Monterey County Assessment Appeals Board Action Minutes 9:00 A.M. Friday, February 11, 2011 Board of Supervisors Chambers, 168 W. Alisal Street, Salinas, California 1. Roll Call: Chair Russ Jeffries; Vice Chair Chris Daniel; Member Glen Alder Wendy Strimling, Deputy County Counsel, Board Counsel; Gail T. Borkowski, Clerk to the 2. Other Board Matters: a. Approve minutes of AAB meeting of January 14, 2011. Member Alder, the Board approved the minutes of November 19, 2010. b. Timeliness hearings: Edward Lo / APN 012-362-052 BOARD ACTION: Upon the motion of Member Daniel, seconded by Member Alder, the Board continued this application to March 10, 2011 and directed the Clerk of the Board to confirm with the State Board of Equalization whether the prior year s form can be used for current year filing. JP Morgan Chase Bank NA / APN 001-567-014 Member Alder, the Board continued this application to March 10, 2011 and directed the Clerk of the Board to confirm with the State Board of Equalization whether the prior year form can be used for current year filing. Seaside Laguna Limited aka Embassy Suites / APN 800-018-587 Separator Daniel, the Board denied the application regarding APN 001-567-014 due to untimely filing.
Minutes February 11, 2011-2 - Separator Technology Solutions US Inc. / APN 810-012-013 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 810-012-013 Edmond A. Benech / APN 009-393-015 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 009-393-015 Lighthouse Lodge II LLC dba Andon Inn / APN 006-361-023 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 006-361-023 Pearson Johnson Ranch LLC / APN 421-221-002 & 421-221-004 Daniel, the Board denied the applications regarding APNs 421-221-002 & 421-221-004 Michelle E. Mondo / APPN 169-171-025 BOARD ACTION: Upon the motion of Member Daniel, seconded by Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 169-171-025 Russell S. Nichols / APN 026-255-013 Daniel, the Board denied the application regarding APN 026-255-013 due to untimely filing. Russell S. Nichols / APN 026-253-012 Daniel, the Board denied the application regarding APN 026-253-012 due to untimely filing. Jose Rios / APN 003-891-007 Daniel, the Board denied the application regarding APN 003-891-007 due to untimely filing. Suzanne S. Shaw / APN 001-721-013 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 001-721-013 Suzanne S. Shaw / APN 001-721-011
Minutes February 11, 2011-3 - Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 001-721-011 Nelson A. Vega / APN 001-191-006 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 001-191-006 Nelson A. Vega / APN 001-181-010 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 001-1818- 010 Nelson A. Vega / APN 001-181-007 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 001-181-007 Nelson A. Vega / APN 001-224-015 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 001-224-015 Nelson A. Vega / APN 013-112-001 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 013-112-001 Karen P. Lacuesta / APN 012-274-053 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 012-274-053 John U. Edwards / APN 011-291-00 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 011-291-00 due to untimeliness of the filing. John U. Edwards / APN 011-291-004 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 011-291-004 Marie C. Delizonna / APN 032-323-018 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 032-323-013
Minutes February 11, 2011-4 - Nelson A. Vega / APN 032-021-042 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 032-021-042 Nelson A. Vega / APN 002-251-015 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 002-251-015 Candice A. Vega / APN 012-421-040 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding 012-421-040 due to untimely filing. Erica S. Walker / APN 012-341-034 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 012-341-034 Erica S. Walker / APN 032-283-025 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 032-283-025 William D. Walker / APN 012-392-040 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 012-392-040 Thomas P. Choe / APN 013-121-009 Member Alder, the Board denied the application regarding APN 013-121-009 Karen & Richard Hargrove / APN 239-041-012 Member Alder, the Board continued consideration of this application to March 10, 2011 and requested the Assessor s office confirm bill date and date of mailing to applicant. Danny L. Gamel / APN 008-471-010 Member Alder, the Board denied this application Alta Vista Communities LLC (c/o Scott Safadi) APN 030-031-011 Member Alder, the Board denied this application
