FINAL ACTION MINUTES MONTEREY COUNTY ASSESSMENT APPEALS BOARD FRIDAY, APRIL 19, 2013 168 W. Alisal St., 1 st Floor, Salinas, CA 93901 9:00 A.M. 1. Roll Call: Russ Jeffries, Chair; Chris Daniel, Vice-Chari; Glen Alder, Board Member Cynthia Hasson, Deputy County Counsel, Board Counsel Iracema Lopez, Board Clerk to the Gail T. Borkowski, Clerk of the Board 2. Public Comment Period: None. 3. Consent Calendar - Approve stipulations: Member Alder, the Board accepted and approved the stipulations below: 11-157 Carmel Candle Power LTD / APN 010-136-022 11-385 Salvador O. Gutierrez & Mary C. Anderson / APN 239-101-031 11-392 Daniel & Nadine V. Clark, TRS / APN 420-171-010 11-420 TRU 2005 RE I LLC / APN 253-201-049 REMOVED 11-451 Kevin Cunningham / APN 006-345-004 11-486 Northridge Fashion Center LLC / APN 253-201-058 11-487 Northridge Fashion Center LLC / APN 253-201-055 11-488 Grace Rosenberg, Trust / APN 008-341-028 11-489 Larry E. Fryman / APN 010-361-007 11-493 Save Mart Store #772 / APN 011-011-047 11-494 Save Mart Store #772 / APN 011-011-046 11-508 Howard & Robin Reisman / APN 239-121-003 11-509 William E. Connor II, Trustee of The Cline Trust-1990 / APN 157-171-076 REMOVED 11-511 The Guillermo & Angela Nieto Family LP / APN 022-451-026 11-549 Miguel Fletes-Zamora / APN 009-551-017 11-573 Sonja A. Johnson / APN 006-092-007 11-576 Steven & Carmen Hutt / APN 006-043-007 11-588 Yifei C. Huang / APN 010-186-006 11-590 Eric J. Le Towt / APN 008-102-014
Agenda April 19, 2013-2 - 11-593 John Cardinalli et al / APN 011-303-010 11-613 James L. Frear / APN 012-642-009 11-615 Thomas R. Fischer / APN 127-253-002 11-616 Thomas R. Fischer / APN 117-191-035 11-617 Thomas R. Fischer / APN 127-253-001 11-618 The Schomac Group Inc. / APN 239-102-013 11-621 Thomas R. Marinus / APN 423-201-032 11-628 John G. Davi / APN 001-574-014 11-629 Joseph T. Faxon / APN 187-131-013 11-692 Nelson A. Vega Tr et al / APN 002-251-015 11-795 Bob Boehlke / APN 259-092-021 11-828 James & Shelley Gallagher / APN 002-701-011 11-836 Jaladham Corporation / APN 003-474-001 A2012- Bob boehlke / APN 259-092-021 00632 4. Consent Calendar - Approve withdrawals: Member Daniel, the Board added the following applications, to today s agenda, to the list of withdrawals to be approved: 11-559 Alan & Joanna Silverman / APN 239-021-010 11-818 James A. & June Hanlon / APN 173-073-053 A2012- Kevin J. McQuillan / APN 239-051-015 00325 Member Daniel, the Board accepted the withdrawals received after the posting of the agenda. Withdrawals received after the posting of the agenda: 11-158 W2005/Fargo Hotel (Pool) Realty LP / APN 261-146-015 (#6) 11-159 W2005/Fargo Hotel (Pool) Realty LP / APN 261-146-016 (#6) 11-221 Raley s Family Stores / 001-014-003 (#7) 11-422 Donohue Schriber Realty Group / APN 153-481-012 (#12) 11-423 Donohue Schriber Realty Group / APN 153-481-014 (#12) 11-424 Donohue Schriber Realty Group / APN 153-481-015 (#12) 11-425 Donohue Schriber Realty Group / APN 153-481-016 (#12) 11-426 Donohue Schriber Realty Group / APN 153-481-017 (#12) 11-427 Donohue Schriber Realty Group / APN 153-481-018 (#12) 11-500 SaveMart / APN 253-171-002 (#18) 11-551 Kevin J. McQuillan / APN 239-051-015 (#21) 11-694 Pacifica Host Hotels / APN 011-401-025 (#45)
Agenda April 19, 2013-3 - Member Alder, the Board accepted and approved the withdrawals below: 11-480 Sears Roebuck & Co. #1688 / APN 253-201-054 11-553 Roy J. Shanker & Linda K. Gibson / APN 008-302-036 11-574 Avalon Villa Sierra LLC / APN 207-101-040 11-653 Granite Construction Company / APN 907-000-063 11-654 Granite Construction Company / APN 800-030-587 11-658 Willa L. Aylaian / APN 010-134-006 11-709 Wells Gargo / Cost Plus Stores #211 / APN 011-102-029 11-779 Daniel Oh dba Salinas Valley Inn & Suites el al / APN 309-200-900 11-799 William L. Perocchi / APN 008-281-017 11-851 Worldmark the Club dba Monterey