STATE OF NEVADA OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL RENO, NEVADA TRANSCRIPT OF ELECTRONICALLY-RECORDED INTERVIEW HOWARD ROSENBERG AUGUST 5, 2014

Similar documents
STATE OF NEVADA OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL RENO, NEVADA TRANSCRIPT OF ELECTRONICALLY-RECORDED INTERVIEW ESTELA GUTIERREZ AUGUST 27, 2014

Lexie World (The Three Lost Kids, #1) Chapter 1- Where My Socks Disappear

Dominque Silva: I'm Dominique Silva, I am a senior here at Chico State, as well as a tutor in the SLC, I tutor math up to trig, I've been here, this

I HAD TO STAY IN BED. PRINT PAGE 161. Chapter 11

Testimony of David Rogers

And you are waving your rights and agreed to ah talk to us? And you do know that ah this interview is being ah taped?

TAINTED LOVE. by WALTER WYKES CHARACTERS MAN BOY GIRL. SETTING A bare stage

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 09/15/ :53 PM INDEX NO /2017 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 71 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 09/15/2017 EXHIBIT I

Candice Bergen Transcript 7/18/06

Testimony of Kay Norris

Condcnsclt! 11. Page 123 Page A. Johnnycake Road. 2 Q. And how close to the -- where Rolling Road. 3 crosses Johnnycake is it?

Famous Quotations from Alice in Wonderland

Edited by

Transcript: Reasoning about Exponent Patterns: Growing, Growing, Growing

Case 1:12-cv GBL-TRJ Document Filed 11/21/12 Page 1 of 198 PageID# 2384

DOCUMENT NAME/INFORMANT: PETER CHAMBERLAIN #2 INFORMANT'S ADDRESS: INTERVIEW LOCATION: TRIBE/NATION: OOWEKEENO HISTORY PROJECT

On the eve of the Neil Young and Crazy Horse Australian tour, he spoke with Undercover's Paul Cashmere.

NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BOARD WASHINGTON, DC INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT CLYDE ANTROBUS NOVEMBER 18, 1996

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK i COUNTY OF NEW YORK. Plaintiff, EXAMINATION BEFORE TRIAL of PETER J. BALZANO, the

SURVIVAL TIPS FOR FAMILY GATHERINGS

4, 0 3>.. ss# 21 CJ 'j

DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY BUREAU OF ALCOHOL, TOBACCO & FIREARMS

Note: Please use the actual date you accessed this material in your citation.

Sketch. A Square Peg in a Round Hole. Ronald Lear. Volume 48, Number Article 19. Iowa State University

Q. But in reality, the bond had already been. revoked, hadn't it? It was already set at zero bond. before September 21st, specifically on September --

DOCKET NO. SA-516 APPENDIX 12 NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BOARD WASHINGTON, DC. INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT RICHARD ORTIZ NOVEMBER 19, 1996 (25 pages)

Speaker 2: Hi everybody welcome back to out of order my name is Alexa Febreze and with my co host. Speaker 1: Kylie's an hour. Speaker 2: I have you

Transcription Media File Name: Radio-Burde_Pierotti.mp4 Media File ID: Media Duration: 11:37 Order Number: Date Ordered:

Elementary Podcast 2-5 Transcript

[3/24/2011] George Ross March 24, 2011

STATE OF NEW HAMPSHIRE

MITOCW ocw f07-lec02_300k

DIFFERENTIATE SOMETHING AT THE VERY BEGINNING THE COURSE I'LL ADD YOU QUESTIONS USING THEM. BUT PARTICULAR QUESTIONS AS YOU'LL SEE

1 MR. ROBERT LOPER: I have nothing. 3 THE COURT: Thank you. You're. 5 MS. BARNETT: May we approach? 7 (At the bench, off the record.

Beyond basic grammar: Connections with the real world

JENS LYBERTH & MAX IRELAND INFORMANT'S ADDRESS: SPADINA ROAD LIBRARY

[6/15/2011] Donald Trump June 15, 2011

PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION OF WEST VIRGINIA CHARLESTON * * * * * * * * * v. * T-C * * * * * * * * * HEARING TRANSCRIPT * * * * * * * * *

Reporter's Transcript of Proceedings TESTIMONY OF CARL MARINO Wednesday, December 13,

Bereavement. Heaven Collins. 5/2/16 Bellows Free Academy Saint Albans 380 Lake Rd, Saint Albans, VT (802)

Aaah just some additional questions that-that we had and we wanted to talk to you in person, okay?