Minutes February 11, 2011-5 - 3. Invalid Applications: Estate Financial, Inc./Asset Logic Group / Multiple APNs Member Alder, the Board denied these applications Brad D. Alexander / APN 012-532-010 Member Alder, the Board denied this application Monterey Kimberly Place, LLLP (Emerging Markets of North America / 96 APNs Martha Daniel, the Board granted an extension of the period to correct the 96 applications to 30 days from the date the letter is sent to the applicant by the Clerk of the Board. Lisa Nava / APN 189-101-002 Daniel, the Board denied this application as invalid and directed the applicant be notified of their right to request a hearing to protestthe denial. Cynthia A. Lesher / APN 243-351-003 Daniel, the Board denied this application as invalid and directed the applicant be notified of their right to request a hearing to protestthe denial. Louise O. Nelson / APN 014-111-051 Daniel, the Board denied this application as invalid and directed the applicant be notified of their right to request a hearing to protestthe denial. 4. Public Comment Period: None 5. Consent Calendar Approve stipulations: Daniel, the Board accepted and approved the stipulations for the following applications: 09-102 John L. Shadek / APN 157-171-076 09-817 Douglas A. Dirksen / APN 032-311-028 09-1032 Godfrey & Suzanne Sullivan TRS / APN 197-082-002 09-1123 Jimmy & Leslie Lee / APN 007-403-013 09-1245 Casey Printing Inc. / APN 800-030-697 09-1246 Casey Printing Inc. / APN 800-030-697 09-1247 Casey Printing Inc. / APN 800-030-697 09-1248 Casey Printing Inc. / APN 800-030-697 10-005 Daniel & Marina Miller / APN 007-413-006
Minutes February 11, 2011-6 - 10-010 Rakesh Kumar & Susan Love / APN 007-322-007 10-019 Mahin Golpanah Sarabi-Bassiri & Bassiri Reza / APN 125-131-024 10-026 David G. Chaladoff / APN 009-023-006 10-032 Claremont Profits Limited / APN 008-302-014 10-033 Christian Meyer / APN 830-021-383 10-035 Christian Meyer / APN 830-021-469 10-036 Midwest First Financial Limited Partnership IV / APN 024-321-031 10-051 Jae J. Kim / APN 014-111-001 10-054 Alex & Richelle Drollinger / APN 139-441-013 10-055 Richard J. II & Christina A. Bianco / APN 130-441-035 10-070 Bonnie J. Gray & Riki J. LaRoche / APN 002-122-018 10-071 Kenneth L. & Susan Rae Church / APN 001-112-019 10-072 Daniel E. Lester / APN 117-301-032 10-126 John M. & Margaret B. Lotz / APN 001-321-027 10-127 Jaime Alvarado Lara / APN 800-022-037 10-163 Louis J. Perske / APN 001-094-001 10-238 John E. & Sharon J. Matthams / APN 103-051-028 10-260 William Nicholls / APN 257-131-009 10-287 Stephen L. Millich / APN 001-652-016 10-354 William A. & Sandar J. Solitaro / APN 001-651-023 6. Consent Calendar - Approve withdrawals: Daniel, the Board accepted the withdrawals on the following applications: 09-1213 Daniel & Irene O Connor TR / APN 001-884-021 10-013 Ruth Donohugh & Frederick Minnes / APN 007-262-002 10-015 Carl P. Holm / APN 139-111-009 10-021 Susan Gaylor / APN 006-259-009 10-023 Jeff Larson / APN 173-074-030 10-024 Jeff Larson / APN 008-072-001 10-039 Roger W. & Mary A. Kieffer / APN 006-141-001 10-042 Nancy Ann Rosendin / APN 007-092-024 10-045 Pietro Investment Company / APN 009-411-012 10-058 Thomas J. & Christine E. Sweeney / APN 187-081-032 10-117 Stericycle, Inc. / APN 800-035-924 10-140 Neil P. & Linda C. Mussallem TRS / APN 125-291-011 10-146 Cobblestone Inn Carmel / APN 010-087-003 10-299 Kassema Jones / APN 261-832-004 10-659 Manuel Alarcon / APN 001-944-019 10-702 Pankaj Patel / APN 117-181-005 10-795 Hotel Pacific Monterey, LLC / APN 001-568-004 10-845 Gideon Properties LLC / APN 261-716-001 7. 09-671 09-672 Muller-Ryan LLC c/o Tim Gooch / APN 259-071-006 Muller-Ryan LLC c/o Tim Gooch / APN 259-071-007
