An Analysis of Vocal Jazz Repertoire by Three Selected Publishing Companies

Transcription

1 418625UPD / BakerUpdate An Analysis of Vocal Jazz Repertoire by Three Selected Publishing Companies Update 30(1) National Association for Music Education Reprints and permission: sagepub.com/journalspermissions.nav DOI: / Wilbur R. Baker Jr. 1 Abstract The purpose of this study was to analyze SATB (soprano, alto, tenor, bass) vocal jazz octavos (N = 150) from three publishers in an effort to (a) identify the most prolific arrangers/composers, (b) cite improvisation opportunities, (c) document publisher improvisation markings, (d) indicate repeated titles, (e) identify most popular styles, and (f) investigate instrumental accompaniment combinations. Results revealed that the most prolific composers were Kirby Shaw, Steve Zegree, and Darmon Meader. Less than one fourth (22.6%) of the charts included improvisation opportunities for singers with transcribed notation (n = 18) or instructions (n = 16). Swing and Ballad styles were more prevalent than Latin and Contemporary. Categories for instrumental accompaniments included none/a cappella (n = 31), bass (n = 1), piano (n = 39), combo (n = 48), and augmented combo (n = 32). Further results and discussion are included. Keywords vocal jazz, choral music, improvisation, music publishers, scat singing, National Standards for Music Education Awareness of jazz education and its popular appeal to students have grown considerably in the past 50 years (Fisher, 1988; International Association for Jazz Education, 2007; Murphy, 1993). For example, jazz degree programs in higher education institutions have placed more emphasis on the study of jazz; 15 institutions offered a Bachelor of Music degree with a major in Jazz and Studio Music in 1974 (Barr, 1974), whereas 309 colleges and universities offered programs of study in jazz in ( Jazz Education Guide, ). Of these 309 institutions, 104 schools had 50 or more students enrolled in jazz programs, and 28 schools had 100 or more students in their jazz departments. The growth and development of jazz programs in higher education have also facilitated the appearance of jazz in middle and high schools (Collier, 1994). Many secondary schools offer jazz ensembles, theory, and/or improvisation classes as a part of the daily schedule (Herzig, 1998; Knox, 1996; Wehr-Flowers, 2006). Extracurricular activities in secondary jazz educational settings include contests, festivals, and concerts for both instrumental and vocal jazz ensembles. Although there is a 60-year history of inclusion of instrumental jazz ensembles in the public schools (MENC: The National Association for Music Education, 1994; Payne, 1973), the more recent popularity of vocal jazz programs has facilitated the need for formal study of vocal jazz pedagogy and specific vocal jazz techniques (Greennagel, 1996). Research investigating specific vocal jazz techniques such as vibrato (Silvera-Jenson, 2005), articulation styles (Cooper, 1992), choral jazz arranging (Regin, 2003; Smalley, 1972), and accompanying (Israels, 1990; Roothaan, 1999; Rose, 1985) has helped solidify this medium into a viable experience that can be taught in the schools. Several practitioners in the field have experimented with various strategies for scat singing (Baker, 2010), shakes (Aitken, 1984), inflections (Schwartz, 1979), staging (Zegree, 2002), and amplification (Aitken, 1985). Additionally, with the appearance of vocal jazz charts, which include solo and improvisation sections, jazz repertoire has been identified as an important development in choral program performance literature (White, 1982). Extensive reviews of choral music education research have revealed a lack of vocal jazz studies in the extant literature. In a summary of choral music education research, Gonzo (1973) concluded that vocal repertoire research was sparse and did not seem to constitute major research activity (p. 21). In a follow-up study of dissertations and professional journals, Hylton (1983) cited extensive choral music education research in the areas of choral rehearsal techniques/conducting and noted that studies of repertoire were lacking. Although Grant and Norris (1998) identified 11 choral literature studies in a subsequent 1 New Jersey City University, Jersey City, NJ, USA Corresponding Author: Wilbur R. Baker Jr., Department of Music, Dance and Theatre, New Jersey City University, 2039 Kennedy Boulevard, Jersey City, NJ , USA wbaker1@njcu.edu