Bay / APN 033-192-041 5. Other Board Matters a. Approve Assessment Appeals Meeting Minutes of January 18, BOARD ACTION: Upon motion of Member Alder, second by Member Daniel, continued approval of the minutes to May 17, b. Approve Assessment Appeals Meeting Minutes of March 22, Upon motion of Member Alder, second by Member Daniel, the Board continued approval of the minutes to May 17, Reconsider of the Denial of Application: c. 11-405 Rangaswamy Vasudevan / APN 239-111-012 Applicant Rangaswamy Vasudevan was present and sworn. He addressed the Board and requested reinstatement of his application. BOARD ACTION: Upon motion of Member Alder, second by Member Daniel, the Board reinstated application 11-405 and set a hearing on May 17, 6. 11-158 11-159 W2005/Fargo Hotel(Pool)Realty LP / APN 261-146-015 W2005/Fargo Hotel(Pool)Realit / APN 261-146-016 7. 11-221 Raley s Family of Stores / APN 010-014-003 8. 11-354 Luis Munoz / APN 012-831-001 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-354 to May 17,
Agenda April 19, 2013-4 - 9. 11-394 Hartnell Plaza Associates / APN 016-081-007 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-394 to May 17, 10. 11-400 11-401 11. 11-415 11-416 12. 11-422 11-423 11-424 11-425 11-426 11-427 CitationShares Management LLC / Citation Air / APN 800-033-876 CitationShares Management LLC / Citation Air / APN 800-033-868 Member Daniel, the Board approved the Request for Agreement for Extension and Waiver of Rights for applications 11-400 and 11-401. Poppy Holding Inc. / APN 008-031-016 Poppy Holding Inc. / APN 008-032-003 Member Alder, the Board postponed applications 11-415 and 11-416 to June 21, Donohue Schriber Realty Group / APN 153-481-012 Donohue Schriber Realty Group / APN 153-481-014 Donohue Schriber Realty Group / APN 153-481-015 Donohue Schriber Realty Group / APN 153-481-016 Donohue Schriber Realty Group / APN 153-481-017 Donohue Schriber Realty Group / APN 153-481-018 BOARD ACTION: Items withdrawn. See item 4 for action. 13. 11-445 Bryan H. Draper / APN 010-223-024 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-445 to May 17, 14. 11-456 Jerome L. Rubin / APN 259-183-002 Member Daniel, the Board approved the Request for Agreement for Extension and Waiver of Rights for application 11-456. 15. 11-483 Richard E. & Sharlene Thum / APN 007-254-005 Margaret Thum, Agent appearing in behalf of the Applicant was sworn. She did not request Findings of Facts. Larry Tack, Supervising Appraiser and Steve Cagle were sworn on behalf of the Assessor s office. Mrs. Thum made her presentation, on behalf of the applicant. The following exhibits were submitted and marked for identification:
Agenda April 19, 2013-5 - Applicant s Exhibit 1 Packet titled Richard & Sharlene Thum: 951 Coral (APN:007-254-005) (18 pages) Mr. Tack made his presentation, on behalf of the Assessor s office. The following exhibits were submitted and marked for identification: Assessor s Exhibit A Applicant s Summary: Assessment Appeal 11-483 Owner of Record; Richard & Sharlene Thum 951 coral Dr., Pebble Beach, CA; APN: 007-254-005; Date of Valuation, January 1, 2011 Current Enrolled Value: $2,512,855 Both parties concluded their presentations and cross-examination. The Board took application 11-483 under submission. Closed Session was held and the Board reported out after Closed Session on this item. Member Alder, the Board found the value of the property, as of the date of January 1, 2011, to be $2,300,000. 16. 11-492 William & Joan Mack / APN 173-074-043 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-492 to May 17, 17. 11-496 Savemart Store #746 / APN 261-145-034 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-496 to June 21, 18. 11-500 Savemart Store #405 / APN 253-171-002 19. 11-510 Jeffrey R. Cohen / APN 006-382-030 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-510 to May 17, 20. 11-519 Carmel Bay, LLC / APN 008-162-019 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-519 to May 17,
