REQUEST FOR NEW COURSE

Similar documents
Bergen Community College Division of Business, Arts, and Social Sciences Department of the Performing Arts. Course Syllabus. MUS-106 World Music

MUH 2051: Music Cultures of the World Fall pm-1pm

Keyboard Area Handbook for Undergraduate and Graduate Students in Applied Keyboard Courses

Music Appreciation Course Syllabus Fall 2014

Introduction to World Music Fall 2011 Instructor: Lindsey Macchiarella Office: Longmire #401 Hours: Monday and Wednesday from 9-11am

Music Appreciation Course Syllabus Fall 2016

Syllabus for MUS 300--Music Appreciation 3 Credit Hours Fall The purpose of this course is to enable the student to do the following:

Course Proposal for Revised General Education Courses MUS 2555G INTERACTING WITH MUSIC

PSYCHOLOGY APPLICATION DEADLINES

Syllabus for MUS Music Appreciation 3 Credit Hours Spring 2016

PELLISSIPPI STATE COMMUNITY COLLEGE MASTER SYLLABUS EAR TRAINING III MUS Class Hours: 1.0 Credit Hours: 1.0

COURSE APPROVAL DOCUMENT Southeast Missouri State University. Department: The Conservatory of Theatre and Dance Course No. TH 401

MUS-111 History of American Popular Music

Functional Piano MUSI 1181 Mondays & Wednesdays FALL 2018

San José State University School of Music and Dance MUSC 147A, Beginning Conducting, Fall 2014

MUSC 1313-PB3 MUSIC IN CONTEMPORARY LIFE SUMMER II, 2017

Music Education Choral C50206BM Voice, Keyboard or Guitar

CASPER COLLEGE COURSE SYLLABUS MUSC 1041:01 Music Theory II for Musical Theatre. Lecture Hours: 3 Lab Hours: 0 Credit Hours: 3

Coastal Carolina University Faculty Senate Consent Agenda March 4, 2015 COLLEGE OF HUMANITIES AND FINE ARTS

Alcorn State University SACSCOC Documentation

BACHELOR OF MUSICAL ARTS

DEPARTMENT OF FINE ARTS

Music World Music - the art of listening -

I. Introduction Assessment Plan for Ph.D. in Musicology & Ethnomusicology School of Music, College of Fine Arts

STUDENT HANDBOOK FOR THE UNDERGRADUATE MUSIC MAJOR TABLE OF CONTENTS

COWLEY COLLEGE & Area Vocational Technical School

MUSI 1306 Music Appreciation 3 Creative Arts MUSI 1306

Music 111 Music Appreciation I, 3 Units

ILLINOIS VALLEY COMMUNITY COLLEGE Course Syllabus for Music 1000

Westminster College School of Music Fall, 2018

Music majors and minors should identify themselves as such at the start of the course.

OAKTON COMMUNITY COLLEGE INTRO TO WORLD MUSIC SYLLABUS

San José State University School of Music and Dance MUSC 147C, Advanced Choral Conducting, Spring 2015

MUSIC INTRODUCTION TO MUSIC THEORY COURSE OUTLINE Section #1240 Monday and Wednesday 8:30-11:00AM

WOODWIND AREA POLICY HANDBOOK DIVISION OF INSTRUMENTAL STUDIES COLLEGE OF MUSIC THE UNIVERSITY OF NORTH TEXAS

RECITAL KIT : POLICIES AND PROCEDURES

UCF Degree Programs. UNIVERSITY OF CENTRAL FLORIDA Undergraduate Catalog

UCSC Summer Session MUSIC 11D Introduction to World Music. Class Times: TTH 1:00 4:30 pm Class Location: Music Center 138 (DARC 340 July10 21)

Syllabus: PHYS 1300 Introduction to Musical Acoustics Fall 20XX

Los Angeles Valley College MUS 200: INTRO TO MUSIC THEORY

PETITION/PROGRAM SHEET Degree: Bachelor of Arts Major: Music Performance

University of Florida Jazz Band Syllabus and Student Handbook (MUN 1710, MUN 3713 and MUN 6715 ) Fall Website:

MUSIC 140A/B -- Principal Applied Study. Twelve 50-minute private lessons per semester on the principal instrument.

DEPARTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY GEOG3811 POLITICAL GEOGRAPHY FALL 2016

Music 111 Music Appreciation I, 3 Units

MUT 4366 JAZZ ARRANGING 2 (offered Spring)

MU 123 Fall 20xx SURVEY OF WORLD MUSIC Course Syllabus

Syllabus for MUS 201 Harmony, Sight Singing, and Ear Training III Fall 1999

Graduate Bulletin PSYCHOLOGY

SCHOOL OF MUSIC. The School of Music: Mission, Vision, and Values Mission. Academic Programs

Functional Piano MUSI 1180 Monday, Wednesday Sessions FALL Course Number, Section Number, and Course Title: MUSI 1180 Functional Piano

I. Introduction Assessment Plan for M.A. in Musicology School of Music, College of Fine Arts

EASTERN ARIZONA COLLEGE Elementary Theory

MUT 4366 JAZZ ARRANGING 2

SOUTH DAKOTA BOARD OF REGENTS. Academic and Student Affairs Consent ******************************************************************************

Syllabus Woodwind Studios: MUAP 3201/3202 Fall 2018

REQUIRED INITIAL ORIENTATION SESSION ONCAMPUS: Friday Sept. 6, 6 to 8 pm 305 DSC. Attendance at this is mandatory to remain in the course!

COURSE SYLLABUS VOICE STUDIO Spring 2017 APPLIED MUSIC MVV 1411, 2421, , 6661

Syllabus Woodwind Studios: MUAP 1202/2202 Spring 2018

The doctor of musical arts curriculum in conducting prepares students for careers in higher education and in the professional world.

TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY-COMMERCE MUSIC DEPARTMENT APPLIED MUSIC: VOICE JENNIFER GLIDDEN, INSTRUCTOR COURSE SYLLABUS

Required text: Scott Deveaux & Gary Giddens, Jazz: Essential Listening (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, Inc., 2011). ISBN:

TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY-COMMERCE MUSIC DEPARTMENT APPLIED MUSIC: VOICE LEANNE SCAGGS, INSTRUCTOR COURSE SYLLABUS, FALL 2016

MUSIC 111 -Learning How to Listen-

Eastern Kentucky University Department of Music Syllabus for MUS , Musicianship I, CRN T/TH 11:00-11:50 1 Credit Hour Fall 2012

Department of Music. Music Student Handbook

Syllabus MUS Piano Class I page 1

Course Revision Form : Entry # 82

CENTRAL TEXAS COLLEGE MUSI 1301 FUNDAMENTALS OF MUSIC. Semester Hours Credit: 3

COWLEY COLLEGE & Area Vocational Technical School

Syllabus Woodwind Studios: MUAP 1201/2201 Spring 2018

School of Music. General Requirements for Undergraduate Majors. School of Music

CORO Choral Institute & Simpson College. Master of Music in Choral Conducting Program Details

15. Proposed Implementation Date Term: Fall, Year: None Any non-w section? 19. Terms Offered Semester: Fall Spring Year: Every_Year

HANDBOOK FOR GRADUATE STUDENTS IN MUSICOLOGY

WEST TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY School of Music. Applied Voice Requirements Rev. 2018

Collaborative Piano. Degrees Offered. Degree Requirements. Collaborative Piano 1

Music Theory. Degree Offered. Degree Requirements. Major Learning Outcomes MUSIC THEORY. Music Theory 1. Master of Music in Music Theory

WEEK 2 DAY 3 1. Historical Topics Covered a. Gender in American Popular Music b. Producers of Rock n Roll 2. Rise of the Tape Recorder Review

Functional Piano MUSI 1181 FALL Office Hours: See Instructor for appointment

MUS-119 Songwriting Workshop

American Music (MUSI 1310) Spring, 2016 HCC Distance Education

LEARNING OUTCOMES: After completing the requirements of this course, the student will be able to make decisions about children and books by:

SOUTH DAKOTA BOARD OF REGENTS ACADEMIC AFFAIRS FORMS

PELLISSIPPI STATE TECHNICAL COMMUNITY COLLEGE MASTER SYLLABUS TECHNICAL VIDEO PRODUCTION II VPT 1300

DEPARTMENT OF FINE ARTS

MUSIC (MU) Music (MU) 1

Performance Dates on Jazz Band Website

HISTORY 3800 (The Historian s Craft), Spring :00 MWF, Haley 2196

University of Utah School of Music Music Musicianship I Fall 2018 Semester

VirtualSC. Course Detail. Course Name: Music Appreciation 1. Estimated Completion Time: weeks (Summer 8 weeks) Course Description

LSC 606 Cataloging and Classification Summer 2007

University of Florida School of Music Woodwind Skills 1 - Clarinet Section Course Syllabus

MU 419 Senior Recital Course Syllabus

B.M. IN MUSIC EDUCATION WITH MINOR IN EDUCATION

JMU SCHOOL OF MUSIC VOICE AREA GRADUATE HANDBOOK

Course Description (see end of syllabus for schedule of topics) MUS/SOA 281 Music, Technology, and Culture Credit Hours: 3 Fall 2009

DAA 3684 Dance Performance Spring Semester, 2017

CURRICULUM COMMITTEE ACTIONS

ORANGE COAST COLLEGE MUSIC 241 Piano 3 Course Syllabus Fall 2018

Transcription:

Request for New Course EASTERN MICHIGAN UNIVERSITY DIVISION OF ACADEMIC AFFAIRS REQUEST FOR NEW COURSE DEPARTMENT/SCHOOL: Music and Dance COLLEGE: CAS DEPARTMENT CONTACT: Marilyn Saker (Professor) on behalf of Christine Prince (Lecturer) CONTACT PHONE: 487 1284 CONTACT EMAIL: msaker@emich.edu REQUESTED START DATE: TERM WINTER YEAR 2013 A. Rationale/Justification for the Course Adding a new, fully online World Music course would expand the General Education offerings of the Department of Music and Dance, and support the University s emphasis on global awareness and education. The course presents a study of basic musical elements such as rhythm, pitch, melody, harmony, texture, and form, but in a way that is global in its inclusivity, encompassing cultural as well as purely musical themes. As students develop a familiarity with world music, they discover greater intercultural tolerance, and develop an appreciation of the common spirit of humanity that unites us all. B. Course Information 1. Subject Code and Course Number: MUSC 1XX 2. Course Title: World Music 3. Credit Hours: 3 4. Repeatable for Credit? Yes No X If Yes, how many total credits may be earned? "##$%&%'()#*+,-./0&/(1#23/4/&#&(#%00.(5/4%&+'6#7#8(.9,":;## # Designed for the non-music major, a study of the world s music. Basic musical concepts are used to explore diverse musical styles and their functions in cultures throughout the world. This course assumes no prior formal musical training. 6. Method of Delivery (Check all that apply.) a. Standard (lecture/lab) On Campus b. Fully Online X c. Hybrid/ Web Enhanced Off Campus 7. Grading Mode: Normal (A-E) X Credit/No Credit 8. Prerequisites: Courses that MUST be completed before a student can take this course. (List by Subject Code, Number and Title.) None Miller, New Course Sept. 09