2 Baker 55 review of choral music education research, none of these investigations included vocal jazz. The current study will address the need for and relevance of a vocal jazz repertoire analysis. Improvisation has been noted as an integral component in the performance of jazz and an important, yet misunderstood or neglected, concept in the field of music education (Gridley, 2008; Madura, 1996; Wehr-Flowers, 2006). Standard number three of the National Standards for Music Education (MENC, 1994), which provides benchmarks to determine how well students are learning and performing, states that students should improvise melodies, variations, and accompaniments. Despite this emphasis on teaching improvisation, studies have concluded that teachers are ill prepared and/or reluctant to employ improvisational techniques in the classroom (Bell, 2003; Byo, 1999; Knobloch, 1985; Lehman, 1995). Classically oriented university students often exhibited anxiety when asked to demonstrate or study the spontaneous, improvisatory, ambiguous, open forms, and kinesthetic movement of the less rigid style of jazz performance (Elliott, 1986, p. 46). Research relating to confidence in and learning to perform jazz improvisation has found mixed results (Flack, 2004; Heil, 2005; Ward-Steinman, 2007, 2008; Wehr- Flowers, 2006). For example, Ward-Steinman (2007) found that intense and comprehensive instruction in jazz listening, singing, transcribing, arranging, and improvising increased the improvisational teaching confidence levels of music education majors enrolled in a 6-week vocal jazz course. Heil (2005), however, concluded in a pretest posttest design that formal vocal jazz improvisation instructional materials had no effect on high school students attitudes toward singing jazz. He did find that there was a significant effect on students ability to sing appropriate tonal material over the rhythm changes of harmonic progressions. Vocal jazz repertoire occasionally includes improvisation sections within the charts. Arrangers of these charts designate the improvisation sections either by transcribing solos with scat syllables, including performance notes to improvise a melody, or by inserting measures of rests with instructions to improvise over chord changes. Although there are advantages and disadvantages to each method, successful improvisation may be based on the teachers and students abilities to interpret the notes of the arranger or composer. To date, there is only one research study that has focused on the publication of vocal jazz ensemble repertoire and no comprehensive database of vocal jazz ensemble music, which includes existing improvisation opportunities. In a survey of Texas choral directors, Cruse (1999) cited 10 of the most common moderately difficult vocal jazz arrangements for high school vocal ensembles by compiling a list of selections with title and composer categories. There was no discussion or inclusion of improvisation opportunities in his study. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to assimilate SATB (soprano, alto, tenor, bass) vocal jazz octavos from multiple publishers and build a database of existing high school vocal jazz ensemble repertoire. The research questions guiding this study were the following: Research Question 1: Who are some of the most prolific arrangers/composers of vocal jazz music? Research Question 2: Are there opportunities for vocalists to improvise? Research Question 3: How are improvisation opportunities indicated in the score? Research Question 4: What titles appear most frequently? Research Question 5: What styles of vocal jazz appear most frequently? Research Question 6: What are the most common types of instrumental accompaniment forces? Research Question 7: Are there any significant differences between publishing companies and the number of arrangers/composers, song titles, improvisational opportunities, vocal jazz styles, or instrumental accompaniment forces? Method Selection of Repertoire The repertoire (N = 150) for this study was collected from three publishers: Alfred, Hal Leonard, and Shawnee Press. Selection of these publishing companies was based on (a) the American Choral Directors Association s website listing of major vocal jazz repertoire publishers (American Choral Directors Association, n.d.), (b) the accessibility of their arrangements to the high school singer, (c) their marketability and familiarity to the high school teacher, and (d) their identification as major sources of vocal jazz repertoire by widely accepted authorities in the field, Vijay Singh (2008) and Stephen Zegree (2002). The music in this study was selected from the catalogues of these three publishing companies. It was determined a priori to select jazz repertoire available only in single SATB octavo format. Medleys, revues, choral/instrumental packs, and other voicings of selections (SSA, SAB, TTB, etc.) were not included in this study. Also determined a priori was that selected pieces had to be currently in print and readily available through J.W. Pepper & Son, Inc., a major national distributor of sheet music. The total number of octavos in each publisher s catalogue varied: Shawnee Press, n = 70; Alfred/ Warner Brothers, n = 114; Hal Leonard, n = 188. To

