response from Freesat 29 August 2014 1 1 About Freesat Freesat is a subscription free satellite and IP TV service offering digital television
More information600 Matters. A vision for collaborating with America s broadcasters
600 Matters A vision for collaborating with America s broadcasters 2017 We re all in! When the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) announced the 600 MHz broadcast spectrum auction, the Un-carrier committed
More informationThe long term future of UHF spectrum
The long term future of UHF spectrum A response by Vodafone to the Ofcom discussion paper Developing a framework for the long term future of UHF spectrum bands IV and V 1 Introduction 15 June 2011 (amended
More informationPresented By: Andy Louis, Chairperson of NAB Technical Committee Date: 3 October National Association Of Broadcasters 1
Presented By: Andy Louis, Chairperson of NAB Technical Committee Date: 3 October 2014 Broadcasters 1 ICT Panel Policy Considerations: Spectrum Issues Broadcasters 2 Before any future spectrum considerations
More informationTelephone Facsimile
TELUS Mobility Floor 16 200 Consilium Place Scarborough, Ontario Canada M1H 3J3 Ed Prior Director, Government & Regulatory Affairs 416 279 7523 Telephone 416 279 3166 Facsimile ed.prior@telus.com October
More informationConsiderations in Updating Broadcast Regulations for the Digital Era
Considerations in Updating Broadcast Regulations for the Digital Era By Koji Yoshihisa Economic & Industrial Research Group Broadcast television, the undisputed king of entertainment in the household,
More information6Harmonics. 6Harmonics Inc. is pleased to submit the enclosed comments to Industry Canada s Gazette Notice SMSE
November 4, 2011 Manager, Fixed Wireless Planning, DGEPS, Industry Canada, 300 Slater Street, 19th Floor, Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0C8 Email: Spectrum.Engineering@ic.gc.ca RE: Canada Gazette Notice SMSE-012-11,
More informationThe Free State Foundation
The Free State Foundation A Free Market Think Tank For Maryland Because Ideas Matter Perspectives from FSF Scholars June 19, 2007 Vol. 2, No. 18 The Federal Unbundling Commission? by Randolph J. May* If
More informationCanada Gazette, Part I, December 18, 2014, Notice No. SLPB Consultation on Repurposing the 600 MHz Band Eastlink s reply comments
March 26, 2015 Senior Director Spectrum Licensing and Auction Operations Industry Canada 235 Queen Street Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0H5 spectrum.auctions@ic.gc.ca Dear Sir/Madam: Re: Canada Gazette, Part I,
More informationSpectrum for the Internet of Things
Spectrum for the Internet of Things GSMA Public Policy Position August 2016 COPYRIGHT 2017 GSM ASSOCIATION 2 SPECTRUM FOR THE INTERNET OF THINGS Summary The Internet of Things (IoT) is a hugely important
More informationSENATE SUBCOMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS
SENATE SUBCOMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS TESTIMONY OF ANDREW S. WRIGHT, PRESIDENT SATELLITE BROADCASTING AND COMMUNICATIONS ASSOCIATION RURAL WIRELESS TECHNOLOGY May 22, 2003 Thank you, Mr. Chairman, Senator
More informationGROWING VOICE COMPETITION SPOTLIGHTS URGENCY OF IP TRANSITION By Patrick Brogan, Vice President of Industry Analysis
RESEARCH BRIEF NOVEMBER 22, 2013 GROWING VOICE COMPETITION SPOTLIGHTS URGENCY OF IP TRANSITION By Patrick Brogan, Vice President of Industry Analysis An updated USTelecom analysis of residential voice
More informationIntroduction of digital TV in Bosnia and Herzegovina - Support for Public Broadcasting System
Introduction of digital TV in Bosnia and Herzegovina - Support for Public Broadcasting System Prof. dr Branko Dokić Member of the House of Representatives of the Parliamentary Assembly od BiH Why DTV?
