FINAL MINUTES MONTEREY COUNTY ASSESSMENT APPEALS BOARD FRIDAY, AUGUST 15, W. Alisal St., 1 st Floor, Salinas, CA :00 A.M.

Transcription

1 FINAL MINUTES MONTEREY COUNTY ASSESSMENT APPEALS BOARD FRIDAY, AUGUST 15, W. Alisal St., 1 st Floor, Salinas, CA :00 A.M. 0. Pledge of Allegiance 1. Roll Call Russ Jeffries, Chair; Chris Daniel, Vice Chair; Glen Alder, Board Member Wendy Strimling, Sr. Deputy County Counsel, Board Counsel Iracema Lopez, Board Clerk to the Gail T. Borkowski, Clerk of the Board 2. Public Comment Period: There were no public comments. 3. Consent Calendar - Approve stipulations: These matters are for routine administrative actions for approval by a single vote. Alder, the Board unanimously approved the stipulation for application A Daniel, the Board unanimously approved the addition of applications received after the posting of today s agenda as referenced below. Alder, the Board unanimously removed from today s agenda and postponed the hearing on application A to September 19, Alder, the Board unanimously approved to remove application A from today s agenda. Alder, the Board unanimously accepted and approved the stipulations below, including the stipulations received after the posting of the agenda: A W2005/Fargo Hotels (Pool C) Realty, LP / APN A W2005/Fargo Hotels (Pool C) Realty, LP / APN

2 Agenda August 15, A W2005/Fargo Hotels (Pool C) Realty, LP / APN A W2005/Fargo Hotels (Pool C) Realty, LP / APN A Ranchland Company, LLC / APN A Daniel Feldman / APN A Monterey Newspaper Partnership dba Media News Group / APN REMOVED A Hugh P. Brady / APN A Beatrice & Raymond B. Perez / APN A John R. Hain, TR ET AL / APN A John R. Hain, TR ET AL / APN A Karen B. Letendre / APN A Samuel A. & Linda A. Lucido / APN A Jae J. Kim / APN A Henry P. Brown / APN A Dirk & Maria Giannini / APN A Richard S. Griffith / APN A Stephen H. Luk / APN A Kimberly A. Wright / APN A David Nemiroff & Karen L. Monahan / APN REMOVED A Steiny Properties, LP / APN A Robert M. Hays / APN A Michael L. Rosendin, Tr ETAL / APN A Rick W. Richardson / APN A Gloria Ledesma / APN A Michael A. Plainse / APN A David V. Rodriguez / APN *Stipulations Received after the Posting of the Agenda: A Steven Mickel / APN #6 4. Consent Calendar - Approve withdrawals: These matters are for routine administrative actions for approval by a single vote. Alder, the Board unanimously approved the addition of applications received after the posting of today s agenda as referenced below. Daniel, the Board unanimously accepted and approved the withdrawals below, including the withdrawals received after the posting of the agenda: A Monarch Pines Homeowners Association, Inc. / APN A Jeffrey D. Brody / APN A Victoria Land c/o Jack in the Box / APN A Scott M. Gibson / APN A Daniel F. Bellem / APN

3 Agenda August 15, A John B. Howard / APN A WFC Holdings Corporation / APN A WFC Holdings Corporation / APN A Shirley Pratt / APN A Jean M. Fort / APN A Flocchini Associates, LLC / APN A TRU 2005 RE I, LLC / APN A Bahman & Farangis Ahmadi / APN A CVS/Longs Drug Stores #9320 / APN A CVS/Longs Drug Stores #9802 / APN A Bakul C. & Jayshri B. Panchal / APN A Cemex Inc. / APN A Foster Dairy Farms / APN A Karen Hargrove / APN Withdrawals Received after the Posting of the Agenda: A First States Investors 5000A, LLC / APN #23 A Sharon M. Damon / APN #30 A Laama LLC / APN #40 A Geoffrey O Donoghue / APN #43 A Oak Park Homes, LLC / APN #58 A Nina Von Saltza Hare / APN #67 A Sabu M. Shake Jr. / APN #68 5. Other Board Matters a. Consider and approve meeting schedule for By consensus the Board continued consideration of the 2015 meeting dates to September 19, d b Applications Status Update. The Clerk of the Board provided a Status Report on Outstanding 2012 Applications to the as requested. The Board discussed and reviewed the report. No further action was taken. c. New Application The did not discuss the New 2015 proposed application form. Timeliness Determination d. A Helen Danhakl / APN Applicant Helen Danhakl was sworn. Gregg McFarlane, Supervising Appraiser and Nick Ortega, Appraiser II were sworn. Ms. Danhakl addressed the Board. Gregg McFarlane and Nick Ortega addressed the Board on behalf of the Assessor s office.

4 Agenda August 15, Alder, the Board unanimously postponed the timeliness hearing on application A to September 19, Request for Extension and Waiver e. A Oyster Point Inn II, LLC / APN Alder, the Board unanimously accepted the Agreement for Extension and Waiver of Rights for application A f. A Janak Bansal / APN Alder, the Board unanimously denied the approval of the Agreement for Extension and Waiver of Rights and postponed the hearing on application A to September 19, 2014; the Board advised no additional postponement will be granted unless an Agreement for Indefinite Waiver and Extension is submitted and approved. g. A Helen M. Hughes / APN Alder, the Board unanimously accepted the Agreement for Extension and Waiver of Rights for application A and postponed the hearing to October 17, A Steven Mickel / APN BOARD ACTION: Application stipulated. See item 3 for action. 7. A Stephanie L. Boucher / APN A to September 19, A Home Depot USA, Inc. / APN Alder, the Board unanimously accepted the Agreement of Extension and Waiver for application A , subject to receipt of the original signed waiver. A to September 19, A Diana Y. Jiang / APN A to September 19, 2014.