TRANSCRIPT OF VIDEOTAPED INTERVIEW OF CHRISTOPHER S. PORCO. Monday, November 15, 2004

THE BENCH PRODUCTION HISTORY

The following interview appeared in Vibe Magazine. In it Tupac describes the shooting at the Quad Studios.

Mary Murphy: I want you to take out your diagrams that you drew yesterday.

ABBOTT AND COSTELLO By Jonathan Mayer

LLT 180 Lecture 8 1. We're over on page 194. We had just gotten done. We had Wart saying clearly

Covering Your Tracts. Torry Martin. And. Marshal Younger

Palliative Care Chat - Episode 18 Conversation with Barbara Karnes Page 1 of 8

Our Dad is in Atlantis

2 THE COURT: All right. You may. 4 MS. BARNETT: Thank you, Your Honor. 6 having been first duly sworn, testified as follows:

Choose the correct word or words to complete each sentence.

That's OK. I thought it was the horse

Chapter X. In which Christopher Robin and pooh come to an enchanted place, and we leave them there

WEST VIRGINIA MINE SAFETY AND HEALTH ADMINISTRATION

BABIES. A short comedy by Don Zolidis

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 10/26/ :06 PM INDEX NO /2017 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 61 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/26/2018

Q. That's all from the OC spray, right? MR. SCOTT: Okay. Pass the. THE COURT: State? MR. SCOTT: Yes, Your Honor. State, call your next.

THE WEIGHT OF SECRETS. Steve Meredith

And all that glitters is gold Only shooting stars break the mold. Gonna Be

Confrontation between Jackie and Daniel s ex-girlfriend

Testimony of Barry Dickey

UA12/2/1/2 Our Fears Are All the Same, John Carpenter

Case: 2:08-cv GLF-NMK Doc #: 96-8 Filed: 05/07/10 Page: 1 of 14 PAGEID #: 1940

Empathic Listening Northwest Compassionate Communications

ECO LECTURE TWENTY-THREE 1 OKAY. WE'RE GETTING TO GO ON AND TALK ABOUT THE LONG-RUN

Look Mom, I Got a Job!

ELEVEN BALLS LEFT. David Wells Diversion Drive Sterling Heights, MI Cell:

Marriner thought for a minute. 'Very well, Mr Hewson, let's say this. If your story comes out in The Morning Times, there's five pounds waiting for

889 R. v Bruno Kraljevic and Branka Kraljevic

Wayne: That's correct. Copyright 2017 LARadioSpecialist.com

WEB FORM F USING THE HELPING SKILLS SYSTEM FOR RESEARCH

A Children's Play. By Francis Giordano

FADE IN: A dimly lit, musty, basement. Water drips from old rusted pipes. Rats scurry across the room.

THE HISTORY OF MOTOWN PAGE 1

No Clowning Around. Jeffrey Dean Langham

Dinosaurs. B. Answer the questions in Hebrew/Arabic. 1. How do scientists know that dinosaurs once lived? 2. Where does the name dinosaur come from?

,-FR.. BURNE T SCAN FROM THE DIOCESE OF JOLIET N

Interviewee: Emile Lacasse, Sr. Interviewer: Carroll McIntire May 12, 1994

MIT Alumni Books Podcast Somewhere There Is Still a Sun

CA09FR008 Lake Buena Vista, Florida July 5, Walt Disney World Mechanical Supervisor Interview July 9, 2009

#029: UNDERSTAND PEOPLE WHO SPEAK ENGLISH WITH A STRONG ACCENT

TIGHTEN UP YOUR WIG. From the 1968 release "The Second" Words and music by John Kay

A short dramedy by Jeri Weiss

Life without Library Systems?

beetle faint furry mind rid severe shiver terrified 1. The word ' ' describes something that has a lot of hair, like a cat or a rabbit.

Conversation on a Rock. (1215 words)

Master Read-Along Script. The Perfect Touch. by Eli Glass. Important Notice! This page must be the first page of all copies of this master script!

CANDI WITH AN I By Macee Binns

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

Carl Wiser (Songfacts): We got an with some great pictures from the '70s of the Bella Vista.

MITOCW big_picture_integrals_512kb-mp4

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR PRINCE GEORGE'S COUNTY, MARYLAND

Chapter 1 Kirren Island. Blood Ties - Introduction

Liberty View Elementary. Social Smarts

GREETINGS. When you enter a room, see someone you know or meet someone new, it is polite to greet him or her. To greet someone, you:

For more material and information, please visit Tai Lieu Du Hoc at American English Idioms.

Cady: Hi. I don't know if anyone told you about me. I'm a new student here. My name is Cady Heron.