New Course Form 9. Concurrent Prerequisites: Courses listed in #5 that MAY also be taken at the same time as a student is taking this course. (List by Subject Code, Number and Title.) None 10. Corequisites: Courses that MUST be taken at the same time as a student in taking this course. (List by Subject Code, Number and Title.) None 11. Equivalent Courses. A student may not earn credit for both a course and its equivalent. A course will count as a repeat if an equivalent course has already been taken. (List by Subject Code, Number and Title) None 12. Course Restrictions: a. Restriction by College. Is admission to a specific College Required? College of Business Yes No X College of Education Yes No X b. Restriction by Major/Program. Will only students in certain majors/programs be allowed to take this course? Yes No X If Yes, list the majors/programs c. Restriction by Class Level Check all those who will be allowed to take the course: Undergraduate Graduate All undergraduates X All graduate students Freshperson Certificate Sophomore Masters Junior Specialist Senior Doctoral Second Bachelor UG Degree Pending Post-Bac. Tchr. Cert. Low GPA Admit Note: If this is a 400-level course to be offered for graduate credit, attach Approval Form for 400-level Course for Graduate Credit. Only Approved for Graduate Credit undergraduate courses may be included on graduate programs of study. Note: Only 500-level graduate courses can be taken by undergraduate students. Undergraduate students may not register for 600-level courses d. Restriction by Permission. Will Departmental Permission be required? Yes No X (Note: Department permission requires the department to enter authorization for every student registering.) 13. Will the course be offered as part of the General Education Program? Yes X No Miller, New Course Sept. 09 Page 2 of 4

New Course Form If Yes, attach Request for Inclusion of a Course in the General Education Program: Education for Participation in the Global Community form. Note: All new courses proposed for inclusion in this program will be reviewed by the General Education Advisory Committee. If this course is NOT approved for inclusion in the General Education program, will it still be offered? Yes X No C. Relationship to Existing Courses Within the Department: 14. Will this course will be a requirement or restricted elective in any existing program(s)? Yes No X If Yes, list the programs and attach a copy of the programs that clearly shows the place the new course will have in the curriculum. Program Required Restricted Elective Program Required Restricted Elective 15. Will this course replace an existing course? Yes No X 16. (Complete only if the answer to #15 is Yes. ) a. Subject Code, Number and Title of course to be replaced: b. Will the course to be replaced be deleted? Yes No 17. (Complete only if the answer #16b is Yes. ) If the replaced course is to be deleted, it is not necessary to submit a Request for Graduate and Undergraduate Course Deletion. a. When is the last time it will be offered? Term Year b. Is the course to be deleted required by programs in other departments? Contact the Course and Program Development Office if necessary. Yes No c. If Yes, do the affected departments support this change? Yes No If Yes, attach letters of support. If No, attach letters from the affected department explaining the lack of support, if available. Outside the Department: The following information must be provided. Contact the Course and Program Development office for assistance if necessary. 18. Are there similar courses offered in other University Departments? Yes No X If Yes, list courses by Subject Code, Number and Title 19. If similar courses exist, do the departments in which they are offered support the proposed course? Yes No If Yes, attach letters of support from the affected departments. If No, attach letters from the affected department explaining the lack of support, if available. D. Course Requirements 20. Attach a detailed Sample Course Syllabus including: a. Course goals, objectives and/or student learning outcomes b. Outline of the content to be covered c. Student assignments including presentations, research papers, exams, etc. d. Method of evaluation e. Grading scale (if a graduate course, include graduate grading scale) f. Special requirements Miller, New Course Sept. 09 Page 3 of 4

New Course Form g. Bibliography, supplemental reading list h. Other pertinent information. NOTE: COURSES BEING PROPOSED FOR INCLUSION IN THE EDUCATION FOR PARTICIPATION IN THE GLOBAL COMMUNITY PROGRAM MUST USE THE SYLLABUS TEMPLATE PROVIDED BY THE GENERAL EDUCATION ADVISORY COMMITTEE. THE TEMPLATE IS ATTACHED TO THE REQUEST FOR INCLUSION OF A COURSE IN THE GENERAL EDUCATION PROGRAM: EDUCATION FOR PARTICIPATION IN THE GLOBAL COMMUNITY FORM. E. Cost Analysis (Complete only if the course will require additional University resources. Fill in Estimated Resources for the sponsoring department(s). Attach separate estimates for other affected departments.) Estimated Resources: Year One Year Two Year Three Faculty / Staff $ $ $ SS&M $ $ $ Equipment $ $ $ Total $ $ $ F. Action of the Department/School and College 1. Department/School Vote of faculty: For 20 Against 0 Abstentions 1 (Enter the number of votes cast in each category.) Diane L. Winder (signature on hard copy) February 6, 2012 Department Head/School Director Signature Date 2. College/Graduate School A. College College Dean Signature Date B. Graduate School (if Graduate Course) Graduate Dean Signature Date G. Approval Associate Vice-President for Academic Programming Signature Date Miller, New Course Sept. 09 Page 4 of 4