More informationRegulatory Issues Affecting the Internet. Jeff Guldner
Regulatory Issues Affecting the Internet Jeff Guldner Outline Existing Service-Based Regulation Telephone Cable Wireless Existing Provider-Based Regulation BOC restrictions Emerging Regulatory Issues IP
More informationTelecommunications Regulation. CHILE Claro y Cia
Telecommunications Regulation CHILE Claro y Cia CONTACT INFORMATION Matias de Marchena Claro y Cia Apoquindo 3721, piso 13 Las Condes, Santiago Chile 56-2-367-3092 mdemarchena@claro.cl 1. What is the name
More information116 Albert Street, Suite 811 Phone: K1P 5G3 Fax: Web site:
Radio Advisory Board of Canada Conseil consultatif canadien de la radio April 17, 2009 Leonard St-Aubin Director General Telecommunications Policy Branch Industry Canada 300 Slater Street Ottawa, Ontario
More informationChapter 2. Analysis of ICT Industrial Trends in the IoT Era. Part 1
Chapter 2 Analysis of ICT Industrial Trends in the IoT Era This chapter organizes the overall structure of the ICT industry, given IoT progress, and provides quantitative verifications of each market s
More informationCanadian Broadcasting Corporation Société Radio-Canada
Canadian Broadcasting Corporation Société Radio-Canada To: Director General, Telecommunications Policy Branch, Industry Canada, 16th Floor, 300 Slater Street, Ottawa, Ontario, K1A 0C8 Re: CBC/Radio-Canada
More informationReport touts benefits of CMA-sized spectrum licenses ahead of 600 MHz auction
Trends» Careers Webinars Reports White Papers RCR TV Global Spectrum Map Test & Measurement Subscribe Home U.S. Americas Carriers Devices Enterprise Analyst Angle Opinion Backhaul LTE Cell Tower News Categories:
More informationEvolution of Spectrum Valuation for Mobile Services In Other Countries
SCHEDULE C Evolution of Spectrum Valuation for Mobile Services In Other Countries By: Lemay-Yates Associates Inc. March 2003 Evolution of Spectrum Valuation for Mobile Services in Other Countries Report
More informationWIRELESS PLANNING MEMORANDUM
WIRELESS PLANNING MEMORANDUM TO: Andrew Cohen-Cutler FROM: Robert C. May REVIEWER: Jonathan L. Kramer DATE: RE: Technical Review for Proposed Modification to Rooftop Wireless Site (File No. 160002523)
More informationIn November, the Federal
Update New Rules Of The Wireless Road Final FCC ruling includes protection for wireless microphones By Chris Lyons In November, the Federal Communications Commission released the full text of its Second
More informationAUSTRALIAN SUBSCRIPTION TELEVISION AND RADIO ASSOCIATION
7 December 2015 Intellectual Property Arrangements Inquiry Productivity Commission GPO Box 1428 CANBERRA CITY ACT 2601 By email: intellectual.property@pc.gov.au Dear Sir/Madam The Australian Subscription
More informationJohn Stankey President and CEO AT&T Operations
John Stankey President and CEO AT&T Operations Bank of America Media, Communications, & Entertainment Conference September 9, 2009 Cautionary Language Concerning Forward-Looking Statements Information
More informationIntroduction. Introductory remarks
Communications Consumer Panel and ACOD s response to Ofcom s consultation on the UK preparations for the World Radiocommunication Conference 2015 (WRC-15) Introduction The Communications Consumer Panel
More informationStatement of the National Association of Broadcasters
Statement of the National Association of Broadcasters Hearing before the House Committee on Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Telecommunications and the Internet May 10, 2007 The National Association
More informationNew Networks Institute
PART II Summary Report: Exposing Verizon NY s Financial Shell Game & the NYPSC s Role RE: Case 14-C-0370 In the Matter of a Study on the State of Telecom in NY State. Connect New York Coalition Petition
More informationWhite Paper. Fibre Optic Technologies for Satellite Communication and Broadcast Industries. By Tom Lacey Applications Engineering Group PPM Ltd, UK
White Paper Fibre Optic Technologies for Satellite Communication and Broadcast Industries By Tom Lacey Applications Engineering Group PPM Ltd, UK Abstract The satellite communications and broadcast industries
More informationREDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION AT&T/DIRECTV DESCRIPTION OF TRANSACTION, PUBLIC INTEREST SHOWING, AND RELATED DEMONSTRATIONS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
AT&T/DIRECTV DESCRIPTION OF TRANSACTION, PUBLIC INTEREST SHOWING, AND RELATED DEMONSTRATIONS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY I. INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY This transaction will unite two companies with uniquely complementary
More informationBefore the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION Washington, DC ) ) ) ) ) ) REPLY COMMENTS OF THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF BROADCASTERS
Before the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION Washington, DC 20554 In the h Matter of Public Notice on Interpretation of the Terms Multichannel Video Programming Distributor and Channel as Raised in Pending
More informationMarch 2, 2018 Via
Howard Slawner 350 Bloor Street East, 6th Floor Toronto, ON M4W 0A1 howard.slawner@rci.rogers.com o 416.935.7009 m 416.371.6708 Via email: ic.spectrumengineering-genieduspectre.ic@canada.ca Senior Director