Stop it! KATHERINE: Dr. Switzer? DR. SWITZER: Yes, come in. I'm just washing. my hands. KATHERINE: I'm Katherine Bigmans. Janet. Carlisle referred me.

The Aesthetic of Frank Oppenheimer

Transcription:

STATE OF NEVADA OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL RENO, NEVADA TRANSCRIPT OF ELECTRONICALLY-RECORDED INTERVIEW HOWARD ROSENBERG AUGUST, 01 RENO, NEVADA Transcribed and proofread by: CAPITOL REPORTERS BY: Michel Loomis 0 North Curry Street Carson City, Nevada 0 () - 1

A P P E A R A N C E S Office of the Attorney General: Jennifer Davies, Deputy Chief Investigator 0 Kietzke Lane Reno, NV jdavies@ag.nv.gov Robison, Belaustegui, Sharp & Low By: Kent Robison, Esq. 1 Washington Street Reno, NV 0 Maupin, Cox & Legoy By: Michael E. Malloy, Esq. Caughlin Parkway Reno, NV 1

RENO, NEVADA, TUESDAY, AUGUST, 01, :00 P.M. -o0o- 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 MS. DAVIES: Okay. Today's date is August th, 01. The time is approximately :00 p.m., and this is an interview taking place at the law offices of Kent Robison at 1 Washington Street in Reno, Nevada. Present in this interview is myself, Jennifer Davies, Deputy Chief Investigator, along with Mike Malloy and Trustee Howard Rosenberg. And, Howard, you are aware that I am tape recording this? MR. ROSENBERG: Yes. MS. DAVIES: And I have your permission to do so? MR. ROSENBERG: Yes. So what I wanted to talk to you a little bit about today are the events that took place on July nd. So what we'll do is I'll kind of let you go through the events, and then we'll go back and kind of break them down a little bit for some specifics. A. Okay. Q. So if you want to just go ahead and start. A. It was a workshop day. We began at, as I remember, :00. First was ethics training from the -- oh,

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 good Lord. Karla -- I can't remember her last name. She's the director of the ethics commission. MR. MALLOY: It doesn't matter. MS. DAVIES: Yeah. MR. ROSENBERG: Okay. Yeah. In any case, it was about hour and a half, then we took a break. Then we had the workshop with the BoardDocs people. They are a group that puts your minutes online and, if you know how, can you access minutes from any time in the past, and they were trying to show us how to use this, which was a complete waste of time for me. I (inaudible) like I remember yesterday. Then we took another break, and -- a few minutes, as I remember, Barbara came back into the room and said that there was going to be a closed session with our attorney and asked everybody else to leave. If I remember, we were all sitting where we would normally sit. So it was a long thingamajig. I was closest to the door over here. Pedro was in the room, as I remember, and hit us from a bolt out of the blue about someone had called and said that Pedro was misrepresenting himself as a CPA and that there was a real problem, and we needed to handle this. Pedro said there was a misunderstanding and that this was not, indeed, the case at all. And as I remember -- it's been a little bit. As I remember, he left to go out and come back and bring us a copy of his -- what do you call that,

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 his diploma from the University of Illinois -- A. -- saying that he was indeed a CPA. There were -- he made copies for each of us, and then I'm not exactly sure when or how, but he left the room. Randy explained to us at the very beginning while Pedro was still there that this was a meeting between the trustees and their attorney. We could discuss. We could ask for information, but under no circumstances was any action to be taken. And I asked him point blank. I said, "Are we violating the open meeting law?" He said, "Absolutely not. You don't have to worry about that. If, indeed, you're even coming close, I'll stop you before you get there." A. So I was relatively comfortable. When she said that it was a closed meeting, I thought that it was going to be to talk about something else. I had no idea that any of this had transpired. Q. And when you're talking about "this," you're talking this CPA issue? A. The CPA issue. Yes. A. That was the bolt out of the blue. Q. Was it President Clark who -- who said to the --

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 the trustees and the other officers that that was the issue that needed to be addressed or discussed? A. It was either her or Mr. Drake, and I'm not sure which. I think it was Barbara. A. I think it was Barbara. And it was very straightforward. There was a complaint that had come in from someone. We needed to get to the bottom of it, and that's what we were doing. All right. So Pedro left the room, and Barbara said that we really needed to talk about this. Do we need to make this a public meeting? She felt that, indeed, we did. They were mostly shocked more than anything else. I didn't know what to ask. It went -- Randy was asked some questions about legalities. This was of sufficient kind of importance that it needed to be an open meeting in which, you know, we were legitimately able to discuss this and possibly take action. At that particular point, we couldn't. It went back and forth for a bit. There were legal questions as to whether or not the diploma was enough to do what Mr. Martinez obviously thought that it did. There were others that said, "But that's in Illinois. That's not in the State of Nevada," you know, and back and forth. So Barbara said, "We need to go talk with Pedro.

