STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT AND COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE: CONCEPTS AND CASES (5TH EDITION) BY JAY B. BARNEY, WILLIAM S. HESTERLY

Similar documents
THE MODERNIZATION OF CHINA BY GILBERT, EDITOR ROZMAN DOWNLOAD EBOOK : THE MODERNIZATION OF CHINA BY GILBERT, EDITOR ROZMAN PDF

CAMBRIDGE ENGLISH FOR THE MEDIA STUDENT'S BOOK WITH AUDIO CD (CAMBRIDGE PROFESSIONAL ENGLISH) BY NICK CERAMELLA, ELIZABETH LEE

KILLING ROMMEL BY STEVEN PRESSFIELD (7-MAY-2009) PAPERBACK FROM BANTAM (7 MAY 2009)

PRACTICE AND PROGRESS (NEW CONCEPT ENGLISH) BY L. G. ALEXANDER DOWNLOAD EBOOK : PRACTICE AND PROGRESS (NEW CONCEPT ENGLISH) BY L. G.

ALLEGED BIBLE CONTRADICTIONS EXPLAINED BY GEORGE W. DEHOFF

MOULIN ROUGE BY PIERRE LA MURE

MOULIN ROUGE BY PIERRE LA MURE DOWNLOAD EBOOK : MOULIN ROUGE BY PIERRE LA MURE PDF

BY MICHAELS, DAVID TOM CLANCY'S ENDWAR (2008) MASS MARKET PAPERBACK FROM BERKLEY

A PURPOSE CENTERED FAITH (GLOBAL GLORY) BY DR. RENNY MCLEAN DOWNLOAD EBOOK : A PURPOSE CENTERED FAITH (GLOBAL GLORY) BY DR.

BEFORE HE CHEATS (PIANO VOCAL, GUITAR SHEET MUSIC) BY CARRIE UNDERWOOD

GLOBALIZATION: A CRITICAL INTRODUCTION

COME OVER TO MY HOUSE BY DR. SEUSS DOWNLOAD EBOOK : COME OVER TO MY HOUSE BY DR. SEUSS PDF

THE COMMUNICATION HANDBOOK: A DICTIONARY BY JOSEPH A. DEVITO

MARKETING RESEARCH: METHODOLOGICAL FOUNDATIONS, 9TH EDITION BY DAWN IACOBUCCI

PERSONALITY THEORIES 8TH (EGITH) EDITION BY BARBARA ENGLER DOWNLOAD EBOOK : PERSONALITY THEORIES 8TH (EGITH) EDITION BY BARBARA ENGLER PDF

THE ESSENTIAL LAW OF ATTRACTION COLLECTION DOWNLOAD EBOOK : THE ESSENTIAL LAW OF ATTRACTION COLLECTION PDF

A HISTORY OF THE ANCIENT NEAR EAST CA BC (BLACKWELL HISTORY OF THE ANCIENT WORLD) 2ND (SECOND) EDITION BY MARC VAN DE MIEROOP

MOBILE A2 LIVRE DE L'ELEVE + DVD 2 (FRENCH EDITION) BY COLLECTIF DOWNLOAD EBOOK : MOBILE A2 LIVRE DE L'ELEVE + DVD 2 (FRENCH EDITION) BY COLLECTIF PDF

ESTADISTICA ELEMENTAL: LO ESENCIAL (SPANISH EDITION) BY ROBERT JOHNSON, PATRICIA KUBY

A BEGINNER'S GUIDE TO MODEL STEAM LOCOMOTIVES BY TIM COLES DOWNLOAD EBOOK : A BEGINNER'S GUIDE TO MODEL STEAM LOCOMOTIVES BY TIM COLES PDF

A GUIDE TO CONFIDENT LIVING BY NORMAN VINCENT PEALE DOWNLOAD EBOOK : A GUIDE TO CONFIDENT LIVING BY NORMAN VINCENT PEALE PDF

UNDERSTANDING HUMAN COMMUNICATION 10TH (TENTH) EDITION DOWNLOAD EBOOK : UNDERSTANDING HUMAN COMMUNICATION 10TH (TENTH) EDITION PDF

BLOODS, AN ORAL HISTORY OF THE VIETNAM WAR BY WALLACE TERRY DOWNLOAD EBOOK : BLOODS, AN ORAL HISTORY OF THE VIETNAM WAR BY WALLACE TERRY PDF

THE LITTLE FOXES PLAY IN THREE ACTS BY LILLIAN HELLMAN DOWNLOAD EBOOK : THE LITTLE FOXES PLAY IN THREE ACTS BY LILLIAN HELLMAN PDF