Minutes February 11, 2011-7 - 09-673 Muller-Ryan LLC c/o Tim Gooch / APN 259-031-064 09-674 Muller-Ryan LLC c/o Tim Gooch / APN 259-031-068 Member Daniel, the Board continued applications 09-671 through 09-674 to April 8, 2011. 8. 09-944 Rangaswamy Vasudevan / APN 239-111-012 Member Alder, the Board continued application 09-944 to May 20, 2011. 9. 09-964 Marriott International / APN 001-384-003 Member Daniel, the Board continued application 09-964 to March 10, 2011. 10. 09-981 Charles D. Hoffman / APN 187-021-014 Member Daniel, the Board continued application 09-981 to May 20, 2011. 11. 09-1136 Petsmart / APN 011-011-045 Member Alder, the Board continued application 09-1136 to March 10, 2011. 12. 09-1148 09-1149 Darden Restaurants / APN 211-032-009 Darden Restaurants / APN 211-032-019 Member Daniel, the Board continued applications 09-1148 and 09-1149 to March 10, 2011. 13. 09-1222 TRU 2005 RE I LLC / APN 253-201-049 Member Alder, the Board continued application 09-1222 to May 20, 2011. 14. 09-1258 09-1259 09-1260 San Benito Supply / APN418-401-031 San Benito Supply / APN418-401-031 San Benito Supply / APN418-401-031 Member Daniel, the Board continued applications 09-1258 through 09-1260 to March 10, 2011. 15. 10-017 Raymond J. Evers / APN 173-074-010 Member Alder, the Board continued application 10-017 to March 10, 2011. 16. 10-027 Menlo Capital Holdings LLC / APN 007-303-003
Minutes February 11, 2011-8 - Member Daniel, the Board continued application 10-027 to March 10, 2011. 17. 10-041 Randy W. & Annie A. Tung / APN 007-092-006 Member Daniel, the Board accepted the withdrawal of application 10-041. 18. 10-046 Pietro Investment Company L.P. / APN 009-411-013 Member Alder, the Board continued application 10-046 to March 10, 2011. 19. 10-057 Ian & Charlotte A. Priestnell / APN 173-074-029 Member Daniel, the Board continued application 10-057 to May 20, 2011. 20. 10-061 Schomac Group Inc. (The) / APN 239-011-023 Member Daniel, the Board continued application 10-061 to April 8, 2011. 21. 10-062 Salvador Gutierrez & Mary Anderson / APN 239-101-031 Member Daniel, the Board continued application 10-062 to April 8, 2011. 22. 10-063 Schomac Group Inc. (The) / APN 239-011-013 Member Daniel, the Board continued application 10-063 to April 8, 2011. 23. 10-064 Salvador Gutierrez & Mary Anderson / APN 239-121-002 Member Daniel, the Board continued application 10-064 to April 8, 2011. 24. 10-069 Hal Lester / APN 420-171-004 Member Alder, the Board continued application 10-069 to May 20, 2011. 25. 10-076 Nathan E. Chaney / APN 033-152-036 Member Daniel, the Board continued application 10-076 to May 20, 2011. 26. 10-081 Michael Victor Szulborski / APN 008-112-004 Member Alder, the Board accepted the withdrawal of application 10-081. 27. 10-102 James R. Dotson, Trustee of Patricia J. Dotson Revocable Trust / APN 421-021- 004 Member Alder, the Board continued application 10-102 to June 17, 2011.
Minutes February 11, 2011-9 - 28. 10-130 Mike Patel dba King City Motel Investments, Inc.: Days Inn / APN 026-412-009 Member Alder, the Board accepted withdrawal of application 10-130. 29. 10-131 Robert A. Ferris, Trustee / APN 009-412-023 Member Daniel, the Board continued application 10-131 to May 20, 2011. 30. 10-135 Jeffrey A. Barnes / APN 241-031-022 Member Daniel, the Board continued application 10-135 to May 20, 2011. 31. 10-141 Neil P. & Linda C. Mussallem TRS / APN 125-291-012 Member Alder, the Board accepted the withdrawal of application 10-141. 32. 10-142 10-143 Matsui Nursery, Inc. / APN 153-101-014 Matsui Nursery, Inc. / APN 153-101-015 Member Daniel, the Board continued applications 10-142 and 10-143 to April 8, 2011. 33. 10-158 Martin J. Swanston / APN 016-122-022 Member Alder, the Board continued 10-158 to May 20, 2011. 34. 10-160 Regency Place, LLC / APN 211-241-007 Member Alder, the Board continued application 10-160 to May 20, 2011. 35. Closed Session 36. Adjourned to Thursday, March 10, 2011