Agenda April 19, 2013-6 - 21. 11-551 Kevin J. McQuillan / APN 239-051-015 22. 11-555 David C. Bouc / APN 187-021-029 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-555 to May 17, 23. 11-557 Georgene K. Pasarell / APN 239-131-004 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-557 to May 17, 24. 11-558 Helen O. d Oliveira / APN 010-031-012 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-558 to May 17, 25. 11-567 Granham S. Caleb / APN 008-511-003 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-567 to May 17, 26. 11-570 Rudy D. Martin / APN 007-262-005 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-570 to May 17, 27. 11-575 Mary B. Boscoe / APN 189-363-008 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-575 to May 17, 28. 11-585 William E. Hayward / APN 259-092-023 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-585 to May 17, 29. 11-586 Alex Barambila / APN 129-152-007 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-586 to May 17,
Agenda April 19, 2013-7 - 30. 11-591 Peter R. Serchuk / APN 009-391-001 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-591 to May 17, 31. 11-592 Georgia Byrne / APN 161-632-025 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-592 to May 17, 32. 11-595 Sandra T. Pepe / APN 008-233-007 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-595 to May 17, 33. 11-596 Patrick J. Connolly / APN 008-291-024 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-596 to May 17, 34. 11-601 11-602 11-603 Arvind Panchal / APN 013-104-024 Arvind Panchal / APN 013-191-006 Arvind Panchal / APN 011-363-006 Member Alder, the Board postponed applications 11-601 through 11-603 to May 17, 35. 11-609 Gemini Theater. / APN 002-234-031 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-609 to May 17, 36. 11-623 Carmelita A. Rogers / APN 127-092-004 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-623 to May 17, 37. 11-633 Michelle E. Uquillas / APN 131-042-015 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-633 to May 17,
Agenda April 19, 2013-8 - 38. 11-634 Kenneth Robin Baggett / APN 007-401-015 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-634 to May 17, 39. 11-638 Home Depot USA / APN 253-332-033 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-638 to May 17, 40. 11-643 Teja C. Patel / APN 161-554-045 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-643 to May 17, 41. 11-649 Taylor B. Loesch / APN 012-051-023 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-649 to June 21, 42. 11-663 Luskin Daughters 1996 Trust / APN 1416-131-032 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-663 to May 17, 43. 11-668 11-669 11-670 11-671 Big Sur Preservation Alliance LLC / APN 422-011-027 Big Sur Preservation Alliance LLC / APN 422-011-028 Big Sur Preservation Alliance LLC / APN 422-011-026 Big Sur Preservation Alliance LLC / APN 422-011-025 Member Alder, the Board postponed applications 11-668 through 11-671 to May 17, 44. 11-683 John Hovannisian / APN 015-012-068 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-683 to May 17, 45. 11-694 Pacifica Host Hotels / APN 011-401-025
Agenda April 19, 2013-9 - 46. 11-704 11-705 Platinum Energy / APN 033-041-025 Member Daniel, the Board postponed application 11-704 to May 17, Platinum Energy / APN 033-041-011 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-705 to May 17, 47. 11-706 FBC, LLC / APN 177-132-039 Member Alder, the Board postponed application 11-706 to May 17, 48. 11-711 11-712 CVS/Longs Drug Stores #9320 / APN 001-061-009 CVS/Longs Drug Stores #9802 / APN 013-181-010 Member Daniel, the Board postponed applications 11-711 and 11-712 to June 21, 49. Closed Session See item 15 for Closed Session report. 50. Adjournment to Friday, May 17,