3 56 Update 30(1) analyze a proportionate number of selections from each publisher and make possible future comparisons between the three companies, individual publisher catalogue listings were randomized by Research Randomizer software program. These three lists were then downloaded into a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet and the first 50 pieces from each publisher listing was sampled. This created a total of 150 octavos from the three companies. Classification of Repertoire Once the list of publications was downloaded into an Excel spreadsheet, a Microsoft Access database was created with the following categories of classification for each piece: Title, Composer/Arranger, Style/Genre, Publisher, Year of publication/original Year of Publication, Vendor Number, Accompaniment, Solos, and Improvisation. According to the MENC (now NAfME) website (Bunge, 2004), the classification of jazz literature may be divided into four main styles: Swing, Ballad, Latin, and Contemporary (any piece composed after 1960). These styles served as a basis for the classification of each octavo as indicated by the publisher or observed during the score analysis. Prerecorded accompaniments were excluded from the accompaniment category. However, optional instrument packages and instrumental passages either printed in the choral score or purchasable as parts were included as accompaniments. Solos were determined by voice part and indicated as voice if no specific part assignment was evident in the printed score. Improvisation opportunities were also noted as they appeared in the score. Results A total of 150 octavos from the three publishers, Alfred, Hal Leonard, and Shawnee Press, were analyzed; sums and percentages were obtained for each research question. For the first research question on the most prolific arrangers/composers of vocal jazz music, results indicate that 3 arrangers/composers had more than 10 charts each: Kirby Shaw, n = 22; Steve Zegree, n = 18; and Darmon Meader, n = 11. These arrangers/composers had a combined total of 51 charts or 34% of the total number of compositions. The remaining arrangers /composers (n = 40) charts ranged from 1 to 9 per individual (M = 2.5). Twenty-three of the sampled arrangers/composers included 2 or more charts. Kirby Shaw and Phil Mattson charts were published by all three companies. Ten arrangers/ composers were published by two of the selected companies, and the remaining 11 arrangers/composers were published exclusively by Alfred, Hal Leonard, or Shawnee Press. See the arrangers/composers listed from largest to smallest number of compositions in Table 1. Of the 150 octavos investigated, 23% (n = 34) of the charts included opportunities for improvisation, whereas the remaining 77% (n = 116) of the charts did not. The improvisation sections within the 34 charts were assigned to one of the following categories: (a) transcribed scat solos, (b) notated melodies, and (c) instruction without notation. Transcribed scat solos included charts with instructions to ad lib or improvise over transcribed melodies and charts with specific scat lyrics beneath the given melodies. Notated melody categorization included a transcribed melody without scat syllables or lyrics. The instruction without notation category contained score markings that varied from performance notes in the preface to repeated choral vamps with solo improvisation appearing above the staves. Although a majority of the charts did not indicate any opportunities for vocal improvisation (n = 116 or 77.3%), the remaining charts did include either transcribed scat solos or notated melodies as guides for improvisation (n = 18 or 12%) or instruct the performer to improvise without any given notation (n = 16 or 10.6%). The list of complete song titles with type of improvisation opportunity is in Table 1. A few titles (n = 13) appear twice in the study: Alexander s Ragtime Band; As Time Goes By; Autumn Leaves; Here s that Rainy Day; I Got Rhythm; I m Always Chasing Rainbows; My Funny Valentine; Over the