A Theory of Voice-leading Sets for Post-tonal Music.

Similar documents
ABSTRACT. Figure 1. Continuous, 3-note, OP-Space (Mod-12) (Tymoczko 2011, fig )

Studies in Transformational Theory

Semitonal Key Pairings, Set-Class Pairings, and the Performance. of Schoenberg s Atonal Keyboard Music. Benjamin Wadsworth

Reflection on (and in) Strunk s Tonnetz 1

Judgments of distance between trichords

Sequential Association Rules in Atonal Music

Chapter X. Intuitive Musical Homotopy

Sequential Association Rules in Atonal Music

A Neo-Riemannian Approach to Jazz Analysis

Mathematics and the Twelve-Tone System: Past, Present, and Future (Reading paper) Robert Morris Eastman School of Music, University of Rochester

Composing with Pitch-Class Sets

Introduction to Set Theory by Stephen Taylor

Ornamentation in Atonal Music

Techniques of Music Since 1900 (MUSI 2214), Spring 2011 Professor: Andrew Davis ( adavis at uh.edu)

Three Conceptions of Musical Distance

Survey of Music Theory II (MUSI 6397)

A NEW PERSPECTIVE ON DAVID LEWIN S INTERVAL FUNCTION: THE SYMMETRICAL IFUNC ARRAY A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL

206 Journal of the American Musicological Society

Theory of Music Jonathan Dimond 12-Tone Composition and the Second Viennese School (version August 2010) Introduction

Analysis of Post-Tonal Music (MUSI 6306) Spring 2006 Professor: Andrew Davis ( )

Flip-Flop Circles and their Groups

Review of Richard Cohn, Audacious Euphony: Chromaticism and the Triad s Second Nature (Oxford University Press, 2012)

Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed page of such transmission.

Volume 9, Number 3, August 2003 Copyright 2003 Society for Music Theory

Teaching Atonal and Beat-Class Theory, Modulo Small. Richard Cohn. Yale University

Techniques of Music Since 1900 (MUSI 2214), Spring 2008 Professor: Andrew Davis ( adavis at uh.edu)

A Composition Project: an Original 12-tone Fugue Modeled After J. S. Bach's BWV 847

Analysis and Discussion of Schoenberg Op. 25 #1. ( Preludium from the piano suite ) Part 1. How to find a row? by Glen Halls.

Schoenberg, Unfolding, and Composing With Twelve Tones : A Case Study (Op. 25/I) John Brackett

On Parsimonious Sequences as Scales in Western Music

Calculating Dissonance in Chopin s Étude Op. 10 No. 1

Bryan R. Simms. The Atonal Music of Arnold Schoenberg, Oxford University Press, ix, 265 pp.

Varieties of Tone Presence: Process, Gesture, and the Excessive Polyvalence of Pitch in Post-Tonal Music

Book Review. Paul Wilson. The Music of Bela Bartok. New Haven: Yale University Press, Reviewed by Craig Cummings

Diatonic-Collection Disruption in the Melodic Material of Alban Berg s Op. 5, no. 2

COMPOSITIONAL PRACTICES (c ) Music Composition 212, 412. (2018, Fall Term) Schedule

Review of Emmanuel Amiot, Music through Fourier Space: Discrete Fourier Transform in Music Theory (Springer, 2016)

Chapter Six. Neo-Riemannian Transformations and Wyschnegradsky s DC-scale

Scalar and Collectional Relationships in Shostakovich's Fugues, Op. 87

Volume 8, Number 3, October 2002 Copyright 2002 Society for Music Theory

Joint AMS/SMT Annual Meeting Vancouver, British Columbia November 6, 2016

12 INDIANA THEORY REVIEW

Rachel W. Hall Saint Joseph s University January 2, 2009 Geometrical Models for Modulation in Arabic Music. Abstract

A Geometrical Approach to Two-Voice Transformations in the Music of Bela Bartok

Noise Engineering. Tonnetz Sequent Eularian Tonnetz Gate-Driven Triad Generator. Overview

Paper #1: (atonal (analysis)) = 50% Paper #2: (serial (analysis)) = 50%

Symmetry in the First Movement of Martin Bresnick s Piano Trio

Analysis of Webern s Pieces for Cello and Piano Op. 11, No. 1. Like much of Anton Webern s music, the short duration of Pieces for Cello and Piano

Set Theory Based Analysis of Atonal Music

Chamber Symphony No.1(Evick)/ Symmetrical and Structural Features in Sonata No.2, Mvt.1, violin and piano.(béla Bartók) Jason Wesley Evick

