Running head: CULTURAL APPROPRIATION AND APPRECIATION 1. Cultural Appropriation and Appreciation in the Legend of the Five Rings Roleplaying Game:

Similar documents
Running head: CULTURAL APPROPRIATION AND APPRECIATION 1. Cultural Appropriation and Appreciation in the Legend of the Five Rings Roleplaying Game:

TEACHING A GROWING POPULATION OF NON-NATIVE ENGLISH SPEAKING STUDENTS IN AMERICAN UNIVERSITIES: CULTURAL AND LINGUISTIC CHALLENGES

History of East Asia I. TTh 1:30-2:50 ATG 123

Culture, Space and Time A Comparative Theory of Culture. Take-Aways

Global Medievalism: From Model Books to Manga

SpringBoard Academic Vocabulary for Grades 10-11

I. PREREQUISITES For information regarding prerequisites for this course, please refer to the Academic Course Catalog.

Tale Of Genji: A Reader's Guide (Tuttle Classics) PDF

The Eastern Shore Room Eastern Shore Public Library LOCAL HISTORY COLLECTION DEVELOPMENT POLICY

A Process of the Fusion of Horizons in the Text Interpretation

Good afternoon! Our topic is book collecting contests and the impact that the digital age may or may not be having on them. [did a bit of explaining

Modernisms Chinas: Introduction

WILLIAM READY DIVISION OF ARCHIVES AND RESEARCH COLLECTIONS COLLECTION DEVELOPMENT POLICY

Programme Specification

Song of the Lonely Mountain

Instrumental Music Curriculum

Extended Engagement: Real Time, Real Place in Cyberspace

ICOMOS ENAME CHARTER

Stage 5 unit starter Novel: Miss Peregrine s home for peculiar children

Ovid s Revisions: e Editor as Author. Francesca K. A. Martelli. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. ISBN: $95.

Big Idea 1: Artists manipulate materials and ideas to create an aesthetic object, act, or event. Essential Question: What is art and how is it made?

2. What is the effect of repeated use of some adjectives to describe the wrestlers?

Prestwick House. Activity Pack. Click here. to learn more about this Activity Pack! Click here. to find more Classroom Resources for this title!

Humor in the Learning Environment: Increasing Interaction, Reducing Discipline Problems, and Speeding Time

The Epistolary Genre from the Renaissance Until Today. even though it is less popular than some other mainstream genres such as satire or saga, for

HISTORY 1130: Themes in Global History: Trade, Economy, and Empires

MAYWOOD PUBLIC SCHOOLS Maywood, New Jersey. LIBRARY MEDIA CENTER CURRICULUM Kindergarten - Grade 8. Curriculum Guide May, 2009

The Gossamer Years: The Diary Of A Noblewoman Of Heian Japan (Tuttle Classics) PDF

Developing Critical Reading Skills, 6th edition Chapter 4 Exercises P. 125 Manwatching: A Field Guide to Human Behavior Cause: Effect:

House Style for Physical Geography at Keele. Updated 25 th September 2012, Peter G Knight

Document A: Textbook. Source: Farah & Karls, World History: The Human Experience, (New York: Glencoe McGraw-Hill, 2001).

Westminster College School of Music Fall, 2018

The First Emperor of China

ICOMOS Charter for the Interpretation and Presentation of Cultural Heritage Sites

Thesis/Dissertation Preparation Guidelines

Student Use of the Internet for Research Projects: A Problem? Our Problem? What Can We Do About It?

The Impact of Media Censorship: Evidence from a Field Experiment in China

Multicultural Children s Literature

ICOMOS Ename Charter for the Interpretation of Cultural Heritage Sites

Tanabata: The Japanese Wish Upon a Star Festival East Asian Seminar Winter, 2006 Deborah W. Robinson

Long Term Residence and the Inside View

Volume 2, Number 5, July 1996 Copyright 1996 Society for Music Theory

Military Tradition in. Imperial China

Automation in Semiconductor Manufacturing IEDM, San Francisco, 1982 Keynote Speech

in order to formulate and communicate meaning, and our capacity to use symbols reaches far beyond the basic. This is not, however, primarily a book

Book Review. John Dewey s Philosophy of Spirit, with the 1897 Lecture on Hegel. Jeff Jackson. 130 Education and Culture 29 (1) (2013):

