CITIZENS POLICE REVIEW BOARD. Robert W. Votaw, Jr. Vice Chair. J. Blair Sanders CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 2200 SECOND STREET

Transcription

1 Luther G. Young, Jr Erma Boyd- Dorsey Vacant Shelly Dusek Chair Robert W. Votaw, Jr. Vice Chair J. Blair Sanders Daniel Bevarly James W. Klingensmith Vacant CALL TO ORDER (5:34) CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 2200 SECOND STREET Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America (5:35) Roll Call (5:35) Oath of Office Vice Chair Votaw led the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America. Absent: Shelly Dusek, Chair; Luther G. Young, Jr., Board Member. None. MINUTES 1. Minutes of October 10, 2017 Approved. One correction. Page 7. Mr. Bevarly salutation was corrected. (See 5:36 p.m.) OLD BUSINESS NEW BUSINESS/APPEARANCES 2. Public Input There was no one present to be heard. 1

2 NON-MANDATORY REVIEW BY BOARD 3. Case No. IA a.) 9.1 General Rules of Conduct Section II (A) (45) Arrest, Search & Seizure b.) 9.1 General Rules of Conduct Section II (A) (2) Obedience to laws, rules, ordinances, and department directives c.) 24.2 Discriminatory Profiling Section I Definitions (A) Bias-Based / Racial Profiling d.) General Rules of Conduct Section II (A) (44) Treatment of Persons in Custody) Approved to hear a full review of the case. (See 6:02 p.m.) Charles Taylor Philip Youngblood (a. & b.) Emilia Santos (a. & c.) Adam Jobbers-Miller (a. & d.) a.) Not sustained b.) Unfounded c.) Unfounded d.) Unfounded 2

3 NON-MANDATORY REVIEW BY BOARD 4. Case No. Prelim Elicienne Bonne (See 6:05 p.m.) Bensly Melidor 5. Case No. Prelim Harold Carter Approved to hear a full review of the case. (See 6:17 p.m.) Tyler Williams 3

4 6. Case No. Prelim George Spyrnal (See 6:27 p.m.) Evan Saboe 7. Case No. Admin a.) 9.1 General Rules of Conduct Section II (A) (21) Conduct Toward the Public b.) 24.2 Discriminatory Profiling Section I (A) Bias-Based/Racial Profiling c.) 9.1 General Rules of Conduct Section VI (L) Harassment (See 6:41 p.m.) Complainants: Charles Davis Dynmond Jackson Jari Sanders (a. & b. & c.) Jason Jackson (a. & b. & c.) Brandon Birch (a.) a.) Sustained - Counseling b.) Unfounded c.) Unfounded 4

5 8. Case No. Admin General Rules of Conduct Section II (9) Standard of Conduct Michael Appel (See 6:47 p.m.) Enrico Doro Unfounded 9. Case No. Admin a.) 9.1 General Rules of Conduct Section II (A)(9) Standard of Conduct b.) 9.1 General Rules of Conduct Section II (A) (44) Treatment of Persons in Custody c.) 9.1 General Rules of Conduct Section II (A) (21) Conduct Toward the Public d.) 9.1 General Rules of Conduct Section II (A) (8) Performance of Duty (See 6:51 p.m.) Rfeal Wigfals Cierra Carter (a. & b.) Jacquelyn Garrett (c. & d.) Unfounded 5

6 10. Case No. Admin a.) 9.1 General Rules of Conduct Section III General Conduct on Duty (M) Misrepresentation or Falsification b.) 20.9 Preliminary Investigations Section I Preliminary Investigation Procedures (B) (8) (See 6:54 p.m.) Emmett Caldwell David Sanchez (a. & b.) Amberlee Williams (a.) a.) Unfounded b.) Not Sustained 11. Case No. Prelim Christopher Sosa (See 6:56 p.m.) Unknown 6

7 12. Case No. Prelim Mamberto Real (See 7:01 p.m.) Not Applicable 13. Case No. Prelim Johnny Streets (See 7:04 p.m.) Mitchell Daniels 7

8 14. Case No. Prelim Jonathan Spellman (See 7:07 p.m.) Jacquelyn Garrett 15. Case No. Prelim Bill Neil (See 7:10 p.m.) None 16. Case No. Prelim Tony Williams (See 7:12 p.m.) Kelly Witt 8

9 17. Case No. Admin a.) 9.1 General Rules of Conduct Section II (A) (21) Conduct Toward the Public b.) 25.3 Mobile/Video Audio Recording Equipment Section V Citizens Contacts and Privacy Concerns(F) (See 7:13 p.m.) Rachel Cervantes Michael Perry a.) Unfounded b.) Other (Policy Failure) 18. Case No. Prelim Shanice Stewart (See 7:27 p.m.) Brandon Birch Officer Ramos 9

10 19. Case No. Admin a.) 9.1 General Rules of Conduct Section II (A) (21) Conduct Toward the Public Approved to hear a full review of the case. (See 7:35 p.m.) Debbie Jordan Emilia Santos (a.) Sarah Gallegos (a.) a.) Unfounded Officer Ramos 20. Case No. Admin a.) 24.2 Discriminatory Profiling Section I Definitions (A) Bias-Based / Racial Profiling b.) 25.3 Mobile/Video Audio Recording Equipment Section V Citizens Contacts and Privacy Concerns(F) (See 7:45 p.m.) Tarique Wilson Nichole Greene a.) Unfounded b.) Exonerated Officer Ramos 10

11 PRESENTATION OF NEW INQUIRIES 21. Report on complaints received since October 10, 2017 No complaints had been received since the last meeting (See 7:53 p.m.) OTHER BUSINESS 22. Announce next meeting will be held on January 9, A motion was not made. (See 7:54 p.m.) Adjourned: 7:54 o clock p.m. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Citizens Police Review Board with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing, he or she will need a record of the proceedings, and that, for such purpose, he or she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. Special Requirements: If you require special aid or services as addressed in the Americans with Disabilities Act, please contact the City Clerk s Office at (239) or for the hearing impaired, TDD telephone number (239)