2 The Tonal Properties of Pitch-Class Sets: Tonal Implication, Tonal Ambiguity, and Tonalness

Geometry and the quest for theoretical generality

Reconceptualizing the Lydian Chromatic Concept: George Russell as Historical Theorist. Michael McClimon

Twelve-tone Serialism: Exploring the Works of Anton Webern

Stephanie Lind and John Roeder

MTO 21.3 Examples: Boss, Motivic Processes in Schoenberg

The Roles of Invariance and Analogy in the Linear Design of Stravinsky s Musick to heare * David Carson Berry

MOTIVIC DEVELOPMENT IN THE PIANO MUSIC OF KARL WEIGL ( ) Justin Gray, B.M., M.M. Dissertation Prepared for the Degree of

Music Theory: A Very Brief Introduction

Tonal Polarity: Tonal Harmonies in Twelve-Tone Music. Luigi Dallapiccola s Quaderno Musicale Di Annalibera, no. 1 Simbolo is a twelve-tone

Volume 15, Number 1, March 2009 Copyright 2009 Society for Music Theory

Breaking Convention: Music and Modernism. AK 2100 Nov. 9, 2005

Analysis (MUSI 4211), Spring 2006 Professor: Andrew Davis ( )

PITCH CLASS SET CATEGORIES AS ANALYSIS TOOLS FOR DEGREES OF TONALITY

TEN. Classical Serialism

DUALISM AND THE BEHOLDER S EYE : INVERSIONAL SYMMETRY IN CHROMATIC TONAL MUSIC

Some properties of non-octave-repeating scales, and why composers might care

Semi-Simple Sonata Form

JAZZ HARMONY: PITCH-CLASS SET GENERA, TRANSFORMATION, AND PRACTICAL MUSIC. [Reader: please see the examples document that accompanies this paper]

Student: Ian Alexander MacNeil Thesis Instructor: Atli Ingólfsson. PULSES, WAVES AND PHASES An analysis of Steve Reich s Music for Eighteen Musicians

Implementing algebraic methods in OpenMusic.

Preliminary Examinations (revised 6/10/15)

Lecture 21: Mathematics and Later Composers: Babbitt, Messiaen, Boulez, Stockhausen, Xenakis,...

Figure 1 Definitions of Musical Forces from Larson (2012) Figure 2 Categories of Intentionality

Symmetry and Transformations in the Musical Plane

Jazz Line and Augmented Scale Theory: Using Intervallic Sets to Unite Three- and Four-Tonic Systems. by Javier Arau June 14, 2008

Chapter Five. Ivan Wyschnegradsky s 24 Preludes

Chapter 2 An Abbreviated Survey

New Issues in the Analysis of Webern's 12-tone Music


Math and Music. Cameron Franc

Deviant Cadential Six-Four Chords

Proceedings of the 7th WSEAS International Conference on Acoustics & Music: Theory & Applications, Cavtat, Croatia, June 13-15, 2006 (pp54-59)

UNDERGRADUATE MUSIC THEORY COURSES INDIANA UNIVERSITY JACOBS SCHOOL OF MUSIC

Harmonic Generation based on Harmonicity Weightings

Yale University Department of Music

Volume 18, No. 2, July - December Narongchai Pidokrajt. College of Music, Mahidol University, Nakhonpathom, Thailand

Serial Composition. Background

david bard schwarz University of North Texas College of Music

STUDY GUIDE FOR THE DMA COMPREHENSIVE EXAM, PART I COLLEGE OF MUSIC, MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY

NEO-RIEMANNIAN CYCLE DETECTION WITH WEIGHTED FINITE-STATE TRANSDUCERS

EIGHT SHORT MATHEMATICAL COMPOSITIONS CONSTRUCTED BY SIMILARITY

Music and Mathematics: On Symmetry

Ever since its publication in 1947, The Thesaurus of

October 29, 2015 A Closer Look at Harmonic Prolongation in Jazz Performance Special Session: What is Jazz Harmony?

INTRODUCTION TO GOLDEN SECTION JONATHAN DIMOND OCTOBER 2018

Boss, Jack Schoenberg s Twelve Tone Music: Symmetry and the Musical Idea. Cambridge: Cambridge University. Reviewed by Andrew J.