ROMEO AND JULIET (LARGE PRINT) BY WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE

EXPERIENCING MIS: COMPUTER SCIENCE, INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY BY CRAM101 TEXTBOOK REVIEWS

AIR SUPPLY GREATEST HITS: PIANO/ VOCAL/ CHORDS SHEET MUSIC BY AIR SUPPLY

POLITICAL ECONOMY: A COMPARATIVE APPROACH DOWNLOAD EBOOK : POLITICAL ECONOMY: A COMPARATIVE APPROACH PDF

THERE'S NO SUCH THING AS A DRAGON FROM DRAGONFLY BOOKS DOWNLOAD EBOOK : THERE'S NO SUCH THING AS A DRAGON FROM DRAGONFLY BOOKS PDF

THE UNTETHERED SOUL BY MICHAEL SINGER DOWNLOAD EBOOK : THE UNTETHERED SOUL BY MICHAEL SINGER PDF

THE CHRONICLE OF YOUNG SATAN BY MARK TWAIN

CHEBURASHKA: CROCODILE GENA AND HIS FRIENDS (KROKODIL GENA I EGO DRUZYA) - IN RUSSIAN LANGUAGE BY E. USPENSKY

WHY MEN LOSE INTEREST: HOW TO BE THE ONE WHO REALLY "GETS" HIM BY ELIZABETH STONE

OH, WICKED WANDA BY FREDERIC MULLALLY DOWNLOAD EBOOK : OH, WICKED WANDA BY FREDERIC MULLALLY PDF

FOURTH REICH OF THE RICH- AUTOGRAPHED COPY BY DES GRIFFIN DOWNLOAD EBOOK : FOURTH REICH OF THE RICH-AUTOGRAPHED COPY BY DES GRIFFIN PDF

ANALYZING PERFORMANCE: THEATER, DANCE, AND FILM PAPERBACK - FEBRUARY 24, 2003 BY PATRICE PAVIS

SNAKE PILOT: FLYING THE COBRA ATTACK HELICOPTER IN VIETNAM DOWNLOAD EBOOK : SNAKE PILOT: FLYING THE COBRA ATTACK HELICOPTER IN VIETNAM PDF

ELSEVIER COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO COMBINED MEDICAL SERVICES (UPSC) BY RAJEEV KUMAR, PRAKASH NAYAK

SYMBOLS, SEX AND THE STARS BY ERNEST BUSENBARK DOWNLOAD EBOOK : SYMBOLS, SEX AND THE STARS BY ERNEST BUSENBARK PDF

BLACK HAT DREAM: A GUIDE TO MAKING MONEY ONLINE WITH COST PER ACTION AND BLACK HAT TECHNIQUES BY MR. CHAD MCFARLIN

SET LIGHTING TECHNICIAN'S HANDBOOK: FILM LIGHTING EQUIPMENT, PRACTICE, AND ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION 4TH (FOURTH) EDITION

MEMES: FUNNY MEMES - ALL YOUR FAVORITE MEMES CHARACTERS IN ONE BOOK: EPIC COLLECTION OF HUMOR - FUNNY BOOKS BY MEMES

THE WHITE-MAGIC BOOK BY JOHN LE BRETON DOWNLOAD EBOOK : THE WHITE-MAGIC BOOK BY JOHN LE BRETON PDF

SUMMARY: THE AMAZON WAY: REVIEW AND ANALYSIS OF ROSSMAN'S BOOK BY BUSINESSNEWS PUBLISHING

DICTIONARY OF THE BIBLE BY S.J. JOHN L. MCKENZIE DOWNLOAD EBOOK : DICTIONARY OF THE BIBLE BY S.J. JOHN L. MCKENZIE PDF

THE NEW ITALIAN AMERICAN SONGBOOK 2ND EDITION ITALIAN HITS POPULAR IN AMERICA FROM BRAND: PROFESSIONAL MUSIC INSTITUTE

FLUENCY IN ENGLISH (NEW CONCEPT ENGLISH) BY L. G. ALEXANDER

THE GLOBAL CHALLENGE: INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, THIRD EDITION BY PUCIK, EVANS, BJORKMAN

501 SPANISH VERBS: FULLY CONJUGATED IN ALL THE TENSES IN A NEW EASY-TO- LEARN FORMAT ALPHABETICALLY ARRANGED BY CHRISTOPHER KENDRIS