Rainbow; Sing, Sing, Sing; Take the A Train; Tuxedo Junction; The Way You Look Tonight; and When I Fall in Love. These standard selections represent music from the first half of the 20th century known as the Big Band/Swing era. Additionally, the 1930 ballad, Embraceable You, appears three times in the listing. None of the contemporary titles were repeated as shown in Table 1. An analysis of jazz styles represented by the three publishers indicates that Swing is the most frequently published (n = 65 or 43.3%), followed by Ballad (n = 45 or 30%), Contemporary (n = 29 or 19.3%), and Latin (n = 11 or 7.3%). The titles Autumn Leaves and Here s that Rainy Day appear multiple times but are arranged in different style categories including swing, Latin, and ballad. See the complete list of song titles by jazz style in Table 1. To determine whether charts used accompaniment, songs were placed in either the accompanied selections category (n = 119) or the none/a cappella selections category (n = 31). Additionally, the accompanied selections were divided into three subcategories: (a) standard combo, which includes piano, guitar, bass, and drums; (b) piano only; or (c) augmented standard combo, which includes the standard combo or piano as well as additional brass, woodwind, string, or other keyboard instruments. The most common types of instrumental forces were the standard

4 Baker 57 Table 1. Jazz SATB (Soprano, Alto, Tenor, Bass) Octavo Listing Arranger/ Composer # Title Improvisation Style Accompaniment Publisher Kirby Shaw 22 A Cappella No Contemporary None H Bim-Bom Instructions Latin Combo H Joy Sounds II No Contemporary None H Fly Me to the Moon No Latin Combo, trumpets I and II, H tenor sax, trombone Java Jive No Swing None A Once Upon a Time No Ballad None H Hit Me with a Hot Note and Instructions Swing Piano A Watch Me Bounce! Do You Know What It Means No Swing Combo, trumpet, clarinet, H to Miss New Orleans? trombone, banjo/guitar Tuxedo Junction Transcriptions Swing Combo, trumpets I and II, S tenor sax, trombone Shoo Fly Pie and Apple Pan Transcriptions Swing Combo H Dowdy Stormy Weather No Swing Piano, optional instrumental H accompaniment I Got the Sun in the Morning No Swing Piano H Unforgettable No Ballad Combo H Mississippi Mud No Swing Piano, trumpet, clarinet, H trombone, banjo/guitar, bass/ tuba, drums T Aint What You Do (It s the Transcriptions Swing Combo S Way that You Do It) Way You Look Tonight, The No Ballad None H Time After Time No Swing Piano A Take Five No Swing Combo A Feelin Groovy No Contemporary Combo S Skatin With My Baby Instructions Contemporary Combo S My Funny Valentine No Ballad None H Choo Choo Ch Boogie Instructions Swing Combo, trumpets I and II, H tenor sax, trombone Steve 18 Take the A Train Transcriptions Swing Piano S Zegree Satin Doll Transcriptions Swing Piano, optional guitar S Look of Love, The Instructions Contemporary Combo H Smile No Contemporary None H Trickle, Trickle No Contemporary Combo S I ve Grown Accustomed to Instructions Ballad None H Her Face They Say It s Wonderful No Ballad None H But Beautiful Transcriptions Ballad Piano S Here s That Rainy Day No Ballad Piano S Mas Que Nada Instructions Latin Combo H Just in Time No Swing Piano H In My Life No Contemporary None H This Masquerade Instructions Latin Combo S Night We Called It a Day, The Instructions Ballad Piano S Hello, Young Lovers Instructions Ballad None H Isn t It Romantic? Instructions Ballad Piano H Lady Is a Tramp, The No Latin Combo, trumpets I and H II, tenor sax, trombone, percussion Try to Remember No Ballad None H (continued)

5 58 Update 30(1) Table 1. (continued) Arranger/ Composer # Title Improvisation Style Accompaniment Publisher Darmon Meader Paris Rutherford Russ Robinson 11 Smack Dab in the Middle Instructions Swing Combo, 2 alto saxes, 2 S tenor saxes, baritone sax, 4 trumpets, 4 trombones Do Nothin Til You Hear No Swing Combo A from Me Charleston Alley No Swing Combo S Last Rose of Summer, The No Contemporary None S Here s That Rainy Day No Latin Combo S Sing, Sing, Sing Instructions Swing Combo/Big Band arrangement S Me and Julio Down by the No Contemporary Combo S Schoolyard Why Don t You Write Me? Instructions Contemporary Combo S I Could Write a Book Transcriptions Swing Combo, trumpets I and II A (optional alto sax in absence of trumpet II), tenor sax, trombone Taking a Chance on Love No Swing Combo A Moonglow No Swing Combo A 9 Autumn Leaves No Swing Combo A Quiet Nights of Quiet Stars No Contemporary Combo H (Corcovado) Easy to Love Transcriptions Latin Combo, trumpet, tenor sax H Sleepin Bee, A