More informationCanada Gazette - Industry Canada Notice SMBR : DTV (Digital Television) Transition Allotment Plan
September 11, 1998 Mr. Robert W. McCaughern Director General, Spectrum Engineering Branch Industry Canada 300 Slater Street Ottawa, ON K1A 0C8 Re: Canada Gazette - Industry Canada Notice SMBR-002-98: DTV
More informationTHE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF BROADCASTER S WRITTEN SUBMISSION ON THE INDEPENDENT COMMUNICATIONS AUTHORITY OF SOUTH AFRICA S DISCUSSION DOCUMENT ON THE
THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF BROADCASTER S WRITTEN SUBMISSION ON THE INDEPENDENT COMMUNICATIONS AUTHORITY OF SOUTH AFRICA S DISCUSSION DOCUMENT ON THE REGULATION OF IPTV AND VOD 26 MARCH 2010 1. Introduction
More informationPresent & Future Opportunities for WISPs to Obtain Access to Additional Spectrum
Present & Future Opportunities for WISPs to Obtain Access to Additional Spectrum TV White Spaces Incentive Auction Incentive Auction process will determine how much unlicensed TV band spectrum will remain
More informationBefore the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION WASHINGTON, DC 20554
Before the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION WASHINGTON, DC 20554 In the Matter of ) ) MB Docket No. 12-83 Interpretation of the Terms Multichannel Video ) Programming Distributor and Channel ) as raised
More informationGlobal Forum on Competition
Unclassified DAF/COMP/GF/WD(2013)26 DAF/COMP/GF/WD(2013)26 Unclassified Organisation de Coopération et de Développement Économiques Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development 24-Jan-2013 English
More informationSwitching to digital television
Switching to digital television The transition from analogue to digital television is well under way in a number of countries around the world. digital television allows for better picture and sound quality,
More informationEBU view How should we use the digital dividend?
EBU view How should we use the digital dividend? Long-term public interest versus short-term profit Revised April 2009 CONTENT How should we use the digital dividend? The EBU s key concerns Why is the
More informationJuly 6, 2015 VIA ELECTRONIC FILING. Marlene H. Dortch, Secretary Federal Communications Commission th Street, SW Washington, DC 20554
July 6, 2015 VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Marlene H. Dortch, Secretary Federal Communications Commission 445 12 th Street, SW Washington, DC 20554 Re: Expanding the Economic and Innovation Opportunities of Spectrum
More informationJoint submission by BBC, ITV, Channel 4, Channel 5, S4C, Arqiva 1 and SDN to Culture Media and Sport Committee inquiry into Spectrum
Joint submission by BBC, ITV, Channel 4, Channel 5, S4C, Arqiva 1 and SDN to Culture Media and Sport Committee inquiry into Spectrum 1. Introduction and summary The above-named organisations welcome the
More informationAT&T Investor Update. 2Q08 Earnings Conference Call July 23, 2008
AT&T Investor Update 2Q08 Earnings Conference Call July 23, 2008 2008 AT&T Intellectual Property. All rights reserved. AT&T, the AT&T logo and all other marks contained herein are trademarks of AT&T Intellectual
More informationCOMMUNICATIONS OUTLOOK 1999
OCDE OECD ORGANISATION DE COOPÉRATION ET ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC DE DÉVELOPPEMENT ÉCONOMIQUES CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT COMMUNICATIONS OUTLOOK 1999 BROADCASTING: Regulatory Issues Country: MEXICO
More informationHead-end in the Sky - A Digital Reality
Head-end in the Sky - A Digital Reality Issue V February 2010 Introduction The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India ( TRAI ), on the request of The Ministry of Information and Broadcasting ( MIB ) has
More informationAustralian Broadcasting Corporation. submission to. National Cultural Policy Consultation
Australian Broadcasting Corporation submission to National Cultural Policy Consultation February 2010 Introduction The Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) welcomes the opportunity to provide a submission
More informationInterim use of 600 MHz for DTT
Interim use of 600 MHz for DTT Executive summary The BBC, Channel 4 and Arqiva have developed a proposal to make interim use of the 600 MHz band to provide additional Digital Terrestrial Television (DTT)
More informationSinclair Broadcast Group Who We Are
SAFE HARBOR The following information contains, or may be deemed to contain, "forward-looking statements" (as defined in the U.S. Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995). Any statements about
More informationBroadcasting Regulatory Policy CRTC
Broadcasting Regulatory Policy CRTC 2016-364 PDF version Reference: 2016-76 Ottawa, 8 September 2016 General authorizations for broadcasting distribution undertakings The Commission amends the general
More informationBefore the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION Washington, DC 20554
Before the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION Washington, DC 20554 In the Matter of Amendment of the Commission s Rules with Regard to Commercial Operations in the 3550-3650 MHz Band ) ) ) GN Docket No.