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 This needs to be an open meeting. I think we need to talk with him about that." She got up, as I remember, Barbara McLaury said, "Well, you're not going to go down there alone. I'll go with you." And Lisa Ruggerio, who's the clerk, also said, "I'll go with you too." And Randy went with them, and they went to talk to Mr. Martinez. MR. MALLOY: Is that where you want to pause, then, and take a -- MS. DAVIES: Yeah, we can do that. We can kind of -- and that will break it up. It might be a little bit easier. MR. MALLOY: So we're at the end of the meeting -- the legal gathering. MR. ROSENBERG: Yes. MR. MALLOY: For the time being. MR. ROSENBERG: Yeah. Yeah. MR. MALLOY: Okay. Q. So President Clark says initially, "We need to have a closed session" and asks all other staff to leave? A. Yes. Q. And then mentions that there had been this complaint. And I just want to make sure, prior to that

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 moment where she informs the trustees and the officers that the complaint was regarding a CPA issue -- A. Um-hum. Q. -- had you been aware of this anonymous complaint prior to that day? A. No. A. Absolutely not. Q. Had you been aware of any sort of investigation internally that had been conducted by anybody on the Board to kind of vet out whether to prove or disprove the -- A. No. A. No. Q. So Pedro shows the Board -- A. Right. Q. -- his certificates. A. Right. Q. How was his demeanor at that point? A. He was agitated. A. Well, I mean, that's understandable. Come on. Q. Sure. A. But everything was more or less okay. I mean, he just handed everybody the thing. I read it, and I'm not a

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 lawyer. I don't understand these things. I never have. It doesn't say certificate of CPA, you know. It's a little bit strange to look at it. And I was, quite frankly, in shock. Q. And you say "in shock." In shock of what? A. The whole thing. This came out of the blue. I was -- I had been -- I had been worried about the way situations are handled, but I don't like to see anybody hurt under any circumstances. There's a humane way of handling everything. So, now, calm it down and we'll get to this. But I knew nothing about it before. I wasn't prepared for it, and it just hit me. So then at this point, President Clark, Vice President McLaury -- A. McLaury. Q. -- and then Clerk Ruggerio leave with Counsel Drake -- A. Yes. Q. -- and go to Superintendent Martinez's office? A. Yes. Q. You were not present -- A. No. Q. -- for any of that? A. No. You stayed back in the board room with -- A. Stayed in the board room, very definitely.

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 Q. With the other two trustees? A. There was Mr. Mayer and Mr. Aiazzi. A. The three of us. At what point, then, do you the officers and counsel come back to the Board? A. I can't tell you how much time. It was a while. A. And then they came back in. Q. And what was discussed when they came back in? A. All this stuff is tough on me. Q. That's okay. A. Naturally, Mr. Martinez was very upset. He wasn't -- he didn't understand what was going on. "If you want me to go, you can buy me out of my contract," you know, that kind of thing. And I'm saying to myself, "No, nobody wants to do that. Relax." Q. Now, let me ask you -- let me stop you for a second. Did Superintendent Martinez come back -- A. No. Q. -- into the board room to say or to share that, or was that information that was shared with you -- A. When -- when the officers and Mr. Drake were -- Who shared that information that that was

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 what Pedro wanted? A. I don't -- Q. Do you remember? A. I don't remember. But it was shared to the trustees and the officers that it was Pedro's intention to get -- buy -- A. Right. Q. -- out of his contract? A. Right. So then what happened after -- what took place after that? A. It was -- Mr. Drake went back and forth a number of times. The -- I don't want to say negotiations, but, you know, who's going to do what and how much is it going to cost and all that kind of business went back and forth and back and forth. And most everybody was just like -- so I said, "Can I go and talk with him?" "Absolutely not." Q. Who did you ask? A. Everybody. And Ruggerio practically sat in my lap. A. The toughest thing in the world to do with me is when I see somebody that's in danger of getting hurt, I want to help. And there are times when you should just keep your big mouth shut. This is not one of my strong suits.