East Asian Civilization: Modern Era (01:214:242) Spring 2018 Monday/Thursday 9:50 am 11:10 am HC-N106. Instructor: Peng Liu Scott Hall 337

History Admissions Assessment Specimen Paper Section 1: explained answers

Culture and Power in Cultural Studies

Interdepartmental Learning Outcomes

My goal in these pages is, first, that

CEDAR CREST COLLEGE REL Spring 2010, Tuesdays/Thursdays, 2:30 3:45 p.m. Issues in Death and Dying 3 credits

Peterborough, ON, Canada: Broadview Press, Pp ISBN: / CDN$19.95

Bioarchitecture and the Principle of Not Forcing

UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE INTERNATIONAL EXAMINATIONS Cambridge International Level 3 Pre-U Certificate Principal Subject

The Historian and Archival Finding Aids

11/13/2012. [H]ow do we provide an arena for contesting stories (Aboriginal History: Workshop Report 5)?

Qing China: History, Fiction, and Fantasy ANS 372/HIS364G TTH 2-3:30, MEZ 1.204

The Canterbury Tales. Transfer Students will be able to independently use their learning to...

MLA IN-TEXT CITATIONS WORKSHEET

1/8. The Third Paralogism and the Transcendental Unity of Apperception

POCLD Policy Chapter 6 Operations 6.12 COLLECTION DEVELOPMENT. 1. Purpose and Scope

Out-of-Print and Special Collection Materials: Acquisition and Purchasing Options

Make a Quill Pen. You will need: Make a quill pen: Show your quill pen and your writing to your class, a friend, or a family member.

KOREA ESSENTIALS No. 1. Hangeul. Korea s Unique Alphabet

Marxist Criticism. Critical Approach to Literature

Part One Contemporary Fiction and Nonfiction. Part Two The Humanities: History, Biography, and the Classics

SECOND EDITION Theresa C. Noonan

Category Exemplary Habits Proficient Habits Apprentice Habits Beginning Habits

East and South-East Asian History. Le Royaume du Cambodge

Guide to the Republic as it sets up Plato s discussion of education in the Allegory of the Cave.

Deconstruction is a way of understanding how something was created and breaking something down into smaller parts.

Township of Uxbridge Public Library POLICY STATEMENTS

MARXIST LITERARY CRITICISM. Literary Theories

Many authors, including Mark Twain, utilize humor as a way to comment on contemporary culture.

HIST The Middle Ages in Film: Angevin and Plantagenet England Research Paper Assignments

126 BEN JONSON JOURNAL

In order to enrich our experience of great works of philosophy and literature we will include, whenever feasible, speakers, films and music.

Dependence of Mathematical Knowledge on Culture

PHIL106 Media, Art and Censorship

Logos, Pathos, and Entertainment

Writing an Annotated Bibliography

Almaviva: a contemporary adaptation of Mozart's Le nozze di Figaro

The Evolution of Japanese Themes:

Module 13: "Color and Society" Lecture 33: "Color and Culture" The Lecture Contains: About Culture. Color and Culture. The Symbolism of Color.

U N I T 2 : T H E M I D D L E A G E S E N G 1 2 A

STUDENT S HEIRLOOMS IN THE CLASSROOM: A LOOK AT EVERYDAY ART FORMS. Patricia H. Kahn, Ph.D. Ohio Dominican University

The Id, Ego, Superego: Freud s influence on all ages in the media. Alessia Carlton. Claire Criss. Davis Emmert. Molly Jamison.

Writing a literature review for a research paper. Teaching My Elementary School Teacher Good research Everyone has written an For in his paper..

CHINESE (CHIN) Courses. Chinese (CHIN) 1

ICOMOS ENAME CHARTER

Computer Coordination With Popular Music: A New Research Agenda 1

Theory or Theories? Based on: R.T. Craig (1999), Communication Theory as a field, Communication Theory, n. 2, May,

Celebrity Culture and the American Dream Stardom and Social Mobility Second Edition Karen Sternheimer CONTENTS LIST OF FIGURES PREFACE ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

Action Theory for Creativity and Process

The Significance of Religion in International Business. Maggie Moberg. University Of Cincinnati. Intermediate Composition. Professor Benander

Learning to see value: interactions between artisans and their clients in a Chinese craft industry

BIC Standard Subject Categories an Overview November 2010

Statement on Plagiarism

What is the Object of Thinking Differently?