Music is applied mathematics (well, not really)

1a.51 Harmonic Seconds and Fifths WB2 1A_51ABCDEFGHIJ.WAV 1a.52 Identifying and Notating Seconds and All WB2 1A_52ABCDEFGHIJ.WAV

Learning Geometry and Music through Computer-aided Music Analysis and Composition: A Pedagogical Approach

Transcription:

Justin Lundberg SMT 2014 1 A Theory of Voice-leading Sets for Post-tonal Music justin.lundberg@necmusic.edu Voice-leading Set (vlset): an ordered series of transpositions or inversions that maps one pitchclass set onto another. Voice-leading Set-class (vlclass): a class of vlsets created through transpositional, inversional, and/or rotational equivalence. Figure 1: transformational voice leading B A B A Tt or I8 Figure 2: Vlset <442> spanning trichords {65e} and {t91} T2 e 1 T4 5 9 T4 6 t <442> Figure 3: Vlset <420>i spanning trichords {65e} and {t91} I0 e 1 I2 5 9 I4 6 t <420>i

Justin Lundberg SMT 2014 2 Figure 4: Drei Klavierstuecke Op. 11 no. 1, by Arnold Schoenberg, mm. 1-5 e 9 e 1 e e 9 1 8 5 5 9 8 5 5 9 7 4 6 t 7 6 4 t <tt8> <442> <tt0> <446> a b c d a c b d Figure 5: Drei Klavierstuecke Op. 11 no. 1, by Arnold Schoenberg, mm. 6-13 8 5 0 8 6 8 8 0 4 e e 2 2 4 t e 6 7 3 9 0 6 9 3 <113> <99e> <442> <335> g h i j e g f i

Justin Lundberg SMT 2014 3 Figure 6a: vlset <05> toroidal voice-leading space. 6b: <05> Moebius Strip.

Justin Lundberg SMT 2014 4 Table 1: dyadic voice-leading spaces. Vlset Sum Number of Pcsets Tn-class cycles Vlset Sum Number of Pcsets <01> 1 144 1 <0e> e 144 1 <2e> 1 48 3 <1t> e 48 3 <3t> 1 144 1 <29> e 144 1 <49> 1 144 1 <38> e 144 1 <58> 1 48 3 <47> e 48 3 <67> 1 144 1 <56> e 144 1 <05> 5 144 1 <07> 7 144 1 <14> 5 48 3 <8e> 7 48 3 <23> 5 144 1 <9t> 7 144 1 <6e> 5 144 1 <16> 7 144 1 <7t> 5 48 3 <25> 7 48 3 <89> 5 144 1 <34> 7 144 1 Tn-class cycles <02> 2 36 2 <0t> t 36 2 <11> 2 12 12 <ee> t 12 12 <3e> 2 36 4 <19> t 36 4 <4t> 2 12 6 <28> t 12 6 <59> 2 36 4 <37> t 36 4 <68> 2 36 2 <46> t 36 2 <77> 2 12 12 <55> t 12 12 <03> 3 16 3 <09> 9 16 3 <12> 3 48 1 <te> 9 48 1 <4e> 3 48 1 <18> 9 48 1 <5t> 3 48 1 <27> 9 48 1 <69> 3 16 3 <36> 9 16 3 <78> 3 48 1 <45> 9 48 1 <04> 4 9 4 <08> 8 9 4 <13> 4 36 2 <9e> 8 36 2 <22> 4 6 12 <tt> 8 6 12 <5e> 4 12 6 <17> 8 12 6 <6t> 4 18 4 <26> 8 18 4 <79> 4 36 2 <35> 8 36 2 <88> 4 3 12 <44> 8 3 12 <00> 0 1 12 <06> 6 4 6 <1e> 0 12 2 <15> 6 12 4 <2t> 0 6 4 <24> 6 12 2 <39> 0 4 6 <33> 6 4 12 <48> 0 3 4 <7e> 6 12 4 <57> 0 12 2 <8t> 6 12 2 <66> 0 2 12 <99> 6 4 12

Justin Lundberg SMT 2014 5 Figure 7: permutational reduction of trichordal orbifold.