Transcriptions Swing Combo H Nica s Dream Transcriptions Latin Combo H Yesterdays No Ballad None H Brazil No Latin Combo, percussion H My Romance Transcriptions Swing Combo, trumpet, tenor sax H April in Paris Transcriptions Ballad Piano H 8 Over the Rainbow No Ballad None A I m Beginning to See the No Swing Piano A Light As Time Goes By No Swing Combo A It Had to Be You No Swing Combo A Mack the Knife Instructions Swing Piano A When I Fall in Love No Ballad Piano A Take the A Train No Swing Piano S Let s Call the Whole Thing No Swing Combo, flute A Off Jay Althouse 7 La Musica (The Music) No Contemporary Combo, trumpets I and II, A trombones I and II, alto sax, tenor sax Yo Vivo Cantando No Contemporary Combo, trumpets I and II, A trombones I and II, percussion I Can t Give You Anything but No Swing Combo, trumpets I and II, A Love tenor sax, trombone License to Scat No Contemporary Combo, glockenspiel, vibes A Embraceable You No Ballad Piano A Come Rain or Come Shine No Swing Combo, alto sax, tenor sax, A trumpet, trombone As Time Goes By No Swing Combo, alto sax A (continued)

6 Baker 59 Table 1. (continued) Arranger/ Composer # Title Improvisation Style Accompaniment Publisher Teena Chinn 7 Anything Goes No Swing Combo, studio horns A I ve Got You Under My Skin No Swing Combo A Embraceable You No Ballad None A Someone to Watch Over Me No Ballad None A Over the Rainbow No Ballad Combo A At Last Instructions Ballad Combo A My Funny Valentine No Ballad None A Carl 6 Embraceable You No Ballad Combo A Strommen They Can t Take That Away No Swing Combo A from Me I m Always Chasing Rainbows No Swing Combo A Shadow of Your Smile, The No Contemporary Combo S Birth of the Blues, The No Swing Combo A All of Me No Swing Piano S Gene 5 Snowfall No Ballad None S Puerling Here, There, and Everywhere No Contemporary None S Michelle No Contemporary None S Yesterday No Contemporary None S Christmas Song, The No Ballad Combo H Phil Mattson 4 S wonderful Transcriptions Swing Combo A I ll Be Seeing You No Ballad None H Tangerine Transcriptions Swing Combo S September Song No Ballad None H Hawley 3 Me and My Shadow No Swing Piano S Ades Sentimental Journey No Swing Piano S Dream No Ballad Piano S John Coates 3 Summer Song No Ballad Piano S Look for the Silver Lining No Ballad Piano S Moon River No Ballad Combo S Roger 3 Blue Skies Transcriptions Swing Combo, flugelhorn solo H Emerson Eleanor Rigby No Contemporary Piano H Go Tell It on the Mountain No Contemporary Piano H Mark Hayes 3 Just One of Those Things No Swing Piano, clarinet, 2 alto/ A tenor saxes, 3 trumpets, 2 trombones, bass trombone, master rhythm I Got Rhythm No Swing Combo A Alexander s Ragtime Band No Swing Piano S Greg 3 Voice Dance III No Contemporary None S Jasperse Voice Dance V No Contemporary None S Begin the Beguine No Latin Combo S Philip Kern 3 But Not for Me No Ballad None A Alexander s Ragtime Band No Swing Piano, clarinet, tenor sax, A trumpet, trombone, percussion, banjo, tuba, drums Sing, Sing, Sing No Swing Piano, instrumental score S (continued)

7 60 Update 30(1) Table 1. (continued) Arranger/ Composer # Title Improvisation Style Accompaniment Publisher Darmon 3 For All We Know No Ballad Piano A Meader and Peter Eldridge Baby Driver No Contemporary Combo S Chamego (Betty s Bossa) No Contemporary Combo S Roy 3 On a Clear Day You Can See No Ballad Piano 3-hand, optional organ S Ringwald Forever Stardust No Ballad Piano S Love Is a Many-Splendored No Ballad Piano S Thing Alan 2 Don t Sit Under the Apple No Swing Piano A Billingsley Tree Nightengale Sang in Berkeley No Ballad None H Square, A Mark 2 Don t Get Around Much No Swing Combo H Brymer Anymore When I Fall in Love No Ballad Piano H Ed Lojeski 2 Girl From Ipanema, The No Contemporary Combo, synthesizer, optional H (Garata de Ipanema) percussion Georgia on My Mind No Ballad None H Harry 2 Mood Indigo No Swing Combo S Simeone Charade No Ballad Piano S Doug 1 My One and Only Love No Ballad None H Andrews April 1 Like Someone in Love No Swing Combo S Arabian- Tini Leo Arnaud 1 Autumn Leaves No Ballad Piano S Ruth 1 Blue Moon Transcriptions Swing Combo, trumpet A Artman John 1 I Love a Piano No Swing Piano A Brimhall Dave 1 Boogie 1 A.M. No Contemporary Piano A Brubeck Rosana 1 Telephone Song Transcriptions Contemporary Combo H Eckert Jeff Funk 1 Happy Days Are Here Again No Swing Combo, horn pack A Greg Gilpin 1 Tea for Two No Swing Piano A David 1 Maple Leaf Rag No Swing Piano S Greenberg Mac Huff 1 Fascinating Rhythm No Swing Piano A Julie 1 Way You Look Tonight, The No Ballad None H Knowles David Lantz 1 Darn That Dream No Ballad Combo S Donald 1 I m Always Chasing Rainbows No Swing Bass (optional) A Moore Jerry Nowak 1 Tuxedo Junction Transcriptions Swing Piano (Parts I and II), optional electric guitar, bass, guitar H (continued)