Sample Course Syllabus for MUSC 1XX, World Music (Fully Online) Catalog Course Description: Designed for the non-music major, a study of the world s music. Basic musical concepts are used to explore diverse musical styles and their functions in cultures throughout the world. This course assumes no prior formal musical training. General Education Rationale: World Music meets the Arts requirement for Knowledge of the Disciplines because students in this course learn the basic elements of music, such as rhythm, pitch, melody, harmony, texture, and form. These elements are brought to life and made accessible via a combination of musical examples and illustrations, which in turn give them the tools needed to enhance their critical perception of the world s music. World Music meets the Global Awareness requirement for Perspectives on a Diverse World because it takes a musicultural approach, consisting of an exploration of numerous musical traditions and the cultures from which they originated and where they continue to exist today. This approach allows students to engage with the complex realities of how music traditions move fluidly across conventional boundaries of history, geography, and identity. Course Goals and Objectives: The successful class participant will learn how the elements of music are applied to music of diverse cultures, and how the music is interwoven with the societies of those cultures. In addition, students will experience music as a global phenomenon of human expression, which will both increase their understanding of what music is and how it works, and their appreciation and enjoyment of music overall. Required Textbook and Materials: Bakan, Michael B. World Music Traditions and Transformations, 2 nd ed. McGraw-Hill, 2011. Bakan, Michael B. World Music Traditions and Transformations CD set, 2 nd ed. McGraw-Hill, 2011. Course Schedule: Week 1: Tutorial specific to this online course Week 2:

Introduction to World Music: What, in the World, is Music? We challenge the conventional notions of what music is: sounds and how they are arranged, human intention, how the term music is tied to Western Culture. Week 3: A Musicultural Approach The intersection of music as sound and music as culture. Ethnomusicology. Week 4: Rhythm and Pitch Introduce the four properties of tones. Explore rhythm in both familiar songs and in diverse world music traditions. Pitch and melody are explored in both Western and non- Western traditions. Week 5: Dynamics, Timbre, Instruments Introduce the elements that effect tones and how subjective tone quality is in Western Music. Discuss the four types of musical instruments, as well as the human voice. Week 6: Texture and Form Discover the relationships between different parts of a musical work. Examine several types of musical form. Midterm Examination Week 7: Balinese Gamelan Music Continuing the study of rhythm through the exploration of the musical, cultural, and social context of gamelan-based music traditions and the principal of interlocking rhythms. Week 8: Music of India Study the growth, musical and otherwise, of raga traditions. Explore how the classical tradition of Hindustani raga and the artistry of Ravi Shankar have combined with Western music styles. Week 9: Traditional Irish Music Explore traditional dance music and its transformations on multiple levels from dance tunes to Irish Rock World Music. Week 10: West African Music

Explore a wide range of African music as musical conversation, created through unique forms and modes. Week 11: Latin Dance Music Using the song Oye Como Va, we follow the path of Afro-Cuban ritual music through the 20th and into the 21st century. Week 12: Egypt and Beyond We take a journey through women s dance of Egypt and the music that accompanies it, including its unique percussion instruments and rhythms. We celebrate this cultural legacy and explore its social complexities. Week 13: Chinese Zheng Using events in Chinese history as a backdrop, we learn about the zheng and its music from 3rd century BCE through present day. Week 14: Music of Ancient Jewish Mystical Text Show the relationship between many different styles of Jewish music, and how the fundamental message of hope is woven within all of them across the centuries. Final Examination Course Policies and Procedures: Course Format: This course is organized into units comprised of any or all of the following: Introduction / Unit Focus / Reading Assignment / Key Terms / Written Assignment / Guided Listening Experience / Multimedia Activity / Threaded Discussion / Assessment and Examination. Participation: Students are expected to complete all assignments (reading, listening, and written), quizzes and examinations within the designated time frame. Late work will only be accepted in the case of extreme circumstances. You should plan on scheduling a minimum of 10 to 12 hours weekly for this course. Scheduling regular and specific times to work on course assignments will help to assure your success in this online class. Yes, you may work ahead in the course. Since face-to-face meetings are not possible in this type of course, a certain amount of online interaction (threaded discussions) becomes very important to make learning and assessment effective. As such, class participation is essential and will account for a significant portion of your grade.

