FINAL ACTION MINUTES MONTEREY COUNTY ASSESSMENT APPEALS BOARD FRIDAY, MAY 16, W. Alisal St., 1 st Floor, Salinas, CA :00 A.M.

Transcription

1 FINAL ACTION MINUTES MONTEREY COUNTY ASSESSMENT APPEALS BOARD FRIDAY, MAY 16, W. Alisal St., 1 st Floor, Salinas, CA :00 A.M. The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Chair Jeffries. 1. Roll Call: Russ Jeffries, Chair; Chris Daniel, Vice Chair; Glen Alder, Board Member Wendy Strimling, Sr. Deputy County Counsel, Board Counsel Gail T. Borkowski, Clerk of the Board 2. Public Comment Period: There were no public comments. 3. Consent Calendar - Approve stipulations: Alder, the Board, unanimously, approved adding the following application to the agenda as item 44.1: A Salinas Newspapers Inc. / APN Alder, the Board, unanimously, moved the following items for action under stipulations: A Paul Ingemanson APN #17 A Steven M. & Emma C. Vetter Trust APN #26 A Jody L. & Jeremy Whitelock APN #31 A Christopher W. & Dimitra M. Hubbard APN #40 A Reynaldo G. & Thelma M. Olalia APN #49 A Doris J. Tolf APN #56 A Albert L. & Edite C. Flores APN #67 A Ramon M. & Juana O. Gomez APN #69 A Hearst-Argyle Stations Inc. APN #110 Daniel, the Board, unanimously, accepted and approved stipulations, including those stipulations moved and added to the agenda as referenced above and below:

2 Minutes May 16, A Leslie A. & Penny A. Bard / APN A LV44 II Limited Partnership / APN A Sharene Hamrock Virnig TR / APN A Ronald E. & Robin L. Steudler TR / APN A Walter Dean Weidner / APN A Kent J. Bransford / APN A Todd & Kelly Stratton / APN A Michael J. & Jennifer K. Vanoli / APN A Michael Nesmith & Victoria Kennedy / APN A Douglas & Fana Oldfield / APN A Larry E. Fryman, Trustee / APN A John & Alessandra Rice / APN A Don Marlette / APN A John L. & Maureen E. Rombeau / APN A Richard E. & Sharlene Thum / APN A Roy Kaminske / APN A Cary H. & Rae J. Gota Trustees / APN A William B. & Delia P. Harder / APN A Delinda G. Robinson / APN A Don Ayres / APN A Johnathan Farahmand / APN A Patricia Horsley / APN A Kathryn H. Allan / APN A Michel De LaTour & Grace E. Doherty TRS / APN A Darlene Whetstine / APN A Mary Beach Boscoe / APN A Michael J.P. & Linda L. Kelly / APN A Paul & Jacqueline Goodard Co-TRS / APN A Stephannie Mower / APN A David S. Shields / APN A Donna J. Shore / APN A FFDA Properties LLC % Derek Hayashi / APN A Hearst-Argyle Stations, Inc. / APN A Dale C. & Christine C. Coke TRS TR / APN A Dale C. & Christine C. Coke TRS TR / APN A Haley F. Matthew / APN A William H. Noel 2011 Irrevocable Trust / APN *A George L. Schroeder TR / APN * See separate action A J.D. II & Judy A. Williamson / APN A Richard Cava / APN A Kent J. Bransford / APN *Member Daniel recused himself and left the room regarding application A George L. Schroeder TR / APN , because the applicant relied on his appraisal for the stipulation.

3 Minutes May 16, * Jeffries, with Member Daniel being recused, the Board accepted and approved the stipulation for application A (Member Daniel Recused) 4. Consent Calendar - Approve withdrawals: These matters are for routine administrative actions for approval by a single vote. Daniel, the Board, unanimously, moved the following items for action under withdrawals: A Sandra Flores / APN (# 11) A John P. & Lilian J. Norton / (#22) A KLA Monterey Leasehold, LLC / APN (#25) A Michael D. Ginsberg & Alan J. Harlan TRS / APN (#30) A Lesley Hambleden / APN (#38) A Patricio Toledo / APN (#50) A C. Winston / APN (#53) A Carmen De La Torre / APN (#63) A Samuel & Paula Downing / APN (#64) A John Endriz / APN (#65) A Barry & Susan Giles / APN (#68) A Joan Holman / APN (#70) A Ismael Magana / APN (#72) A Shirley Pratt / APN (#74) A Paul Soares / APN (#77) A Jay R. & Allene Williams / APN (#78) A Thomas & Diane Stone / APN (#79) A Donald & Mary K. Orosco / APN (#84) A Seaside City Center Project, LLC / APN (#86) A Seaside City Center Project, LLC / APN (#86) A Seaside City Center Project, LLC / APN (#86) A Seaside City Center Project, LLC / APN (#86) A Seaside City Center Project, LLC / APN (#86) A Michael Kassner / APN (#87) A Monterey Downtown TL LLC / APN (#88) A Platinum Energy/Northwest Dealer/David Delrahim / APN (#102) A Laura L. Severino / APN (#111) Daniel, the Board, unanimously, accepted and approved withdrawals, including those withdrawals moved to the agenda as referenced above and below: A Monterey Peninsula Land Partners, LLC / APN A Carmel Bay LLC / APN A Horace C. & Mary T. Clabo / APN A Richard C. Freese & Karen Kreiger / APN A STG Firestone LLC / APN