Transcription:

Running head: CULTURAL APPROPRIATION AND APPRECIATION 1 Cultural Appropriation and Appreciation in the Legend of the Five Rings Roleplaying Game: A Sample Commentary Essay Geoffrey B. Elliott DeVry University

CULTURAL APPROPRIATION AND APPRECIATION 2 Cultural Appropriation and Appreciation in the Legend of the Five Rings Roleplaying Game: A Sample Commentary Essay The Legend of the Five Rings Roleplaying Game (L5R) centers on the fictional empire of Rokugan, itself based on feudal Japan with elements of Chinese, Mongolian, Korean, and other East and Southeast Asian cultures included. My engagement with the game began when I was an undergraduate in San Antonio; it has persisted since, including as ownership of the intellectual property was transferred and a new edition of the game was released in 2018. Having played it and helped to administer it, both officially and informally, I have immersed myself in the property s narrative for nearly twenty years. That immersion has made me aware of some difficulties surrounding the game. Because L5R, originally an American product, works in an amalgamation of feudal Japanese and not-necessarily-contemporary-to-it East Asian cultures, there are concerns of whether the game is culturally appreciative or culturally appropriative. On the whole, though, while there are appropriative elements, the game is appreciative of those cultures from which it borrows. Ascertaining whether L5R is appropriative or appreciative requires the development of a rubric by which to assess those qualities, which entails working from particular understandings of those terms. For example, Matthes (2016) follows other scholars in regarding cultural appropriation as the representation of a culture by those outside it, the use of cultural styles by those outside that culture, or the procurement or possession of cultural objects by those outside that culture, especially when the outsider is in a position of dominance over or oppression of the culture producing them; Matthes adds cultural essentialism, the reduction of a complex culture to oversimplified surface features, to that definition. The scholarly take is supplemented by prevailing views that assign the representation of authenticity to the outsider, as well, and the

CULTURAL APPROPRIATION AND APPRECIATION 3 lack of appropriate compensation for goods received (that is, someone can purchase a cultural object that is offered for sale without being appropriative). Generally, appropriation is decried as an oppressive practice akin to theft, one not desirable. In contrast, cultural appreciation might follow the idea advanced by Von Bergen, Von Bergen, Stubblefield, & Bandow (2012) under the name of authentic tolerance. That is, it can take the form of engaging with persons across cultures with demonstrated respect for people, if not practices, in a manner encouraging self-reflection and consideration of assumptions. To it might be added an explicit disclaiming of ownership or dominance, something that has emerged as particularly important since their work. Or, instead, cultural appreciation might follow the definition articulated by Malmo and Moiseichik (2017) as they examine martial arts communities: the perceived attitude towards, and awareness, cultivation, implementation or integration of, the understanding of customary beliefs, social forms, shared attitudes, values, goals, practices, and material traits of a racial, religious, or social group, especially a favorable attitude that does not assume greater ownership or authenticity with the culture at large. An amalgamation of the two, a favorable and respectful attitude that makes use of agreeable traits without claiming ownership of them and without condemning those who practice the less agreeable, might serve as a useful working definition of the term, a useful rubric for a desirable trait. The L5R materials to which such definitions might be applied were released in a new edition in 2018. The new edition also reset the narrative that had grown up through years of play, offering a fresh start for players; it consequently marks a new beginning for analysis and interpretation. In the materials, narrative focus is on the empire of Rokugan, described geographically as similar to mainland China and culturally as largely feudal-era Japanese

CULTURAL APPROPRIATION AND APPRECIATION 4 (Brooke & Ostrander, 2018, pp. 6-19); that is, the empire spans a large eastern landmass bracketed by mountains and jungles, punctuated by rivers, boasting a mighty wall, and ruled by katana-wielding samurai gathered into clans under a presiding, heaven-descended emperor. A number of sources are reported as undergirding L5R, many of which are from or are scholarly treatments of Japan; Musashi s Book of Five Rings, Sei s Pillow Book, Murasaki s Tale of Genji, The Tales of the Heike, Inazo s Bushido: The Soul of Japan, and Kurosawa s films are prominent among them (Brooke & Ostrander, 2018, p. 332). It is clear from the descriptions and the informal bibliography, then, where the game s inspirations lie, and it is from those inspirations and their treatment that the issue of whether the game is appropriative or appreciative emerges. Some appropriative elements emerge even in the bibliography. Relatively few of the scholarly works referenced appear to derive from the cultural inheritors of the tropes in which L5R deals, and several of the fictional works also seem to derive from outside sources (Brooke & Ostrander, 2018, p. 332). Treating in such works, which themselves tend toward the appropriative, makes it more likely that L5R is itself appropriative. Similarly, the selected works appear to tend towards cultural essentialism; just as Warner Brothers and Disney cartoons and Hollywod films present skewed, over-simplified ideas of Americanness, anime of any quality and even such excellent films as Kurosawa s will present necessarily limited and heavily overdetermined ideas of Japaneseness and East Asian identity. Working from them tends to make for an essentialist, appropriative product. A more overtly appropriative attitude emerges earlier in the text, as well. A sidebar noting the inclusion of mature themes in the work explicitly urges individual groups to determine which elements of the setting they engage with in the stories they tell (Brooke & Ostrander, 2018, p. 6). The sidebar references a later section of the text, in which effective