5 Agenda August 15, A K & G Services, LLC / APN A to September 19, A East Romie Lane, LLC c/o Windsor Gardens Rehab Care Center / APN A to September 19, A Marriott Intl. / APN A to September 19, A A Ismael Magana / APN Ismael Magana / APN s A and A to September 19, A Salinas Valley Cooling, LLC / APN Alder, the Board unanimously accepted the Agreement for Extension and Waiver of Rights for application A , subject to receipt of the original signed waiver. A to September 19, A Steinbeck Early Morning Cooling / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously accepted the Agreement for Extension and Waiver of Rights, subject to receipt of the original signed waiver and postponed the hearing on application A to September 19, A Michael Azzopardi / APN Alder, the Board unanimously accepted the Agreement for Extension and Waiver of Rights, subject to receipt of the original signed waiver and postponed the hearing on application A to September 19, 2014.

6 Agenda August 15, A Stratham Homes c/o Jack in the Box / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously accepted the Agreement for Extension and Waiver of Rights, subject to receipt of the original signed waiver and postponed the hearing on application A to September 19, A California Partnership/Denny s 175 / APN Alder, the Board unanimously accepted the Agreement for Extension and Waiver of Rights, subject to receipt of the original signed waiver and postponed the hearing on application A A Recreation Equipment, Inc. / APN A to September 19, A A A A A A A A Save Mart Store #772 / APN Save Mart Store #772 / APN Save Mart Store #738 / APN Save Mart Store #724 / APN Save Mart Store #703 / APN Save Mart Store #405 / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously denied applications A , A , A , A , A and A due to lack of appearance. Save Mart Store #747 / APN Save Mart Store #746 / APN A and A to September 19, 2014, and noted that a new Agent s Authorization is needed for A Comcast IP Phone II, LLC / APN Alder, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of appearance. 22. A Comcast Spotlight Inc. / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of appearance.

7 Agenda August 15, A First States Investors 5000A, LLC / APN A Prieto Investments Company c/o Michael Prieto / APN A to September 19, A A A Mary Ann & Michael Prieto / APN Mary Ann & Michael Prieto / APN Mary Ann & Michael Prieto / APN s A through A to September 19, A Prieto Investments Company c/o Michael Prieto / APN A to September 19, A BHRIJ Hospitality, LLC / APN A to September 19, A DF/Hilltop, LLC / APN A to September 19, A Grover T. Wickersham / APN A to September 19, A Sharon M. Damon / APN A Sharon M. Damon / APN A to September 19, 2014.

8 Agenda August 15, A Robert Axley / APN A to September 19, A Carlson Bazan / APN A to September 19, A Ronald Berti / APN A to September 19, A Capra 2011 Family Trust / APN A to September 19, A Johnathan Farahmand / APN A to September 19, A Albert Flores / APN A to September 19, A William Hutchinson / APN A to September 19, A Jae Kim / APN A to September 19, A Laama LLC / APN

9 Agenda August 15, A Mary McDonnell / APN A to September 19, A George Nunes / APN A to September 19, A Geoffrey O. Donoghue / APN A Angelantonio Padilla / APN A to September 19, A Gary W. Purcell / APN A to September 19, A Jorge Rocha / APN A to September 19, A Edward M. Schellinck / APN Alder, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of appearance. 48. A Bruce H. Williamson Trust etal / APN A to September 19, A A Heritage-Titan Propane c/o Amerigas Propane LP / APN Heritage-Titan Propane c/o Amerigas Propane LP / APN s A and A to September 19, 2014.

10 Agenda August 15, A Great Valley Holdings, LLC / APN Alder, the Board unanimously accepted the Agreement for Extension and Waiver of Rights, subject to receipt of the original signed waiver and postponed the hearing on application A to November 21, A Richard S. Griffith / APN A to September 19, A Howard M. & Robin R. Reisman / APN A to September 19, A Five Mandeville Court, LLC / APN A to September 19, A A Deubel Enterprises LP / APN Deubel Enterprises LP / APN s A and A to September 19, A Roger L. Peirce / APN A to September 19, A Geoffrey G. Xie / APN A to September 19, A Tom & Eva Di Maggio / APN A to September 19, A Oak Park Homes LLC / APN

11 Agenda August 15, A The 300 LLC / APN A to September 19, A Howard Birnberg / APN A to September 19, A A G6 Hospitality LLC dba Motel 6 #1370 / APN G6 Hospitality LLC dba Motel 6 #1370 / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously scheduled consideration of acceptance of the Agreement for Indefinite Extension and Waiver and postponed the hearing on applications A and A to September 19, A Joanne M. May / APN A to September 19, A Rancho Sierra Inc. / APN A to October 17, A Kenneth L. & Susan Rae Church / APN A to September 19, A Joyce & Nashwan Hamza / APN A to September 19, A A G6 Hospitality LLC dba Motel 6 # 1370 / APN G6 Hospitality LLc dba Motel 6 #1370 / APN Alder, the Board unanimously accepted the Agreement for Extension and Waiver of Rights, subject to receipt of the original signed waiver and postponed the hearing on applications A and A to September 19, 2014.

12 Agenda August 15, A Nina Von Salta Hare / APN A Sabu M. Shake Jr. / APN A Michael J.P Kelly. / APN A to September 19, A Deubel Enterprises LP / APN A to September 19, A Michelle E. Uquillas / APN A to September 19, A Lew K. Borzini / APN A to September 19, A Sabino Godoy / APN A to September 19, Closed Session No Closed Session was held. 75. Adjournment to September 19, 2014