4 Minutes May 16, A Riggs Property LP / APN A P & O Cold Logistics LLC / APN A Pacifica Host Hotels / APN A J. Jerrold Applegarth / APN A J. Jerrold Applegarth / APN A J. Jerrold Applegarth / APN A J. Jerrold Applegarth / APN A Paul W. Rummel / APN A John Maguire, Trustee for Maguire Family Trust / APN Other Board Matters a. Approve meeting minutes of April 25, BOARD ACTION: By consensus the Board continued approval of the minutes of April 25, 2014 to July 14, d Timeliness Determination b. A Wente Bros. / APN A Wente Bros. / APN A Wente Bros. / APN Authorized Agent Travis Carlson, for the applicant Wente Brothers, was sworn. Supervising Appraiser Gregg MacFarlane was sworn on behalf of the Assessor s office. Travis Carlson testified on behalf of the Applicant. Gregg MacFarlane testified on behalf of the Assessor. The following exhibits were submitted and marked for identification: Assessor s Exhibit A Copies of applications A , A and A Alder, the Board unanimously accepted withdrawal of applicant s request for timeliness determination for application A Daniel, the Board unanimously accepted withdrawal of applicant s request for timeliness determination for application A Alder, the Board unanimously accepted withdrawal of applicant s request for timeliness determination for application A

5 Minutes May 16, Request for Extension and Waiver c. A Alicia Curci / APN Alder, the Board unanimously accepted the Agreement for Extension and Waiver of Rights for application A Alder, the Board unanimously postponed the hearing on application A to October 17, A A A A A A W2005/Fargo Hotels (Pool C) Realty / APN W2005/Fargo Hotels (Pool C) Realty / APN W2005/Fargo Hotels (Pool C) Realty / APN W2005/Fargo Hotels (Pool C) Realty / APN W2005/Fargo Hotels (Pool C) Realty / APN W2005/Fargo Hotels (Pool C) Realty / APN Alder, the Board unanimously accepted the Extension and Waiver of Rights, Subject to receipt of the original signed waiver. Alder, the Board unanimously postponed the hearing on applications A , A , A , A and A to July 14, A Margaret Healy / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of 8. A DF/Hill Top, LLC / APN to July 14, A Woodman Investment Company, a General Partnership / APN to July 14, 2014.

6 Minutes May 16, A A Motel 6 Operating, LP #639 / APN Motel 6 Operating, LP #1370 / APN Alder, the Board unanimously accepted the Agreement for Extension and Waiver of Rights for applications A and A BOARD ACTION: Upon the motion on Member Alder, seconded by Member Daniel, the Board unanimously postponed the hearing on applications A and A to July 14, A Sandra A. Flores / APN A Michelle E. Uquillas / APN to July 14, A Green Desert Oil, LLC / APN to July 14, A Kenneth Steers / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of 15. A CEC Entertainment Inc. / APN to July 14, A A Katherine S. Clark / APN Katherine S. Clark / APN Alder, the Board unanimously postponed the hearing on applications A and A to July 14, A Paul L. Ingemanson / APN BOARD ACTION: Application stipulated. See items 3 for action.