8 Baker 61 Table 1. (continued) Arranger/ Composer # Title Improvisation Style Accompaniment Publisher Jackie O Neill Pete Schmutte Larry Shackley Robert Sterling Clay Warnick Luigi Zaninelli 1 In the Still of the Night No Ballad Piano H 1 Night and Day No Latin Combo A 1 Ain t Misbehavin No Swing Combo, clarinet, trumpet, A trombone 1 Oh! You Beautiful Doll No Swing Combo S 1 I Got Rhythm No Swing Piano A 1 It s a Raggy Waltz No Contemporary Piano S Note: H = Hal Leonard; A = Alfred; S = Shawnee Press. Number column (#) represents total number of charts by arranger/composer. In the Accompaniment column, Combo indicates piano, guitar, bass, and drums, and None represents a cappella. combo (n = 48) followed by piano only (n = 39). I m Always Chasing Rainbows by Donald Moore was the only accompanied chart that did not include piano in the standard combo grouping. The remaining accompanied charts augmented the standard combo or piano with additional instruments (n = 32). Sing, Sing, Sing by Jay Althouse was the only chart in more than one category as the publisher offered accompaniments for a standard combo or big band. When the number of charts by each publisher was compared by variable (number of composers per publisher, repeated titles, styles, improvisation opportunities, and accompaniments), there were no significant differences between the publishers and the number of arrangers/ composers, repeated titles, and improvisational opportunities. However, chi-square analyses revealed significant differences between publishers: χ 2 (2, N = 65) = 10.59, p <.01, with 68% (n = 34) of Alfred, 36% (n = 18) of Shawnee, and 26% (n = 13) of Hal Leonard publications, respectively, indicating swing style as a percentage of their individually sampled selections. Additionally, significant differences were found with the contemporary style: χ 2 (2, N = 29) = 6.25, p <.05; in 8% (n = 4) of Alfred, 20% (n = 10) of Hal Leonard, and 30% (n = 15) of Shawnee Press publications, respectively. Analysis of the accompaniment variable, none/a cappella: χ 2 (2, N = 31) = 8.61, p <.01; revealed significant differences, with Hal Leonard (36%, n = 18) publishing more a cappella selections than Alfred (8%, n = 6) and Shawnee Press (14%, n = 7) combined. Discussion Several interesting results were found within this investigation. First, vocal jazz music publishers produce many charts by select individuals, with 3 out of 43 of the arranger/composers publishing 34% of the total number of selections. It is interesting this data set s most prolific composer published in all three companies, and the next two most prolific composers (of the 150 sampled titles) each published in two of the three publishing companies. A possible reason for this result may be because of the fact that there are relatively few vocal jazz arrangers/composers actively creating charts. However, questions of whether publishing companies are highlighting a select few arrangers/composers or whether these publishers are seeking/wanting other arrangers and composers to contribute more vocal jazz selections to the existing body of repertoire have yet to be answered. Furthermore, the lack of variety in arrangers/composers among these publishers may limit choice options for choral directors and, as a result, discourage them from programming vocal jazz. Improvisation is considered to be an integral component of jazz music, however, more than three fourths (77.3%) of the vocal jazz charts within this study made no reference to this performance practice in the printed score. Many authorities in the field (Gridley, 1994; International Association for Jazz Education, 2007; Zegree, 2002) have identified improvisation as a cornerstone of jazz music. It is also widely accepted that serious jazz musicians possess the talent and ability to improvise. The omission of improvisation in so many charts seems to be contrary to common and authentic performance practice in the realm of jazz music. Perhaps there is the perception among arrangers/composers that music educators are not prepared to teach improvisation. Such a perception would concur with the findings of Bell (2003), Byo (1999), Knobloch (1985), and Lehman (1995). A comparison of vocal jazz styles most commonly found within the selections investigated revealed that