Justin Lundberg SMT 2014 6 Table 2: trichordal voice-leading spaces. Vlset Inversional Pair Sum Number of Pcsets Tn-class spaces <001>, <445>, <889> <00e>, <443>, <887> 1/e 1728 1 <02e>, <346>, <78t> <01t>, <245>, <689> 1/e 1728 1 <03t>, <247>, <68e> <029>, <146>, <58t> 1/e 1728 1 <049>, <148>, <058> <038>, <047>, <48e> 1/e 1728 1 <067>, <4te>, <238> <056>, <49t>, <128> 1/e 1728 1 <11e>, <355>, <799> <1ee>, <335>, <779> 1/e 432 2 <12t>, <256>, <69t> <2te>, <236>, <67t> 1/e 1728 1 <139>, <157>, <59e> <39e>, <137>, <57e> 1/e 432 2 <166>, <5tt>, <229> <66e>, <3tt>, <227> 1/e 1728 1 <337>, <77e>, <3ee> <599>, <119>, <155> 1/e 108 5 <005>, <449>, <188> <007>, <44e>, <388> 5/7 1728 1 <014>, <458>, <089> <08e>, <034>, <478> 5/7 1728 1 <023>, <467>, <8te> <09t>, <124>, <568> 5/7 1728 1 <06e>, <34t>, <278> <016>, <45t>, <289> 5/7 1728 1 <07t>, <24e>, <368> <025>, <469>, <18t> 5/7 1728 1 <113>, <557>, <99e> <9ee>, <133>, <577> 5/7 432 2 <122>, <566>, <9tt> <tte>, <223>, <667> 5/7 1728 1 <15e>, <359>, <179> <17e>, <35e>, <379> 5/7 432 2 <16t>, <25t>, <269> <26e>, <36t>, <27t> 5/7 1728 1 <33e>, <377>, <7ee> <199>, <115>, <559> 5/7 108 5 <002>, <446>, <88t> <00t>, <244>, <688> 2/t 216 2 <011>, <455>, <899> <0ee>, <334>, <778> 2/t 864 1 <03e>, <347>, <78e> <019>, <145>, <589> 2/t 864 1 <04t>, <248>, <068> <028>, <046>, <48t> 2/t 216 2 <059>, <149>, <158> <037>, <47e>, <38e> 2/t 864 1 <077>, <4ee>, <338> <055>, <499>, <118> 2/t 864 1 <12e>, <356>, <79t> <1te>, <235>, <679> 2/t 864 1 <13t>, <257>, <69e> <29e>, <136>, <57t> 2/t 864 1 <167>, <5te>, <239> <56e>, <39t>, <127> 2/t 864 1 <22t>, <266>, <6tt> <2tt>, <226>, <66t> 2/t 54 5 <004>, <448>, <088> <008>, <044>, <488> 4/8 27 5 <013>, <457>, <89e> <09e>, <134>, <578> 4/8 432 1 <022>, <466>, <8tt> <0tt>, <224>, <668> 4/8 108 2 <05e>, <349>, <178> <017>, <45e>, <389> 4/8 432 1 <06t>, <24t>, <268> <026>, <46t>, <28t> 4/8 108 2 <079>, <14e>, <358> <035>, <479>, <18e> 4/8 432 1 <112>, <556>, <99t> <tee>, <233>, <677> 4/8 432 1 <15t>, <259>, <169> <27e>, <36e>, <37t> 4/8 432 1 <23e>, <367>, <7te> <19t>, <125>, <569> 4/8 432 1 <277>, <6ee>, <33t> <55t>, <299>, <116> 4/8 432 1 <000>, <444>, <888> 0 1, 3 <01e>, <345>, <789> 0 144 3 <02t>, <246>, <68t> 0 36 6 <039>, <147>, <58e> 0 16, 48 4

Justin Lundberg SMT 2014 7 <048> 0 9 <057>, <49e>, <138> 0 144 3 <066>, <4tt>, <228> 0 8, 12 10 <11t>, <255>, <699> <2ee>, <336>, <77t> 0 16, 48 4 <129>, <156>, <59t> <237>, <67e>, <3te> 0 144 3 <003>, <447>, <88e> <009>, <144>, <588> 3/9 64, 192 4 <012>, <456>, <89t> <0te>, <234>, <678> 3/9 576 3 <04e>, <348>, <078> <018>, <045>, <489> 3/9 576 3 <05t>, <249>, <168> <027>, <46e>, <38t> 3/9 576 3 <069>, <14t>, <258> <036>, <47t>, <28e> 3/9 64, 192 4 <111>, <555>, <999> <eee>, <333>, <777> 3/9 4, 12 <13e>, <357>, <79e> <19e>, <135>, <579> 3/9 144 6 <159> <37e> 3/9 36 <177>, <5ee>, <339> <55e>, <399>, <117> 3/9 16, 48 10 <22e>, <366>, <7tt> <1tt>, <225>, <669> 3/9 64, 192 4 <23t>, <267>, <6te> <29t>, <126>, <56t> 3/9 576 3 <006>, <44t>, <288> 6 8, 24 10 <015>, <459>, <189> <07e>, <34e>, <378> 6 288 3 <024>, <468>, <08t> 6 72 6 <033>, <477>, <8ee> <099>, <114>, <558> 6 32, 96 4 <123>, <567>, <9te> 6 288 3 <16e>, <35t>, <279> 6 288 3 <17t>, <25e>, <369> 6 32, 96 4 <222>, <666>, <ttt> 6 2, 6 <26t> 6 18 Figure 8: Vlclass [047] ordered tn-class space.