More informationFAQ s DTT 1. What is DTT? 2. What is the difference between terrestrial television and satellite television?
FAQ s ABOUT DTT 1. What is DTT? - DTT stands for Digital Terrestrial Television or Digital Terrestrial Transmission. It refers to the broadcasting of terrestrial television in a digital format. Currently,
More informationAnnex J: Outline for Bhutan DTV Road Map
Annex J: Outline for Bhutan DTV Road Map A Guide for the Working Committee This is an outline of a possible form of a final report of the Working Committee, which could then easily be converted to the
More informationObjectives and Methodology for the Over-the-air Television Transition
January 2017 Spectrum Management and Telecommunications Objectives and Methodology for the Over-the-air Television Transition Aussi disponible en français DGGPN-002-017 Contents 1. Intent... 3 2. Background...
More informationMotion Picture, Video and Television Program Production, Post-Production and Distribution Activities
The 31 th Voorburg Group Meeting Zagreb Croatia 19-23 September 2016 Mini-Presentation SPPI for ISIC4 Group 591 Motion Picture, Video and Television Program Production, Post-Production and Distribution
More informationCOMMUNICATIONS OUTLOOK 1999
OCDE OECD ORGANISATION DE COOPÉRATION ET ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC DE DÉVELOPPEMENT ÉCONOMIQUES CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT COMMUNICATIONS OUTLOOK 1999 BROADCASTING: Regulatory Issues Country: Norway
More informationBefore the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION Washington DC ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) COMMENTS OF
Before the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION Washington DC 20554 In the Matter of Amendment of Part 101 of the Commission s Rules to Facilitate the Use of Microwave for Wireless Backhaul and Other Uses
More informationIntelsat Media Solutions. Capture and Expand Your Audience
Intelsat Media Solutions Capture and Expand Your Audience Distributing programming and serving the demands of your audiences worldwide are increasingly becoming more difficult. Customer s viewing patterns
More informationIntelsat Maritime Solutions
Intelsat Maritime Solutions One Flex for Maritime The Commercial Maritime Industy is Changing... Are You Ready? 69,500 Ships in Addressable Commercial Maritime VSAT market 60 Gbps High-throughput Satellite
More informationCOMMUNICATIONS OUTLOOK 1999
OCDE OECD ORGANISATION DE COOPÉRATION ET ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC DE DÉVELOPPEMENT ÉCONOMIQUES CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT COMMUNICATIONS OUTLOOK 1999 BROADCASTING: Regulatory Issues Country: Denmark
More informationBROADCASTING REFORM. Productivity Commission, Broadcasting Report No. 11, Aus Info, Canberra, Reviewed by Carolyn Lidgerwood.