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 But Randy looked at me and he said, "Howard, it would not be a good idea." So I sat down and behaved myself. During that period of time, there was kind of -- like you said, there was negotiations back and forth between the trustees and the officers and -- A. Randy was going back and forth. A. Okay. Q. Can you describe to me the environment or kind of what was going on in the room and how the trustees and the officers, you know, reached a decision to give back to Randy to take to Pedro or how did that go? MR. MALLOY: You said how they reached the decision. MS. DAVIES: Okay. MR. MALLOY: You need to ask if they reached a decision. MS. DAVIES: Okay. Q. How did the discussion take place? A. This is what is so confusing to me. I was aware that I'm not supposed to say: What do you think? So I couldn't. So everybody's trying to read everybody else without actually saying anything. And we're looking at each other. Barbara McLaury

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 is practically in tears. John is sitting there -- I mean, he's -- I'm not going to say catatonic, but he's damn close to it. I'm looking at Dave, and Dave's looking at me, and we don't say another thing. And I can't remember, it might have been me saying, "Randy, go back and see", you know, "This is going way too fast. Calm everything down. We can take care of this." And Randy tried a couple of times. There was -- at one point, somebody was trying to do the numbers. Q. Do you remember who that was? A. No, I don't. A. It wasn't me because I can't add two and two. I can't remember who it was, but I know that I said to myself when they were -- that it was close to $0,000. That's a great deal of money. And it's taxpayers' money. Why don't we just, you know, cool it down. I wish I could run other things in sequence. I never can. Now, if it's a movie, I can do it. Q. And what I'm trying to kind of figure out is how -- and you had said that there was -- everybody was trying to kind of read each other without saying anything. A. Right. Well, I mean, we were talking to each other. Q. Sure, sure.

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 A. But we were also mindful of the open meeting law. Q. So what I'm trying to figure out is how the information goes back and forth and -- and how, if a decision is made, to offer -- A. No. Q. -- Pedro -- A. What was happening -- what was happening was Randy would go to Pedro, Pedro would say whatever he said to Randy. Randy would come back and say that, you know, and tell everybody. One or two people -- never -- and I say this in all sincerity and honesty. No one ever said, "What shall we do?" A. Ever. The thing was Randy would come back with figures, and everybody would just be, you know, that kind of thing. MR. MALLOY: That doesn't show on the tape. MR. ROSENBERG: Sort of shaking their heads. Nobody knew what to say. A. Honestly. I mean, forget the open meeting law and everything else. This is a human being that we know. I mean, there are times I'm so mad at him, I would like to kill him, and I'm sure he feels the same way about me. But he's a 1

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 human being. Come on. Calm it down. We'll get through this. Most of us are just so, I think, shocked at the whole situation. A. I mean, where did this come from? Out of nowhere. Q. So did you at any time share with Randy Drake that maybe we should offer him a certain amount? A. No, no. Do you remember any other trustee or -- A. Nope. Q. -- saying, "We should offer him -- A. Nope. Q. -- "this"? A. Nope. Nope. A. Because Randy had told us, as I remember, "This is all stipulated in his contract. If you're going to do this kind of a situation, it's" -- "it's stipulated in his contract." Okay. Fine. It's stipulated in his contract. I don't know what the contract says. MR. MALLOY: Say that a little louder, please. MR. ROSENBERG: I don't know what the contract says. I'm a trustee. I should know. But I didn't. I have read it now four times. I don't understand it. I'm sorry. 1

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 Q. That's okay. And the contract is, you know, it's not of issue here. A. Okay. Q. What I was trying to figure out is, you know, how you go from Pedro saying, "I want this" and Randy comes back and says, "Pedro wants this," and then he goes back to -- Randy goes back to Pedro with something different. I'm trying to figure out how Randy gets the information to go back to Pedro. A. I honest to goodness couldn't tell you exactly. A. I don't remember. Q. And if you don't remember, you don't know, then I can't -- I can't beat it out of you. A. Well, you can try. Q. And so -- MR. MALLOY: Just don't worry about it. MR. ROSENBERG: Jennifer, I'm 0 years old. I can't remember. MS. DAVIES: He says he's 0 years old. MR. ROSENBERG: You have to go blab, thanks a lot. I have a problem. 1

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 Q. No, I understand. So at what point -- and I'm -- not necessarily time wise, but how does that portion of the gathering or that event end? A. As I remember, they tried -- some people went out into the corridor, and Pedro was leaving. Okay. Fine. Where are you going? But nobody knew what to say. But he was -- he was leaving. All right. Fine. He left. So we decided that we needed to move into someplace a little bit more secure, especially where sound is concerned, because that room leads right directly onto the main entrance of the building. A. And I -- I think it was Barbara who said, "I think we need to get down to Pedro's office." A. "It's more secure, and we'll be able to talk more." I was still sitting there. I can remember this. I was still sitting there. Everybody was out the door, and David looked at me and said, "Are you coming?" I mean, I was like -- I got up, naturally, and went after them. We were sitting around the table, trying to decide: Do we -- you know, do we make a statement? How do we tell the staff what's happening? You know, that kind of 1