Justin Lundberg SMT 2014 8 Figure 9: Examples of complete ordered set-class spaces. a) vlclass [056] b) vlclass [025]

Justin Lundberg SMT 2014 9 c) vlclass [014] d) vlclass [013]

Justin Lundberg SMT 2014 10 Figure 10: Vlset <t16> in A; Webern Op. 5 n. 3, mm. 1-4. Figure 11: Vlclass [038] in B, mm. 9-10.

Justin Lundberg SMT 2014 11 Figure 12: Variations of A in mm. 10-14 Figure 13: A and B on the [047] ordered tn-class space.

Justin Lundberg SMT 2014 12 Selected Bibliography Callender, Clifton. Voice-Leading Parsimony in the Music of Alexander Scriabin. Journal of Music Theory 42, n. 2 (1998): 219-233., Ian Quinn, and Dmitri Tymoczko. Generalized Voice-leading Spaces. Science 320, (2008): 346-348. Cohn, Richard. A Tetrahedral Graph of Tetrachordal Voice-Leading Space. Music Theory Online 9, n. 4 (2003). Available at http://societymusictheory.org/mto/. Forte, Allen. Pitch-class Set Genera and the Origin of Modern Harmonic Species. Journal of Music Theory 32, n. 2 (1988): 187-270. Gollin, Edward. Some Aspects of Three-Dimensional Tonnetze. Journal of Music Theory 42, n. 2 (1998): 195-206.. Multi-Aggregate Cycles and Multi-Aggregate Serial Techniques in the Music of Bela Bartok. Music Theory Spectrum 30, n. 1 (2008): 139-151. Hall, Rachel. Geometrical Music Theory. Science 320 (2008): 328-329. Haimo, Ethan. Atonality, Analysis, and the Intentional Fallacy. Music Theory Spectrum 18, n. 2 (1996): 167-199. Headlam, David. Introduction. Theory and Practice 33, (2008): 1-47. Hook, Julian. Uniform Triadic Transformations. Journal of Music Theory 46, nos. 1&2 (2002): 57-126. Lewin, David. Notes on the Opening of the F# Minor Fugue from WTCI. Journal of Music Theory 26, n. 1 (1982): 23-60.. Some Ideas about Voice-Leading between PCSets. Journal of Music Theory 42, n. 1 (1998): 15-72.. Transformational Techniques in Atonal and Other Music Theories. Perspectives of New Music 21, nos. 1-2 (1982-83): 312-71. Morris, Robert. Composition with Pitch-Classes. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1987.. Voice-Leading Spaces. Music Theory Spectrum 20, n. 2 (1998): 175-208. O Connell, Walter. Tone Spaces. Die Reihe 8 (English ed. 1968): 35-67. Perle, George. Serial Composition and Atonality. 6 th ed. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2001.. Twelve-Tone Tonality. 2 nd ed. Berkeley: University of California press, 1996. Quinn, Ian. Listening to Similarity Relations. Perspectives of New Music 39, n. 2 (2001): 108-158. Roeder, John. A Theory of Voice Leading for Atonal Music. Ph.D. Diss. Yale University, 1984.. A Geometric Representation of Pitch-Class Series. Perspectives of New Music 25, n. 1/2 (1987): 362-409.. Voice Leading as Transformation. In Musical Transformation and Musical Intuition: Essays in Honor of David Lewin. Edited by Raphael Atlas and Michael Cherlin. Roxbury, MA: Ovenbird Press, 1994: 41-58. Straus, Joseph. Uniformity, Balance, and Smoothness in Atonal Voice Leading. Music Theory Spectrum 25, n. 2 (2003): 305-352.. Voice Leading in Atonal Music. Music Theory in Concept and Practice. Rochester, NY: University of Rochester Press, 1997: 237-74.. Voice Leading in Set-Class Space. Journal of Music Theory 49, n. 1 (2005): 45-108. Tymoczko, Dmitri. The Geometry of Musical Chords. Science 313, n. 5783 (2006): 72-74.. A Geometry of Music: Harmony and Counterpoint in the Extended Common Practice. New York: Oxford University Press, 2011. Wilson, Andrew. (2011) Voice Leading as Set. Unpublished manuscript.