7 Minutes May 16, A Steven Mickel / APN to July 14, A Ranchland Company, LLC / APN to July 14, A Monarch Pines Homeowners Association, Inc. / APN to July 14, A Oyster Point Inn II LLC / APN to August 15, A John P. & Lillian J. Norton / APN BOARD ACTION: Applicant withdrawn. See item 4 for action. 23. A Stephanie L. Boucher / APN to July 14, A Home Depot USA, Inc. / APN to July 14, A KLA Monterey Leasehold, LLC / APN BOARD ACTION: Item withdrawn. See item 4 for action. 26. A Steven M. Vetter / APN BOARD ACTION: Application stipulated. See item 3 for action. 27. A Phillip J. Ward / APN Alder, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of

8 Minutes May 16, A Surflet, LLC / APN to July 14, A Mena H. Campise & James R. Hogan / APN to July 14, A Santa Lucia Subtrust, Michael D. Ginsberg, Alan Harlan, Trustees / APN A Jody L. Whitelock / APN BOARD ACTION: Application stipulated. See item 3 for action. 32. A K & G Services, LLC / APN to July 14, A A A A Muller-Ryan, LLC / APN Muller-Ryan, LLC / APN Muller-Ryan, LLC / APN Muller-Ryan, LLC / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously postponed the hearing on applications A through A to July 14, 2014, directed the Clerk to request a valid Agent s Authorization be submitted. 34. A Martin Slanina / APN to July 14, A Zhizhong Zhang / APN to July 14, A David C. & Wanda L. Brown / APN to July 14, 2014.

9 Minutes May 16, A East Romie Lane, LLC c/o Windsor Gardens Rehab Care Center/APN to July 14, A Lesley Hambleden (Holding Field Run, LLC) / APN A Elisa M. Oreggia / APN Alder, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of 40. A Christopher W. & Dimitra M. Hubbard / APN BOARD ACTION: Application stipulated. See item 3 for action. 41. A Larry M. Hampson / APN Alder, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of 42. A David A. Osorio / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of 43. A Ronald W. & Patricia K. Eastman / APN Authorized Agent Brian Finnegan and Applicant Ronald Eastman, were sworn. The Applicant did not request Findings of Fact. Keith Hayes, Realty Appraiser II gave his presentation on behalf of Assessor. The following exhibits were submitted and marked for identification: Assessor s Exhibit A Subject: 21 Vasquest Trail photos & sales adjustment form (5 pages) Assessor s Exhibit B Distance and Travel Time calculated by Google Maps (1 page) Brian Finnegan, Agent and Ron Eastman, Applicant gave their presentation. The Following exhibits were submitted and marked for identification: Applicant s Exhibit 1 Property Tax Appeal #

10 Minutes May 16, Parcel # Address: 21 Vasquez Trail, Carmel, CA Both parties concluded their presentations and cross-examination. The Board took application A under submission. Closed Session was held and the Board reported out after Closed Session on this item. Alder, the Board found the value for application A , as of January 1, 2012, to be $4,500, A Janak Bansal / APN to July 14, A Salinas Newspapers / APN BOARD ACTION: Application stipulated. See item 3 for action. 45. A Kim Young / APN to July 14, A Nicholas Azcona / APN to July 14, A Marvin Iannone / APN to July 14, A Santos Jaramillo / APN to July 14, A Reynaldo Olalia / APN BOARD ACTION: Application stipulated. See item 3 for action.

11 Minutes May 16, A Patricio Toledo / APN A Patarapol Waranimman / APN to July 14, A Loretta Warren / APN to July 14, A C. Winston / APN A Carl Rudiger / APN to July 14, A David Scanlon / APN to July 14, A Doris Tolf / APN BOARD ACTION: Application stipulated. See item 3 for action. 57. A Angelo V., Jr. & Leslie E. Anastasia / APN to July 14, A Carlos Bazan / APN to July 14, A Bryan-Heritage Limited Partnership / APN to July 14, 2014.

12 Minutes May 16, A Jack Chestnut / APN to July 14, A Jay L. Cooke, TR / APN to July 14, A Phillip Crispell / APN to July 14, A Carmen De La Torre / APN A Samuel Downing / APN A John Endriz / APN A Joe English /APN to July 14, A Albert Flores / APN BOARD ACTION: Application stipulated. See item 3 for action. 68. A Barry Giles / APN A Ramon Gomez / APN BOARD ACTION: Application stipulated. See item 3 for action. 70. A Joan Holman / APN

13 Minutes May 16, A Catherine Lambetecchio / APN to July 14, A A A Ismael Magana / APN Ismael Magana / APN and A to July 14, Ismael Magana / APN BOARD ACTION: Applications withdrawn. See item 4 for action. 73. A Mary McDonnell / APN to July 14, A Shirley Pratt / APN A Heather Rose / APN to July 14, A E. Schulz / APN to July 14, A Paul Soares / APN A Jay R. & Allene Williams / APN A Thomas Stone / APN A Thomas P. & Ann K. Bradley / APN to July 14, 2014.