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 thing. And that was the nuts and bolts kind of stuff that they were discussing. Q. And you were -- the trustees and the officers were discussing this in -- A. In Pedro's office. Yes. Q. And he was -- he had left the building? A. Yes. A. Yeah. Q. So what happens then after that discussion? You guys discuss do you need to make a statement. A. Yes. Q. Do we -- who do we need to tell? A. The first thing was to get the Communications people in -- A. -- as quickly as possible. And then Tracy Davis, who's the academic side of the house, and Kristin McNeel, who's the operations side of the house, they had to know what had happened. A. What happens if he doesn't come back and that kind of business. That never bothered me. That's why you have the line of succession that you have. You have the

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 superintendent, the deputy superintendent and so on. Q. Did you believe that he was not going to come back? A. No, absolutely not. But I'm a teacher. I've been a teacher for years. I know that no one is responsible for the entire operation. So, in my mind, calm down a bit. It will be taken care of. There are people here who know what they're doing, and they'll do their jobs. Let's get this straightened away first, and framing what we were going to say was very important. So who -- who was present -- actually, I take that back. Were you present when President Clark told Deputy Superintendent Tracy Davis about the events that had just taken place? A. I don't remember being there. I don't. Were you present during the time when President Clark told Chief of Staff Kristin McNeel about the events that took place? A. I don't -- I don't remember being there. As I remember, I was outside of Mr. Martinez's office. There is an old-fashioned desk and chair that you and I used to go to school in back in the year, and I was sitting there. Just -- people have to tell me, "Howard, come in here." I mean, I was -- I'm still -- 1

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 A. This doesn't happen. This does not happen. It's not good for the kids. It's not good for any of us. A. I'm afraid I should know better. I'm older. Q. So then were you in that annex area when President Clark was talking to Tracy Davis and Kristin McNeel? A. I'm not sure. A. I was in that area, so yes, she might have been. A. But I remember coming in and opening the refrigerator, getting a Diet Pepsi and not being able to open it. MR. MALLOY: You have your answer. She doesn't need to -- MS. DAVIES: Right. Right. Absolutely. MR. ROSENBERG: I don't know what the hell happened. Q. Were you ever present during a conversation with President Clark and Superintendent Martinez regarding what -- what the outcome or possible events in the future were going to be -- A. No. 0

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 Q. -- with -- A. No. A. They wouldn't let me. Q. With his employment? A. Right. No. They wouldn't let me. A. I'm not kidding you. Lisa was practically sitting on me. A. Which was not unpleasant. That's a little over (inaudible). MR. MALLOY: (Inaudible) saying, Howard. MR. ROSENBERG: I'm not older (inaudible). MS. DAVIES: It's on two tapes now. MR. ROSENBERG: Oh, good, good. We'll have a little blackmail going. MR. MALLOY: We digressed. MS. DAVIES: We did. MR. MALLOY: That's all right. Q. So you had mentioned earlier that, during the meeting when you guys were in the board -- when the trustees and the officers were in the board room, that Randy Drake had given legal advice. 1

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 A. Um-hum. Q. And I don't want to know what it is. A. Okay. Q. It's just a "yes" or "no" question. A. Yes. Q. At some point either before -- during these events, did Randy Drake give you as a trustee or the trustees and the officers legal advice? A. He told us -- MR. MALLOY: Just a "yes" or "no" question. MR. ROSENBERG: Yes. As to what you could or couldn't do? A. Yes. So at what point -- kind of try and wrap up the day. At what point did all of this kind of end? A. I remember being in Pedro's office. Eileen was here. Michelle was there, and what we were trying to do is craft an announcement that could be made that would do what we needed to do, but keep it as calm and comfortable as is humanly possible. A. And it was wordsmithing the announcement because we knew, naturally, that the newspapers and the television people would want a statement.

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 And I know personally that I need to be very careful what I say to newspapers and to television people, because I've gotten myself into trouble up to my elbows. So I simply look at them and say, "No comment," and they don't believe me because Rosenberg always has a comment. So all I was interested is, what do we do? Then the decision -- there was a decision made that we would all stand behind Barbara while she was making this. Q. And what you're referring to is the public statement -- A. Right. Q. -- to the press? A. Yes. Yes. Were you present during the statement that President Clark made to the leadership team back -- I believe it was back in the board room? MR. MALLOY: So the question is just whether he was there? MS. DAVIES: Correct. MR. ROSENBERG: Yes, I think I was. MS. DAVIES: Okay. MR. ROSENBERG: Yes. Yes, I was. Q. Do you remember what was -- what President Clark said to the leadership team?