9 62 Update 30(1) swing and ballad were more prevalent than Latin and contemporary. The imbalance of jazz style diversity limits the availability of varied repertoire from which the conductor may choose. The reasons for this result are beyond the scope of this study. However, one might contemplate that the law of supply and demand may dictate the styles of music each publisher chooses to print. That is, if choral directors are programming more swing and ballad selections than contemporary or Latin selections, then arrangers and composers are writing more charts in these styles to market and publish their work. It may also be that swing and ballad titles are easily recognized as standards from the golden age of jazz (Carmichael, Gershwin, Porter, Rodgers and Hart, etc.), and as a result, these titles are considered to be more marketable. Finally, an awareness of vocal jazz accompaniment textures and instrumentations is demonstrated by the balance of printed materials for a variety of ensemble types: a cappella, 21%; standard combo, 32%; piano, 26%; and various instrument combination, 21%. Although Hal Leonard published more a cappella charts (n = 18) than Alfred (n = 6) and Shawnee Press (n = 7) combined, there were no significant differences between other styles of accompaniment among these three publishers. It should be noted, however, that this study was limited to a random sample of each publisher s vocal jazz inventory with 50 titles from each of the three publishers catalogues. The studied titles thus represented 71% from Shawnee Press, 44% from Alfred, and 27% from Hal Leonard, respectively. It is possible that some composers or styles were missed by using this particular random sampling approach, and it may worth further examination of trends within each publishing company. Although these findings are limited to this particular study and should not be generalized to other jazz publishing companies, data from this study seem to suggest that arrangers, composers, and publishing companies should consider providing students with more opportunities to improvise in the printed scores of vocal jazz. The establishment of this technique as a national standard for music education and its acceptance as an integral component of the jazz genre deem improvisation to be a worthy skill for students to practice and perform. Future research may lead to more information about this topic in an effort to ascertain why arrangers, composers, and publishing companies seem to omit improvisation in their printed scores. Declaration of Conflicting Interests The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interests with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. Funding The author(s) received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. References Aitken, G. (1984). Vocal jazz techniques. Jazz Educators Journal, 17(1), Aitken, G. (1985). Individual miking. Jazz Educators Journal, 17(3), American Choral Directors Association. (n.d.). US & international publisher list. Retrieved from Publisherlist Baker, B. (2010). Successful steps to scat singing. Florida Music Director, 63(7), Barr, W. L. (1974). The jazz studies curriculum. National Association of Jazz Education Educator, 7(2), 6 8. Bell, C. L. (2003). Beginning the dialogue: Teachers respond to the national standards in music. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 156, Bunge, G. D. (2004). Tips for choosing jazz literature. Retrieved from Byo, S. J. (1999). Classroom teachers and music specialists perceived ability to implement the national standards for music education. Journal of Research in Music Education, 47(2), Collier, G. (1994). Jazz education in America. Jazz Changes, 1(1), Cooper, G. A. (1992). A multidimensional instructional approach for the solo jazz singer. Dissertation Abstracts International, 53(05), 1438A. (UMI No ) Cruse, S. R. (1999). The status of vocal jazz ensembles in Texas high schools and the impact of vocal jazz instruction on the overall program. Dissertation Abstracts International, 60(05), 1383A. (UMI No ) Elliott, D. J. (1986). Jazz education as aesthetic education. Journal of Aesthetic Education, 20(1), Fisher, L. (1988). How important are jazz performing groups in your school? In C. T. Brown (Ed.), Jazz research papers (pp ). Manhattan, KS: International Association of Jazz Educators. Flack, M.A. (2004). The effectiveness of Aebersold play-along recordings for gaining proficiency in jazz improvisation. (Doctoral dissertation). Retrieved from edu/uhtbin/catkey/ Gonzo, C. (1973). Research in choral music: A persepective. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 33, Grant, J. W., & Norris, C. (1998). Choral music education: A survey of research Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 135, Greennagel, D. J. (1996). Jazz vocal in jazz education: A conversation with Larry Lapin. In L. Fisher (Ed.), Jazz research papers (pp ). Manhattan, KS: International Association of Jazz Educators. Gridley, M. C. (2008). Jazz styles: History and analysis (10th ed.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall. Heil, L. T. (2005). The effects of two vocal jazz improvisation methods on high school choir students attitudes