Reviews BROADCASTING REFORM Productivity Commission, Broadcasting Report No. 11, Aus Info, Canberra, 2000 Reviewed by Carolyn Lidgerwood When it was announced in early 1999 that the Federal Treasurer had
More informationOECD COMMUNICATIONS OUTLOOK 2001 Broadcasting Section
OECD COMMUNICATIONS OUTLOOK 2001 Broadcasting Section Country: NEW ZEALAND Date completed: 1 September 2000 Broadcasting s available BROADCASTING 1. Please provide details of the broadcasting and cable
More informationConsultation on Repurposing the 600 MHz Band. Reply Comments of the Public Interest Advocacy Centre ( PIAC )
Consultation on Reply Comments of the Public Interest Advocacy Centre ( PIAC ) TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Introduction... 1 2. Limited justification and limited support for repurposing... 1 3. Transition costs
More information6Harmonics. 6Harmonics Inc. is pleased to submit the enclosed comments to Industry Canada s Gazette Notice SLPB
February 24, 2015 Senior Director, Spectrum Licensing and Auction Operations, Industry Canada, 235 Queen Street, Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0H5 Email: spectrum.auctions@ic.gc.ca RE: Canada s Gazette Notice SLPB-005-14
More informationMicrowave Backhaul Solutions SUPER HIGH PERFORMANCE ANTENNAS. Not just a new backhaul solution a whole new backhaul strategy
Microwave Backhaul Solutions SUPER HIGH PERFORMANCE ANTENNAS Not just a new backhaul solution a whole new backhaul strategy Sentinel Class 4 antennas from our Andrew Portfolio When you think about network
More informationBefore the Federal Communications Commission Washington, D.C
Before the Federal Communications Commission Washington, D.C. 20554 In the Matter of ) ) Amendment of Parts 73 and 74 of the ) MB Docket No. 08-253 Commission s Rules to Establish Rules for ) Replacement
More informationUSO OFCOM Consultation Comments
Input by ViaSat to Support the Universal Service Obligation (USO) Consultation High Capacity Satellite (HCS) Broadband EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The USO is the latest, and welcomed, commitment to improve the delivery
More informationSOUTH AFRICA BROADCASTING DIGITAL MIGRATION (BDM) A Z. the doc
GODIGITAL SOUTH AFRICA BROADCASTING DIGITAL MIGRATION (BDM) A Z the doc The Department of Communications (DoC) developed the Go DIGITAL South Africa booklet to educate, inform and create awareness about
More informationBroadcasting Decision CRTC
Broadcasting Decision CRTC 2017-145 PDF version References: 2016-225, 2016-225-1, 2016-225-2, 2016-225-3 and 2016-225-4 Ottawa, 15 May 2017 Corus Entertainment Inc. Across Canada Application 2016-0022-1
More informationResolution Calling on the FCC to Facilitate the DTV Transition through Additional Consumer Education Efforts
Resolution Calling on the FCC to Facilitate the DTV Transition through Additional Consumer Education Efforts WHEREAS, Congress has established February 17, 2009, as the hard deadline for the end of full-power
More informationMEDIA OWNERSHIP AND CONCENTRATION IN AMERICA
MEDIA OWNERSHIP AND CONCENTRATION IN AMERICA TABLE OF CONTENTS ELI M. NOAM COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY I. INTRODUCTION CHAPTER 1: IS THE AMERICAN INFORMATION SECTOR BECOMING MORE CONCENTRATED? 1. A LOST GOLDEN
More informationDigital Switchover in Chinese Taipei
2010/TEL41/LSG/RR/005 Session 2 Digital Switchover in Chinese Taipei Purpose: Information Submitted by: Chinese Taipei Regulatory Roundtable Chinese Taipei 7 May 2010 Digital Switchover in Chinese Taipei
More informationSTAATSKOERANT, 17 FEBRUARIE 2012 No GOVERNMENT NOTICE DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS ELECTRONIC COMMUNICATIONS ACT, 2005 (ACT NO.
STAATSKOERANT, 17 FEBRUARIE 2012 No.35051 3 GOVERNMENT NOTICE DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATIONS No. 124 17 February 2012 ELECTRONIC COMMUNICATIONS ACT, 2005 (ACT NO. 36 OF 2005) SUBSTITUTION OF PARAGRAPHS 1
More informationBefore the Federal Communications Commission Washington, D.C ) ) ) ) ) ) REPLY COMMENTS OF THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF BROADCASTERS
Before the Federal Communications Commission Washington, D.C. 20554 In the Matter of Annual Assessment of the Status of Competition in the Market for the Delivery of Video Programming MB Docket No. 12-203
More informationBroadband development in Argentina
Broadband development in Argentina Optimising risk and infrastructure development in times of crisis Sonia Agnese Regulatory Evolution Manager Telecom Personal - Telecom Argentina Broadband market Argentina
More informationGuide to Wireless Microphone Operation. Post FCC 600 MHz Incentive Auction. By Joe Ciaudelli Sennheiser Electronic Corporation
Guide to Wireless Microphone Operation Post FCC 600 MHz Incentive Auction By Joe Ciaudelli Sennheiser Electronic Corporation Almost every venue and person using multiple wireless microphones in the United
More information