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 A. No. MR. MALLOY: The answer was -- MR. ROSENBERG: No. But -- but I can't remember exactly. The gist of it was in the next days, do your jobs, please. Take care of the kids. That's all we were interested in. Do you remember anything specifically about Superintendent Martinez and what had just happened? A. No. MR. MALLOY: What do you mean by that? I didn't understand your question. MS. DAVIES: He says that he remembers President Clark saying, you know, do your job. Take care of the kids. And so I was trying to find out if he remembers anything that she said about whether Superintendent Martinez was on administrative leave -- MR. ROSENBERG: No. MS. DAVIES: -- if his contract had been terminated -- MR. ROSENBERG: No, no. MS. DAVIES: -- anything specific --

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 MR. ROSENBERG: No. No. No. A. No. (Inaudible). Q. That's okay. I sometimes don't remember yesterday. MR. MALLOY: Yeah, I remember things that happened 0 years ago, but I don't remember what happened 0 minutes ago, usually. So don't worry about it. Q. So all of the trustees and the officers made an agreement -- made the decision to stand behind -- A. Yes. Q. -- President Clark at the press conference? A. At the press conference. Do you remember what she said at the press conference? A. No, I don't. It was a crafted piece. I should have brought it with me, but I never thought to do it, and she read it. A. But I don't remember what was said. Q. Do you remember any of the questions or anything that came from the press to -- A. Yes, yes.

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 A. "Is he fired?" That was the first one. "No." "Has this got anything to do with the Mike Mieras situation?" "No. They're two totally different things." And there were a bunch of other stuff. "What are you going to do now," you know, that kind of business. But no. There was one question that she was asked, and she said, "That's something that we can't discuss." I don't remember what the question was. A. I thought she handled it well. This was rough. I wouldn't have been able to do it. Let's jump ahead to the July th meeting that took place here at counsel's office. A. Okay. Q. Were you aware of a statement that President Clark made on July 1st regarding the events that had taken place the prior week? MR. MALLOY: You're confusing me because you said, "Let's jump to the th," and you're asking him something that happened two days later. Q. The meeting on the th -- A. Right. Q. -- that ultimately resulted in a statement being

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 made by President Clark on July 1st. A. I don't remember. Did you ever read a statement from President Clark in regards to Superintendent Martinez returning to work? A. Not that I remember. Not that I remember. I get e-mails and I scan them. I don't read the newspaper. I burn it as quickly as I see it. I said it, and I'll stand by it. MR. MALLOY: How do you feel about that? MS. DAVIES: Exactly. Right? Q. So how did you learn that Superintendent Martinez was returning to work? A. I remember we discussed here ramifications and all that kind of business. MR. MALLOY: I don't want you to discuss, please, the content of your discussions with Mr. Robison. MR. ROSENBERG: Right. MR. MALLOY: If she asks you "yes" and "no" questions -- MR. ROSENBERG: Okay. MR. MALLOY: -- we'll deal with each one as they come up. MR. ROSENBERG: Okay. How do I handle it now? Ask me another question.

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 Q. Did you learn of -- of Superintendent Martinez returning to work from the meeting that you had on the th here at counsel's office? MR. MALLOY: So I think if I may paraphrase your question -- MS. DAVIES: Yes. MR. MALLOY: -- is that right? MS. DAVIES: Yeah. MR. MALLOY: With your permission. MS. DAVIES: Yeah. MR. MALLOY: I think Jennifer is asking you if you recall that Pedro Martinez returned to work on August 1st -- MS. DAVIES: Yes. MR. MALLOY: -- as a result of the statement put out by the president on July 1st. Correct? MS. DAVIES: Correct. MR. MALLOY: Okay. MR. ROSENBERG: Yes. Yes. MS. DAVIES: Okay. MR. ROSENBERG: Yeah. Q. So -- okay. But you were not aware of the statement being

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 crafted? A. I -- I was aware that something was going to come. A. But I had no idea what. There we go. In reference to a court filing from Kent Robison regarding some deficiencies -- current deficiencies, I believe, of Superintendent Martinez, are you aware of that court filing? A. Yes. Are you aware of the deficiencies that -- A. No, I don't know which they might have put in. Are you aware of, at this point, any deficiencies that Superintendent Martinez has at this time? A. Sure. We all have deficiencies. Q. Any that would -- never mind. MR. MALLOY: Were you asking him what they are? Q. Do you know what they are? A. I know what I think they are. Q. What do you think his current deficiencies are? MR. ROSENBERG: Can I say that? MR. MALLOY: Yes. MR. ROSENBERG: Okay. He treats the Board with