CHINESE LION DANCE EXPLAINED BY WILLIAM C. HU DOWNLOAD EBOOK : CHINESE LION DANCE EXPLAINED BY WILLIAM C. HU PDF

TEST DE CAPACITE DE RAISONNEMENT ABSTRAIT POUR LES EXAMENS DU SELOR (FRENCH EDITION) BY EMMANUEL HETRU, CLAIRE MERCIER

OCR PHILOSOPHY OF RELIGION FOR AS AND A2 BY JILL OLIPHANT, MATTHEW TAYLOR

INTRODUCTION TO ANIMAL SCIENCE (5TH EDITION) BY W. STEPHEN DAMRON

A WAY OF BEING FREE BY BEN OKRI DOWNLOAD EBOOK : A WAY OF BEING FREE BY BEN OKRI PDF

COMPANION TO THE SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTIST HYMNAL BY WAYNE HOOPER DOWNLOAD EBOOK : COMPANION TO THE SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTIST HYMNAL BY WAYNE HOOPER PDF

BEYOND DEATH"S DOOR BY DR MAURICE RAWLINGS DOWNLOAD EBOOK : BEYOND DEATH"S DOOR BY DR MAURICE RAWLINGS PDF

GEOMETRY, TEACHER'S EDITION BY RAY C. JURGENSEN, RICHARD G. BROWN, JOHN W. JURGENSEN

RADIO SHACK BASIC ELECTRONICS BY GENE MCWHORTER, ALVIS J. EVANS DOWNLOAD EBOOK : RADIO SHACK BASIC ELECTRONICS BY GENE MCWHORTER, ALVIS J.

40 INTERMEDIATE SNARE DRUM SOLOS: FOR CONCERT PERFORMANCE FROM HAL LEONARD

DEWEY DECIMAL CLASSIFICATION, DDC 23 (DEWEY DECIMAL CLASSIFICATION & RELATIVE INDEX) BY MELVIL DEWEY

VICTIMS OF A MAP: A BILINGUAL ANTHOLOGY OF ARABIC POETRY BY ADONIS, MAHMUD DARWISH, SAMIH AL- QASIM

MERCATOR 11E édition - TOUT LE MARKETING à L'èRE NUMéRIQUE. AVEC E- BOOK

LEONARD COHEN - HALLELUJAH PIANO SOLO SHEET MUSIC FROM HAL LEONARD

PHILOGRAPHICS: BIG IDEAS IN SIMPLE SHAPES FROM BIS PUBLISHERS DOWNLOAD EBOOK : PHILOGRAPHICS: BIG IDEAS IN SIMPLE SHAPES FROM BIS PUBLISHERS PDF

LE GRAND LIVRE DU LUXE FROM EYROLLES DOWNLOAD EBOOK : LE GRAND LIVRE DU LUXE FROM EYROLLES PDF

THE INVISIBLE MAN DIARIES: VOLUME 2 BY STEVE HOGARTH

THE ROULETTE WINNER: A PRACTICAL GUIDE FOR BEATING THE WHEEL BY LEE TUTOR

BYE, BYE MISS AMERICAN PIE BY JAN GREENBERG

LES FONDAMENTAUX DU CYCLISME : TOME 2 (FRENCH EDITION) FROM AMPHORA

FROM OLD ENGLISH TO STANDARD ENGLISH: A COURSE BOOK IN LANGUAGE VARIATIONS ACROSS TIME (STUDIES IN ENGLISH LANGUAGE) BY DENNIS FREEBORN

THE EPIC OF AMERICA BY JAMES TRUSLOW ADAMS DOWNLOAD EBOOK : THE EPIC OF AMERICA BY JAMES TRUSLOW ADAMS PDF

SKIN CARE BY DR. RENU GUPTA DOWNLOAD EBOOK : SKIN CARE BY DR. RENU GUPTA PDF

DIAGNOSTIC IMAGING: BREAST, 2ND ED: PUBLISHED DOWNLOAD EBOOK : DIAGNOSTIC IMAGING: BREAST, 2ND ED: PUBLISHED PDF

HISTOLOGIE ET BIOLOGIE CELLULAIRE (FRENCH EDITION) FROM DE BOECK

GLASS ON A STICK BY ELYSE BRUCE DOWNLOAD EBOOK : GLASS ON A STICK BY ELYSE BRUCE PDF

PEOPLE THE LIE BY M.D. M. SCOTT PECK DOWNLOAD EBOOK : PEOPLE THE LIE BY M.D. M. SCOTT PECK PDF

BASIC ENGINEERING ECONOMY BY HENRY MALCOLM STEINER

EAR TRAINING AND SIGHT SINGING BY MAURICE LIEBERMAN DOWNLOAD EBOOK : EAR TRAINING AND SIGHT SINGING BY MAURICE LIEBERMAN PDF