14 Minutes May 16, A Ernest M. & Gunde D. Posey, Trustees / APN to July 14, A Susan L. Skidmore, Trustee of the Incline Trust-1990 / APN to July 14, A Thomas A. Gray / APN to July 14, A Donald & Mary K. Orosco / APN A DBO Development No. 30, LLC / APN to July 14, A A A A A Seaside City Center Project, LLC / APN Seaside City Center Project, LLC / APN Seaside City Center Project, LLC / APN Seaside City Center Project, LLC / APN Seaside City Center Project, LLC / APN BOARD ACTION: Applications withdrawn. See item 4 for actions. 87. A Michael E. Kassner / APN A Monterey Downtown TL LLC / APN A Monterey Newspaper Partnership DBA Media News Group / APN to July 14, 2014.

15 Minutes May 16, A Abbott Street Investments LLC / APN A Salinas Valley Cooling LLC / APN to July 14, A Steinbeck Early Morning Cooling / APN to July 14, A Michael Azzopardi / APN to July 14, A Enea Properties Company LLC / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of 95. A Syufy Enterprises / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of 96. A Victoria Land c/o Jack in the Box / APN to July 14, A Stratham Homes c/o Jack in the Box / APN to July 14, A Herman Shine / APN to July 14, 2014.

16 Minutes May 16, A California Partnership/Denny s 175 / APN to July 14, A The Schomac Group, Inc. / APN Alder, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of 101. A Robert G. Moskowitz / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of 102. A Platinum Energy/North West Dealer/David Delrahim / APN A A A A A A A A A A A A A Save Mart Store #772 / APN Save Mart Store #772 / APN Save Mart Store #747 / APN Save Mart Store #746 / APN Save Mart Store #738 / APN Save Mart Store #724 / APN Save Mart Store #703 / APN Save Mart Store #405 / APN Alder, the Board unanimously postponed the hearing on applications A through A to July 14, Inc. & Southland Corporation / APN Inc. & Southland Corporation / APN Inc. & Southland Corporation / APN Inc. & Southland Corporation / APN Inc. & Southland Corporation / APN Alder, the Board unanimously postponed the hearing on applications A through A to July 14, 2014.

17 Minutes May 16, A Comcast of CA IX Inc. / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of Daniel, the Board unanimously reconsidered the denial of application A to July 14, A Comcast Cable Holdings, LLC / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously denied application A due to lack of Daniel, the Board unanimously reconsidered the denial of application to July 14, A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A Comcast IP Phone II LLC / APN Comcast IP Phone II LLC / APN Comcast IP Phone II LLC / APN Comcast IP Phone II LLC / APN Comcast IP Phone II LLC / APN Comcast IP Phone II LLC / APN Comcast IP Phone II LLC / APN Comcast IP Phone II LLC / APN Comcast IP Phone II LLC / APN Alder, the Board unanimously postponed the hearing on applications A , A , A , A , A , A , A , A and A to July 14, Comcast of CA IX Inc. / APN Comcast of CA IX Inc. / APN Comcast of CA IX Inc. / APN Comcast of CA IX Inc. / APN Comcast of CA IX Inc. / APN Comcast of CA IX Inc. / APN

18 Minutes May 16, A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A Comcast of CA IX Inc. / APN Comcast of CA IX Inc. / APN Comcast of CA IX Inc. / APN Comcast of CA IX Inc. / APN Alder, the Board unanimously postponed the hearing on applications A through A to July 14, Marina Community Partners LLC / APN Marina Community Partners LLC / APN Marina Community Partners LLC / APN Marina Community Partners LLC / APN Marina Community Partners LLC / APN Marina Community Partners LLC / APN Marina Community Partners LLC / APN Marina Community Partners LLC / APN Marina Community Partners LLC / APN Marina Community Partners LLC / APN Marina Community Partners LLC / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously postponed the hearing on applications A through A to September 19, A Hearst-Argyle Stations Inc. / APN BOARD ACTION: Application stipulated. See item 3 for action A Laura L. Severino / APN A Tunin Family Ltd. Partnership / APN to July 14, A Hugh P. Brady / APN to July 14, A Athas Karahalios / APN

19 Minutes May 16, A Athas Karahalios / APN Daniel, the Board unanimously postponed the hearing on applications A and A to July 14, Closed Session See item 43 for report out of Closed Session Adjournment to July 14, 2014