Student Conduct Code: It is expected that all students will adhere to accepted codes of ethical, personal, and civil conduct when conversing online, using email, or engaging in threaded discussions. Failure to abide by such codes of conduct and etiquette may result in withdrawal from the course and a failing grade or temporary restriction of access to pertinent course components. For sake of clarity, please realize that the University and I cannot and will not be responsible for the content of any personal messages that are sent from one student directly to another student using the online email delivery system. I will be reviewing the content of all shared components of this course on a regular basis. All Class Discussion sections provide me with an ability to remove and/or edit content that you have submitted. Failure to abide by proper online etiquette will result in my emailing you about my concern and expecting an appropriate redirection of conduct. Grading Policy: It is your responsibility to review the Gradebook regularly throughout the semester and submit/complete the designated assignments and exams by the established deadlines. A passing grade will not be achieved by completing only the exams and quizzes. You will be assigned a final grade for this course based on the following criteria: 45% - Examinations and Quizzes 40% - Class Discussion Postings and Written Assignments 15% - Final Project A 94-100% A- 90-93% B+ 87-89% B 84-86% B- 80-83% C+ 77-79% C 74-76% C- 70-73% D+ 67-69% D 63-66% D- 60-62% Earning below a 60% average of the grading components will constitute a failing grade for the course. Academic Dishonesty: All forms of cheating, falsification, and/or plagiarism, will not be tolerated in this course and will result in a failing grade for the entire course. In addition, you may be referred to the Office of Student Judicial Services for discipline that can result in either a suspension or permanent dismissal. The Student Conduct Code

contains detailed definitions of what constitutes academic dishonesty, but if you are not sure about whether something you are doing would be considered academic dishonesty, consult with the instructor. You may access the Code online at www.emich.edu/sjs. Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA): The Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) is a Federal law designated to protect the privacy of a student s education records and academic work. The law applies to all schools and universities that receive funds under an applicable program of the U.S. Department of Education and is applicable to students at EMU. All files, records, and academic work completed within this course are considered educational records and are protected under FERPA. It is your right as a student in this course to expect that any materials you submit in this course as well as your name and other identifying information will not be viewable by guests or other individuals permitted access to the course. The exception will be only when you have given explicit, written, signed consent. Verbal consent or e-mail is insufficient. Special Needs Accommodations: If you wish to be accommodated for your disability, EMU Board of Regents Policy #8.3 requires that you first register with the Students with Disabilities Office (SWD) in 240K Student Center. You may contact SWD by telephone at (734) 487 2470. Students with disabilities are encouraged to register with SWD promptly as you will only be accommodated from the date you register with them forward. No retroactive accommodations are possible. Student and Exchange Visitor Statement (SEVIS): The Student Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS) requires F and J students to report the following to the Office of International Students, 244 Student Center within ten (10) days of the event: Changes in your name, local address, major field of study, or source of funding Changes in your degree-completion date Changes in your degree-level (ex. Bachelors to Masters) Intent to transfer to another school Prior permission from OIS is needed for the following: Dropping ALL courses as well as carrying or dropping BELOW minimum credit hours Employment on or off-campus Registering for more than one ONLINE course per term (F visa only) Endorsing I-20 or DS-2019 for re-entry into the USA Failure to report may result in the termination of your SEVIS record and even arrest and deportation. If you have questions or concerns, contact the Office of International Students at 734.487.3116, not the course instructor.

Appendix 1 Encountering Multiphonic Singing Written Assignment Rubric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riteria Unacceptable Acceptable Target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

Appendix 2 Eileen Ivers/Irish Music Threaded Discussion Rubric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riteria Unacceptable Acceptable Target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