MUSIC OF THE BAROQUE BY DAVID SCHULENBERG

TURBO PASCAL 7: THE COMPLETE REFERENCE BY STEPHEN K. O'BRIEN, STEVEN NAMEROFF

FOURIER SERIES (DOVER BOOKS ON MATHEMATICS) BY G. H. HARDY, W. W. ROGOSINSKI

ARCHAIC AND CLASSICAL GREEK ART (OXFORD HISTORY OF ART) BY ROBIN OSBORNE

ENCYCLOPEDIA OF PARASITOLOGY BY HEINZ MEHLHORN

KYIRUX II: THE HIDDEN HISTORY BY KAPIEL RAAJ

LA HISTORIA DEL AMOR/ THE HISTORY OF LOVE (SPANISH EDITION) BY NICOLE KRAUSS

THE PRINCESS: SHORT STORY BY D. H. LAWRENCE DOWNLOAD EBOOK : THE PRINCESS: SHORT STORY BY D. H. LAWRENCE PDF

AMAZING ANIMALS: TIGERS BY VALERIE BODDEN DOWNLOAD EBOOK : AMAZING ANIMALS: TIGERS BY VALERIE BODDEN PDF

ALBANIAN ETYMOLOGICAL DICTIONARY BY VLADIMIR OREL DOWNLOAD EBOOK : ALBANIAN ETYMOLOGICAL DICTIONARY BY VLADIMIR OREL PDF

PRINCIPLES OF LEADERSHIP BY ANDREW DUBRIN DOWNLOAD EBOOK : PRINCIPLES OF LEADERSHIP BY ANDREW DUBRIN PDF

GCSE ENGLISH TEXT GUIDE - A CHRISTMAS CAROL BY CGP BOOKS

WISDOM FROM T.D. JAKES BY T. D. JAKES

ONCOLOGIA GINECOLOGICA CLINICA (SPANISH EDITION) BY WILLIAM T. CREASMAN, PHILIP J. DISAIA

LADY (KENNY ROGERS) - SIMPLIFIED PIANO ARRANGEMENT SHEET MUSIC DOWNLOAD EBOOK : LADY (KENNY ROGERS) - SIMPLIFIED PIANO ARRANGEMENT SHEET MUSIC PDF

THE DIRECTOR'S CRAFT: A HANDBOOK FOR THE THEATRE BY KATIE MITCHELL

IN MY OWN LITTLE CORNER, CINDERELLA SHEET MUSIC, 1957 FROM WILLIAMSON

TOWN, CITY, AND NATION: ENGLAND, (O P U S) BY PHILIP J. WALLER

WILD SWAN BY CELESTE DE BLASIS DOWNLOAD EBOOK : WILD SWAN BY CELESTE DE BLASIS PDF

SUMMARY: THE 4-HOUR WORKWEEK...IN 30 MINUTES - A CONCISE SUMMARY OF TIMOTHY FERRISS'S BESTSELLING BOOK BY 30 MINUTE EXPERT SUMMARIES

ELECTRONICS WORKSHOP COMPANION FOR HOBBYISTS BY STAN GIBILISCO DOWNLOAD EBOOK : ELECTRONICS WORKSHOP COMPANION FOR HOBBYISTS BY STAN GIBILISCO PDF

PUBLIC FINANCE BY HARVEY S. ROSEN DOWNLOAD EBOOK : PUBLIC FINANCE BY HARVEY S. ROSEN PDF

Transcription:

Read Online and Download Ebook STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT AND COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE: CONCEPTS AND CASES (5TH EDITION) BY JAY B. BARNEY, WILLIAM S. HESTERLY DOWNLOAD EBOOK : STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT AND COMPETITIVE JAY B. BARNEY, WILLIAM S. HESTERLY PDF

Click link bellow and free register to download ebook: STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT AND COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE: CONCEPTS AND CASES (5TH EDITION) BY JAY B. BARNEY, WILLIAM S. HESTERLY DOWNLOAD FROM OUR ONLINE LIBRARY

Simply for you today! Discover your preferred publication right here by downloading and also getting the soft documents of guide Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly This is not your time to generally likely to guide stores to purchase a book. Below, ranges of publication Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly and collections are offered to download. Among them is this Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly as your preferred e-book. Getting this e-book Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly by on the internet in this website could be understood now by seeing the link page to download and install. It will certainly be very easy. Why should be right here?