10 Baker 63 and performance achievement. Dissertation Abstracts International, 67(10), 3341A. (UMI No ) Herzig, M. (1998). Looking at the past, present, and future of jazz education: An interview with David Baker, September In L. Fisher (Ed.), Jazz research proceedings yearbook (pp ). Manhattan, KS: International Association of Jazz Educators. Hylton, J. (1983). A survey of choral education research: Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 76, International Association for Jazz Education. (2007) : IAJE educational jazz festival directory. Jazz Education Journal, 40(2 3), Israels, C. (1990). Putting chord symbols in their proper perspective: Notation is only a code. In C. T. Brown (Ed.), Jazz research papers (pp ). Manhattan, KS: International Association of Jazz Educators. Jazz education guide. ( ). JazzTimes, pp Retrieved from Knobloch, V. (1985). A comparison of show choirs and vocal jazz in Wisconsin elementary and high schools and midwest universities and colleges. In C. T. Brown (Ed.), Jazz research papers (pp ). Manhattan, KS: International Association of Jazz Educators. Knox, D. C. (1996). The status of high school jazz programs in Alabama. In L. Fisher (Ed.), Jazz Research Papers (pp ). Manhattan, KS: International Association of Jazz Educators. Lehman, P. R. (1995). The national standards for music education: Meeting the challenges. Quarterly Journal of Music Teaching and Learning, 6(2), Madura, P. D. (1996). Relationships among vocal jazz improvisation achievement, jazz theory, knowledge, imitative ability, musical experience, creativity, and gender. Journal of Research in Music Education, 44(3), MENC: The National Association for Music Education. (1994). National standards for music eduation. Retrieved from Murphy, D. K. (1993). Preparing jazz performance majors to teach in the studio. Update: Applications of Research in Music Education, 11(2), Payne, J. R. (1973). Jazz education in the secondary schools of Louisiana, implications of teacher education. Dissertation Abstracts International, 34(06), 3038A. (UMI No ) Regin, J. E. (2003). Toward a more comprehensive textbook on choral jazz arranging. San Jose, CA: San Jose State University. Roothaan, J. P. (1999). Perspectives on teaching jazz piano comping in the college music program with sample instructional units. Dissertation Abstracts International, 60(11), 3947A. (UMI No ) Rose, R. (1985). Walking bass lines. In C. T. Brown (Ed.), Jazz research papers (pp ). Manhattan, KS: International Association of Jazz Educators. Schwartz, D. (1979). Standardization of vocal jazz articulations and inflections. The Choral Journal, 20(4), Silvera-Jenson, J. (2005). A comparison of stylistic, technical, and pedagogical perspectives in vocal instruction among classical and jazz voice teachers. Dissertation Abstracts International, 66(12), 4237A. (UMI ) Singh, V. (2008). Considering musical theater and vocal jazz as integral parts of the choral program: Part 2. Developing appropriate vocal jazz style. In M. Holt & J. Jordan (Eds.), The school choral program (pp ). Chicago, IL: GIA. Smalley, J. (1972). A simplified guide to writing and arranging songs for swing choirs, show choirs, and small instrumental groups. Beverly Hills, CA: First Place Music. Ward-Steinman, P. M. (2007). Confidence in teaching improvisation according to the K-12 achievement standards: Surveys of vocal jazz workshop participants and undergraduates. Bulletin for the Council of Research in Music Education, 172, Ward-Steinman, P. M. (2008). Vocal improvisation and creative thinking by Australian and American university jazz singers. Journal of Research in Music Education, 56(1), Wehr-Flowers, E. (2006). Differences between male and female students confidence, anxiety, and attitude toward learning jazz improvisation. Journal of Research in Music Education, 54(4), White, J. P. (1982). Significant developments in choral music education in higher education between Journal of Research in Music Education, 30(2), Zegree, S. (2002). The complete guide to teaching vocal jazz. Dayton, OH: Heritage Music Press.