CULTURAL APPROPRIATION AND APPRECIATION 5 administration of the game is discussed (Brooke & Ostrander, 2018, p. 282). While content warnings are appropriate, there is always a peril of imposing cultural mores inappropriately. While it is the case that games need rules, and it is the case that stories cannot engage all aspects of even their own milieus (as the plethora of supplemental materials for any number of imaginary worlds attests), making such comments overtly tends to assign determination of authenticity to consumers of derivations from cultural products. In brief, it is appropriative. But there are also aspects of L5R that are appreciative of the cultural inspirations for the game, rather than strictly appropriative. One such is related to the aforementioned list of references for the game. While the list is skewed, as noted above, it does ascribe authority over the intellectual underpinnings of the game to more presumably authentic sources, disclaiming some degree of ownership of cultural identities not the game-owners own and inclining the game toward the appreciative. Similarly, the game makes repeated reference in callouts and sidebars to the fact that it is inspired by feudal Japan and other cultures rather than a faithful representation of them; the Your Game, Your Rokugan callout (Brooke & Ostrander, 2018, p. 274) and the Bushido in Historical Japan sidebar (Brooke & Ostrander, 2018, pp. 300-301) both note, for example, that L5R works in fiction derived from history. They join the long-standing assertion in the game s player community that Rokugan is not Japan to highlight the nonrepresentative nature of the game s milieu. By making itself explicitly other than a faithful representation of the cultures inspiring it, then, L5R makes itself more appreciative of those cultures than appropriative of them. Further, while some simplification is necessary for any simulation, and a game is necessarily a simulation, L5R works to provide a rich and detailed background for its narrative milieu and the characters who work in it. Roleplaying games are narrative exercises in which

CULTURAL APPROPRIATION AND APPRECIATION 6 players describe the thoughts, words, and actions of characters they create; nearly a third of the L5R core rules is devoted to the character creation process (Brooke & Ostrander, 2018, pp. 40-139), reflecting the importance placed upon it, and much of that portion of the book involves integrating the character into and cultivating the character from the narrative milieu. Players are, in effect, asked to immerse themselves in more than a rudimentary, superficial culture, one likely to be markedly different from their own, and in ways that have both benefits for adhering to and penalties from deviating from social norms that make sense in the narrative context. Rather than an essentialized caricature of a culture, then, L5R presents a nuanced and detailed milieu that examines its sources without claiming authority over them, so that while there is some potential for appropriation in certain circumstances, the game is, on the whole, appreciative of what inspires it. There is more work to do on L5R, of course. The core rules are not the only materials released for it as of this writing, and more materials are pending. That work, though, seems poised to begin in a good place, and it is to be hoped that L5R will continue to be more appreciative than appropriative of its source materials cultures of origin.

CULTURAL APPROPRIATION AND APPRECIATION 7 References Brooke, M, & Ostrander, K. (2018). Legend of the five rings roleplaying: Core rulebook. Roseville, MN: Fantasy Flight Games. Malmo, J.R., & Moiseichik, M. (2017). Development of the cultural appreciation of martial arts scale. Journal of Combat Sports & Martial Arts, 8(1), 9 17. Matthes, E.H. (2016). Cultural appropriation without cultural essentialism? Social Theory & Practice 42(2), 343-366. doi: 10.5840/soctheorpract201642219 Von Bergen, C.W., Von Bergen, B.A., Stubblefield, C., & Bandow, D. (2012). Authentic tolerance: Between forbearance and acceptance. Journal of Cultural Diversity 19(4), 111-117.