Download: STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT AND COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE: CONCEPTS AND CASES (5TH EDITION) BY Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly. A job may obligate you to always enhance the understanding as well as encounter. When you have no sufficient time to boost it straight, you could obtain the encounter as well as expertise from checking out guide. As everyone knows, book Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly is preferred as the window to open the globe. It implies that checking out publication Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly will certainly give you a new way to find everything that you need. As guide that we will provide here, Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly Surely, to boost your life high quality, every publication Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly will certainly have their certain driving lesson. However, having specific recognition will certainly make you feel much more confident. When you really feel something occur to your life, in some cases, checking out book Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly can aid you to make tranquility. Is that your genuine hobby? In some cases yes, yet occasionally will certainly be uncertain. Your option to read Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly as one of your reading books, could be your correct book to read now. This is not about how a lot this publication Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly prices; it is not also concerning just what sort of publication you really love to review. It is about exactly what you could take and obtain from reading this Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly You can favor to decide on other e-book; however, it doesn't matter if you try to make this book Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly as your reading option. You will not regret it. This soft file e-book Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly can be your excellent buddy in any situation.

For courses in strategy and strategic management. Core strategic management concepts without the excess. Just the essentials, Strategic Management and Competitive Advantage strips out excess by only presenting material that answers the question: does this concept help readers analyze real business situations? This carefully crafted approach provides readers with all the tools necessary for strategic analysis. Teaching and Learning Experience This program will provide a better teaching and learning experience for you and your students. Here s how: Improve Results with MyManagementLab: MyManagementLab delivers proven results in helping students succeed and provides engaging experiences that personalize learning. Help Students Develop Critical Thinking Skills: Proven pedagogy geared towards ensuring students grasp the concepts. Present Specific Issues in a Flexible Format: Each chapter has four short sections that present specific issues in more depth, allowing the professor and the student to adapt the text to their particular needs. This package contains: 0133127400 / 9780133127409: Strategic Management and Competitive Advantage, 5e 0133113000 / 9780133113006 NEW MyManagementLab with Pearson etext Standalone Access Card for Strategic Management and Competitive Advantage, 5e Sales Rank: #29904 in Books Published on: 2014-08-23 Original language: English Number of items: 1 Dimensions: 10.10" h x 1.10" w x 8.00" l,.0 pounds Binding: Hardcover 592 pages Most helpful customer reviews 18 of 18 people found the following review helpful.

Great book but missing the cases By Andy The kindle version of this book is missing the cases that was required in my class. I had to find a classmate to make a copy for me. It was a great inconvenience full book should have been available. 14 of 14 people found the following review helpful. Be careful: Kindle and hardcover editions are different By David W. Logan So far, I like the book. It's fairly straight to the points without too much fluff, but I've only gotten into the second chapter. The big problem that I (and others) have found is that the hardcover and Kindle versions and different, and this fact is not made clear on either of the Amazon listings. The Kindle version does not include the cases, and perhaps the paperback version does not as well (I don't know). I can verify, however, that the hardcover version contains all of the necessary cases (over 200 more pages). So, make sure that you check the ISBN for the exact version you need before purchasing. To reiterate... * The HARDCOVER edition, entitled "Strategic Management and Competitive Advantage: Concepts and Cases" (ISBN 978-0132555500), is 624 pages long and COMES WITH ALL OF THE CASES. * The KINDLE edition, entitled "Strategic Management and Competitive Advantage: Concepts" (ISBN 978-0132546348), is 408 pages long and DOES NOT INCLUDE THE CASES. 7 of 7 people found the following review helpful. Did not include case studies! By Ben Davis Bought the book thinking it had the case studies in it and found out when it arrived that it did not! That was one of the biggest reasons why I bought the book. I had to have those for class and the book did not supply that case studies, very unhappy with it. See all 35 customer reviews...

By downloading this soft documents e-book Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly in the on the internet link download, you remain in the initial step right to do. This site really offers you simplicity of ways to obtain the most effective publication, from best vendor to the new launched book. You could find more books in this site by checking out every web link that we provide. Among the collections, Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly is among the most effective collections to market. So, the first you get it, the first you will obtain all positive concerning this publication Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly Simply for you today! Discover your preferred publication right here by downloading and also getting the soft documents of guide Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly This is not your time to generally likely to guide stores to purchase a book. Below, ranges of publication Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly and collections are offered to download. Among them is this Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly as your preferred e-book. Getting this e-book Strategic Management And Competitive Advantage: Concepts And Cases (5th Edition) By Jay B. Barney, William S. Hesterly by on the internet in this website could be understood now by seeing the link page to download and install. It will certainly be very easy. Why should be right here?