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 complete contempt. By his own admission, he will talk to groups of people on the Board, but not to all of us. There are some people -- he's divisive in that way. I'm not saying that he means to be, but it happens. There's a certain lack of empathy and compassion. Human beings make mistakes. When they do, you put it right as best you can, but you don't go after them with an ax. He tends to do that. He doesn't know as much about education as he thinks he does. There is a directive to members of the faculty and staff: No one is to speak to a member of the Board of Trustees because, quote -- this is what I've been told -- "They will stab you in the back," end quote. MR. MALLOY: You're saying that's what he said. MR. ROSENBERG: Yes. MR. MALLOY: Not what the Board said. MR. ROSENBERG: No. That's what he said. For me, the culture of fear in that place is bad, really bad. It's all numbers. Teachers don't teach by numbers, they teach by the individual kid as best you can. So I find it very, very difficult. We have not had a one on one meeting -- I think it's in a year. MR. MALLOY: When you say "we," are you talking 0

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 about you individually or the Board? MR. ROSENBERG: No, me individually and Pedro -- with Pedro. MR. MALLOY: All right. MR. ROSENBERG: We're supposed to, as I understand it, meet at the very least one on one quarterly. Let me ask you specifically: There was a comment that you made, I believe, to the media that -- that these had -- that this had -- had deeper issues than a CPA issue. A. Yes. Q. What were you speaking of? A. His behavior in response to it. It accelerated. I mean, he went -- as far as I could tell from what I'm hearing, he went completely ballistic. He was -- they -- he wasn't tracking more than anything else. It was bad enough that we had the situation, but all attempts to calm the situation down, he wasn't having any. Q. So when you spoke of the, quote/unquote, deeper issues -- A. Right. Q. -- you were speaking of Superintendent -- A. Right. Q. -- Martinez's behavior? 1

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 A. Yes. During the entire event on the nd? A. Yeah. Okay. One last question, and I -- and I know you -- I believe you already answered it, but I just want to clarify: What was your impression at the end of the day of the -- the events that unfolded? Did you believe that Superintendent Martinez was going to be back to work the next day? Did you believe that he -- A. I think I believed at that time that there was going to be more discussion. As I understand what happened afterwards, Mr. Martinez made phone calls and told the world that he had been fired. He hadn't been fired. Nobody wanted to fire him. And from there, it just sort of -- then we can't say anything. So what do you do? And, you know, when somebody's looking at you and saying you're a bad person and you're dreadful, you want to justify it, and you can't. And for me, it's been really, really difficult. I've been in this town for a long, long time, and a lot of people that I thought knew me and knew me well don't, evidently. That's frightening. Disappointing. I'm going to cry is what's going to happen. Idiot.

1 1 1 1 1 0 1 MR. MALLOY: Don't worry about it, Howard. MR. ROSENBERG: I'm supposed to be a grown-up. MR. MALLOY: Well, we all cry or we all get upset. No worries. MR. ROSENBERG: Let me put it to you this way. In every situation, there's three sides to every story: Your side, my side and the truth. It doesn't mean anybody's lying. It simply means we're seeing things differently. If we can just get to the middle, then a lot of people can avoid being hurt, and I don't want to see anybody hurt. Pedro's a young man. He doesn't need this. We don't need it. There. MS. DAVIES: Okay. I think I don't have any -- any other questions at this time. Mike, do you? MR. MALLOY: No, I don't. MS. DAVIES: Okay. Howard, do you have any questions for me? MR. ROSENBERG: No. All can I say to you is I never would willingly break the open meeting law. I've been taught better than that. My attorney would kill me. MR. MALLOY: I wouldn't. That wasn't me. MS. DAVIES: That wasn't you. MR. MALLOY: It wasn't. MR. ROSENBERG: It's Bill Bileu. I'll say it. I

don't care. MS. DAVIES: So at this time, I will go ahead and end the interview. The time is approximately : p.m. It is August th, 01. (Proceedings concluded.) 1 1 1 1 1 0 1

STATE OF NEVADA, ) ) ss. CARSON CITY. ) I, Michel Loomis, do hereby certify: That on August, 01, an interview was held in the within-entitled matter in the office of Attorney General. That said interview was recorded, and said CD-ROM was delivered to me for transcription; That the foregoing transcript, consisting of pages 1 through, is a full, true and correct transcript of said recorded CD-ROM performed to the best of my ability. 1 1 August, 01. Dated at Carson City, Nevada, this 1st day of 1 1 1 Michel Loomis, Transcriber 0 1